Critics » Matthew Leyland » Rotten
Matthew Leyland

Matthew Leyland

Agrees with the Tomatometer 79% of the time.

Publications:
BBC , Total Film
Total Reviews:
132

Worst Reviewed Films

Showing 1 - 50 of 131
Previous | Next
Rating T-Meter Title | Year Add Date
1/5 15% The Amateurs (The Moguls) (Dirty Movie) (2005) " A miscalculated mix of sleaze and schmaltz." — BBC
Posted May 6, 2006
1/5 22% The Pink Panther (2006) " As for Martin, no matter how many he times he stumbles, fumbles, burns his balls or mispronounces the word hamburger, he never gets close to making the Clouseau persona his own." — BBC
Posted Mar 14, 2006
2/5 24% The Dilemma (2011) " A film with an identity crisis: an awkward hybrid of comedy and drama that's never sure of which avenue to pursue." — Total Film
Posted Jan 20, 2011
2/5 42% Wild Child (2008) " Shame on Iggy Pop for letting them (ab)use his anarchy-anthem 'Real Wild Child' in a girls'-own flick that is so paltry it makes the recent St Trinians addition look like Picnic At Hanging Rock." — Total Film
Posted Aug 15, 2008
2/5 22% Resident Evil: Extinction (2007) " Scaling dizzy heights of sheer averageness, the third in writer/ producer Paul WS Anderson's stillborn zombie saga is the best - or least worst - yet." — Total Film
Posted Oct 10, 2007
2/5 33% Marigold (2007) " A sari attempt to hybridise Hollywood and Bollywood." — Total Film
Posted Aug 17, 2007
2/5 81% Taxidermia (2006) " Where Hukkle's circle-of-life surrealism had a certain twisted charm, this film's sense of the grotesque is more glum than fun. On the tail of such a promising debut, it can't help feeling like a hiccup." — BBC
Posted Jul 13, 2007
2/5 81% Fong juk (Exiled) (2006) " Saved by set-piece action." — BBC
Posted Jun 15, 2007
2/5 66% Meet the Robinsons (2007) " This is eye candy with a hollow centre." — Total Film
Posted Mar 27, 2007
2/5 33% Duelist (Hyeongsa) (2005) " Duelist turns from playful to precious in the last 30-odd minutes, straggling towards a prancey showdown that's as graceful as all get-out but as cold as the endless falling snow." — BBC
Posted Mar 8, 2007
2/5 51% The Fountain (2006) " First, the good news: The Fountain is only 97 minutes long. Now the bad: that's 97 minutes of rampant metaphysical codswallop." — BBC
Posted Jan 26, 2007
2/5 42% Lives of the Saints (2007) " A bizarre brew of Brit-grit, magic realism and religious allegory." — BBC
Posted Jan 26, 2007
2/5 53% Crime Novel (Romanzo criminale) (2005) " Revenge is a dish served once too often in Romanzo Criminale, an Italian crime epic that runs out of appeal well before it runs out of ammo." — BBC
Posted Nov 11, 2006
2/5 27% Waist Deep (2006) " The worst is saved for last: just when you think the movie has shown the courage of its 'gritty' convictions, it hits you with schmaltz that would shame a Hallmark card." — BBC
Posted Nov 11, 2006
2/5 26% Stay (2005) " A head-scratching thriller..." — BBC
Posted Sep 6, 2006
2/5 44% Angel-A (2005) " The whole film's easy on the eye thanks to the Parisian summer setting, photographed in creamy black and white. If only the romance wasn't so monochrome too..." — BBC
Posted Aug 1, 2006
2/5 12% An American Haunting (2006) " Unoriginal and unrelenting, this gothic ghost story invests too much time in banging doors and billowing drapes and not enough in its characters." — BBC
Posted Jun 3, 2006
2/5 9% When a Stranger Calls (2006) " You know a horror movie's in trouble when the fake scares outweigh the real ones." — BBC
Posted May 16, 2006
2/5 7% Basic Instinct 2 (2006) " A veritable cold shower of a sequel to 1992's softcore spectacular." — BBC
Posted May 6, 2006
2/5 5% The Fog (2005) " Another remake bites the dust." — BBC
Posted Feb 14, 2006
2/5 59% Steamboy (2005) " It may be one of the most expensive anime features ever, but there isn't a wealth of entertainment on offer in Steamboy." — BBC
Posted Dec 6, 2005
2/5 53% Wolf Creek (2005) " The film's preference for female suffering gives it a misogynist undertow that's even more unsettling than the gore." — BBC
Posted Sep 24, 2005
2/5 72% Primer (2004) " One of the most wilfully obscure sci-fi movies ever made, Primer will either blow your mind or drive you out of it." — BBC
Posted Aug 9, 2005
2/5 41% The Heart Is Deceitful Above All Things (2004) " An overwrought and underwhelming study of childhood abuse." — BBC
Posted Jul 12, 2005
2/5 38% I Am David (2004) " Short, simple and inoffensive, it's well suited to family viewing, albeit on the gogglebox one Sunday teatime rather than the big screen." — BBC
Posted Nov 9, 2004
2/5 33% Imagining Argentina (2004) " Well-intentioned but awkwardly executed." — BBC
Posted Apr 23, 2004
2/5 17% The Perfect Score (2004) " What could, and should, have been as fun and daring as skipping school turns out to be as dull as a two-hour detention." — BBC
Posted Mar 16, 2004
2/5 56% Looney Tunes: Back in Action (2003) " Bursts with energy but not inspiration." — BBC
Posted Feb 3, 2004
2/5 38% Brother Bear (2003) " Run-of-the-mill fare like this only gives more power to the pixel-pushers." — BBC
Posted Dec 2, 2003
3/5 84% Contagion (2011) " A level-headed take on a topic that's often an excuse for madness and melodrama." — Total Film
Posted Oct 19, 2011
3/5 75% The Adventures of Tintin (2011) " Like the 3D, an adventure that's serviceable but doesn't reach out and grab you as often as you'd expect. Frenetic to a fault, it'll divert the under-10s; older viewers may feel there's not enough lift in the quiff." — Total Film
Posted Oct 13, 2011
3/5 85% Tucker & Dale vs Evil (2011) " Genre staples and stereotypes are slain only for convention to wreak revenge; but it'd sure be sweet to follow the loveable lugs on another misadventure." — Total Film
Posted Sep 14, 2011
3/5 44% Cowboys & Aliens (2011) " Solid bordering on stolid. It's Favreau in control again after Avengers advert Iron Man 2 - but given the possibilities, a mild, mild west. More horsing around and another set-piece or two might've helped." — Total Film
Posted Jul 29, 2011
3/5 79% Captain America: The First Avenger (2011) " The final piece of the Avengers jigsaw falls efficiently into place: decent acting, decent action, a few too many "we're all heroes inside" platitudes." — Total Film
Posted Jul 21, 2011
3/5 78% Chalet Girl (2011) " It's steered to success - just - by Jones, a natural, likeable everygirl who will make you care, possibly against your will, about a story as old as the Alps." — Total Film
Posted Mar 7, 2011
3/5 53% Knight & Day (2010) " Diminishing returns eventually topple it, but not before Cruise has cemented one of his most relaxed and likeable performances in some time." — Total Film
Posted Aug 12, 2010
3/5 56% It's Complicated (2009) " Not too sickly-sweet, but not sour either - still, Meyers' sex-with-the-ex comedy is an entertaining poke in the eye for Hollywood ageism." — Total Film
Posted Jan 8, 2010
3/5 34% G.I. Joe: Rise of Cobra (2009) " Sommers bucks the bad buzz with a throwaway blast of solid, stupid fun. You laugh at it rather than with it, but a sequel would be worth it just for more of Gordon-Levitt's one-eyed dramatics." — Total Film
Posted Aug 7, 2009
3/5 19% Star Wars: The Clone Wars (2008) " John Williams' music elbowed in favour of Kevin Kiner's pale imitations... Little things that jar and jar, but at least there's no Jar Jar." — Total Film
Posted Aug 15, 2008
3/5 77% Miss Pettigrew Lives for a Day (2008) " Stagey fluff, yes, but old romantics will spare a sigh for the fairytale fade-out." — Total Film
Posted Aug 15, 2008
3/5 81% Charlie Wilson's War (2007) " Less than the sum of its A-list parts, Nichols' grown-up satire only catches fire when Hoffman's steamed up." — Total Film
Posted Jan 11, 2008
3/5 93% Enchanted (2007) " Subversive enough for older brother, sweet enough for kid sis, this cine-panto's a safe if not spectacular choice for a Chrimbo family outing. The cartoon chipmunk almost steals it, but Adams' dippy dazzle is the movie's heart, soul and lungs." — Total Film
Posted Dec 13, 2007
3/5 74% Planet Terror (Grindhouse Presents: Robert Rodriguez's Planet Terror) (2007) " A bona fide trash pastiche. So good it's bad, then? Almost, but the panache and playfulness machine-gun most of the shortcomings. DVD suppliers! Can we have the two films plus trailers in one now, please?" — Total Film
Posted Nov 9, 2007
3/5 50% 30 Days of Night (2007) " This has more bite than we've come to expect from Sam Raimi's Ghost House production outfit. Some of the action misses the jugular, but Danny Huston makes for a sensational baddie." — Total Film
Posted Nov 1, 2007
3/5 41% December Boys (2007) " A warm, sentimental glow prevails at the end, while copious shots of rolling landscape offset the teatime-telly feel of veteran goggleboxer Rod Hardy's direction." — Total Film
Posted Sep 14, 2007
3/5 88% Waitress (2007) " A stylised indie chick-flick, Waitress gets itself into a tonal puree but still offers flavoursome pleasures and full-on food-porn visuals. A funny and touching testament to Shelly's multi-talent - savour it." — Total Film
Posted Aug 10, 2007
3/5 79% Ghosts of Cité Soleil (2006) " Captured at hair-raisingly close quarters by the fearless filmmakers, the sense of lawlessness grabs the throat and haunts the mind." — Total Film
Posted Jul 20, 2007
3/5 94% The Seventh Seal (Det Sjunde inseglet) (1957) " Fear, peril and hoplessness soak every frame." — BBC
Posted Jul 20, 2007
3/5 79% Ghosts of Cité Soleil (2006) " Arguably the film romanticises its morally challenged protagonists, but there's little hint of rose-tint in the fear, peril and hopelessness that seem to soak every frame like a cold sweat." — BBC
Posted Jul 17, 2007
3/5 81% Sketches of Frank Gehry (2006) " More a thumbnail than a full portrait." — BBC
Posted Jun 26, 2007
Showing 1 - 50 of 131
Previous | Next
  • Sort by Rating:

    Sort results by this critic's rating. This option is only available for critics with a rating system (4 star, letter grade, 1-10, etc.)

  • Sort by T-meter:

    Sort results by the Tomatometer (percentage of critics recommending a certain movie)

Best to Worst Sampling

Help | About | Jobs | Newsletter | Critics Submission | API | Licensing | Mobile