RottenTomatoes.com
Log In | Register | What is RT?
Check out the new RT Community
  • Home
  • Movies
  • DVD
  • Celebrities
  • News
  • Critics
  • Trailers & Pictures
  • CommunityBeta
RT Search Powered by Google
help icon Enhanced RT
searches on Google
Click here to turn on enhanced search results from RT on your Google searches.
 
Critics / Stephen Whitty / Movies
Stephen Whitty

    STEPHEN WHITTY

    Agrees with the Tomatometer 75% of the time.

    Publications: MSNBC, Newark Star-Ledger, Newhouse News Service, San Francisco Examiner

    Critics' Group: New York Film Critics Circle

    Total Reviews: 1055

    MOVIE REVIEWS ONLY

    • All
    • Movies
    • Best
    • Worst
    • Unquoted
    Rating T-Meter Title | Year Add Date (default)

    Fresh
    3/4

    Rotten
    47%

    The Box (2009)

    " It’s not slick, standard sci-fi, sure -- and that’s a good thing." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Nov 5, 2009

    Rotten
    1/4

    Rotten
    16%

    The Fourth Kind (2009)

    " As the movie repeatedly insists, it’s only presenting this information; it’s up to you to decide what to believe. Well, I believe this was a waste of about an hour and a half." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Nov 5, 2009

    Rotten
    2.5/4

    Fresh
    87%

    Precious: Based on the Novel PUSH by Sapphire (2009)

    " The whole thing begins to feel like The Color Purple as rewritten for a poetry slam, heaping on the abuse like a horror film." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Nov 5, 2009

    Fresh
    3/4

    Rotten
    54%

    Disney's A Christmas Carol (2009)

    " It's nice of Hollywood to go to all the trouble but, honestly, Dickens doesn't need the help." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Nov 5, 2009

    Rotten
    1.5/4

    Rotten
    13%

    Gentlemen Broncos (2009)

    " The filmmakers must have been the most sophisticated wits in the BYU cafeteria. I bet they did really funny impressions of the foreign-exchange students behind their backs." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Oct 29, 2009

    Fresh
    3/4

    Fresh
    88%

    The House of the Devil (2009)

    " A slightly faster set-up, and slightly more drawn-out climax, would make this even better." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Oct 29, 2009

    Fresh
    3/4

    Fresh
    80%

    Michael Jackson's This Is It (2009)

    " There’s no sign of sickness here, no sense of an artist past his prime. Instead, you see a performer at his peak." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Oct 28, 2009

    Rotten
    2/4

    Rotten
    17%

    Amelia (2009)

    " Who was Amelia Earhart, really? It's a good question. Unfortunately, it's one beyond Amelia." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Oct 22, 2009

    Rotten
    2/4

    Rotten
    37%

    Cirque du Freak: The Vampire's Assistant (2009)

    " The movie has no sense of magic or fun; the characters never seem to have anything at stake. It's just a lot of computer graphics and gleefully hamming-it-up actors." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Oct 22, 2009

    Fresh
    3/4

    Fresh
    71%

    Where the Wild Things Are (2009)

    " It’s a qualified pleasure, now, to say that the movie is not a disaster -- in fact, parts of it are miraculous -- and that it is still, very much, a Spike Jonze movie." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Oct 15, 2009

    Fresh
    3/4

    Rotten
    57%

    Trucker (2009)

    " Even if the film dutifully hits all the old notes, its characters are interesting, its California desert setting is novel, and its cast works hard. And not only is its star trying something new -- she’s getting it wonderfully right." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Oct 8, 2009

    Fresh
    3/4

    Fresh
    76%

    Bronson (2009)

    " Refn tells his story in a gripping, genre-breaking way, introducing broad theatricality and surreal animation. In some scenes, Peterson delivers monologues in a clown’s whiteface; in others, we’re in an asylum as mad as its patients." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Oct 8, 2009

    Rotten
    1.5/4

    Rotten
    34%

    St. Trinian's (2009)

    " It’s an impressive bit of slumming by some name actors revisiting a childhood favorite -- a bit as if Hollywood had somehow convinced William Hurt to help restart Lost in Space, or Robert De Niro to do a Bullwinkle movie. Oh, wait." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Oct 8, 2009

    Rotten
    2/4

    Rotten
    55%

    The Invention of Lying (2009)

    " The small-town Massachusetts settings are certainly fresh, and some of the involuntary confessions are fun. But, all in all, it’s not a great comedy. And that’s no lie." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Oct 2, 2009

    Rotten
    2/4

    Fresh
    82%

    Whip It (2009)

    " It’s as if Napoleon Dynamite and Little Miss Sunshine strapped on skates and sailed right into some pat Hollywood comedy." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Oct 1, 2009

    Fresh
    3.5/4

    Fresh
    85%

    A Serious Man (2009)

    " So which is it: a simply pointless existence? Or a world so complicated, we can’t grasp the point? If you think the Coens are going to try and answer that question, you haven’t seen many of their movies." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Oct 1, 2009

    Rotten
    2/4

    Fresh
    72%

    The Boys Are Back (2009)

    " It sounds like the start of a Neil Simon sitcom, or some Dennis Quaid movie for Disney, with Rene Russo sweeping in during the second act to bring some order. Actually, that might have been okay. At least it would have had a few jokes." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Sep 25, 2009

    Fresh
    3/4

    Fresh
    66%

    Coco Before Chanel (2009)

    " In the end, even the style and structure of the film are tributes to the great designer herself -- clean, classic and unadorned. And completely unapologetic." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Sep 25, 2009

    Rotten
    2.5/4

    Rotten
    18%

    The Other Man (2009)

    " Before long, the characters, which director Richard Eyre adapted from a Bernhard Schlink short story, cease to be people and start to become devices." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Sep 25, 2009

    Rotten
    2.5/4

    Rotten
    35%

    Blind Date (2009)

    " Ultimately, the joke goes on too long -- for the couple and for us -- and the film fades away before the final fade-out." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Sep 25, 2009

    Fresh
    2.5/4

    Rotten
    28%

    Fame (2009)

    " Pleasant, undemanding entertainment for drama-club kids and the people who love them -- a family-friendly salute to young performing artists." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Sep 25, 2009

    Rotten
    1.5/4

    Rotten
    38%

    Surrogates (2009)

    " The script is by the team that gave us Catwoman and the last two Terminator movies, which tells you all you need to know." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Sep 25, 2009

    Rotten
    2.5/4

    Fresh
    75%

    Capitalism: A Love Story (2009)

    " Is everything always the bank’s fault? Is it only the guys in suits who can get greedy? In Moore’s world, yes, it is." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Sep 24, 2009

    Rotten

    Fresh
    77%

    The Informant! (2009)

    " The Informant! is too clever by half -- and yet, at the same time, not quite as smart as it thinks." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Sep 17, 2009

    Fresh

    Fresh
    94%

    Crude (2009)

    " The film is fair (which is different from being objective) and works hard at representing both points of view. That it's already been denounced in some quarters is only proof he has the oil companies worried." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Sep 10, 2009

    Fresh
    3/4

    Rotten
    56%

    9 (2009)

    " As a late-summer treat for adults with a childlike sense of wonder -- or older children with a grown-up sense of adventure -- 9 is a definite 8 out of 10." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Sep 8, 2009

    Rotten

    Rotten
    31%

    Tickling Leo (2009)

    " Briefly in theaters now, Tickling Leo -- the title makes little sense -- will undoubtedly disappear quickly, only to have a faltering second life at small film festivals. You'll miss little if you pass it by." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Sep 3, 2009

    Rotten
    2/4

    Rotten
    51%

    Taking Woodstock (2009)

    " Too much of Taking Woodstock seems barely sketched out." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Aug 28, 2009

    Fresh
    2.5/4

    Fresh
    84%

    World's Greatest Dad (2009)

    " World's Greatest Dad is a twisted comedy that refuses to let any assumption rest in peace -- including the one that every dearly departed is really dear at all." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Aug 21, 2009

    Fresh
    3/4

    Fresh
    86%

    The Baader Meinhof Complex (2009)

    " This dramatic film documents a decade of near-anarchy in Germany, beginning with a brutal 1967 police riot." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Aug 21, 2009

    Rotten
    2/4

    Rotten
    9%

    Post Grad (2009)

    " The story that writer Kelly Fremon wants to tell in Post Grad -- recent college grad strikes out at finding a job, moves back home with her wacky family and finds true love -- is pretty tired." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Aug 21, 2009

    Rotten
    2.5/4

    Fresh
    71%

    My One and Only (2009)

    " Zellweger isn't dreadful -- in fact, she's more appealing than she's been in years -- but she's not quite good enough. Neither is the film." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Aug 21, 2009

    Rotten
    2.5/4

    Fresh
    88%

    Inglourious Basterds (2009)

    " It's these fine sequences that can make you truly regret Tarantino's snarky, in-joke impulses, not to mention his arrogant -- perhaps even dangerous -- lack of concern with the story's moral dimensions." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Aug 21, 2009

    Fresh
    3/4

    Fresh
    86%

    Yasukuni (2009)

    " Directed by Chinese filmmaker Li Ying, it's an impressionistic documentary that concentrates on the Yasukuni shrine, a Japanese religious memorial to soldiers who died for the emperor." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Aug 14, 2009

    Rotten
    2/4

    Fresh
    91%

    Ponyo (2009)

    " Miyazaki's artwork can be lovely -- and the delicate, watery colors of Ponyo are particularly well done -- but he's still a slave to the genre's peculiar traditions." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Aug 14, 2009

    Rotten
    2.5/4

    Fresh
    77%

    It Might Get Loud (2009)

    " Even longtime music fans are bound to pick up a fresh fact or two. But if you really want to enjoy this music, close your door, crank up a CD and whip out that air guitar." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Aug 14, 2009

    Rotten
    2/4

    Rotten
    38%

    The Time Traveler's Wife (2009)

    " The whole thing feels arbitrary. Henry and Clare's love is bedeviled not by anything they've done or have any control over, so the drama fails to build." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Aug 14, 2009

    Fresh
    3/4

    Fresh
    80%

    Bandslam (2009)

    " Bandslam is hardly the definition of a great movie, but it is pleasant and bright and doesn't insult its audience's intelligence. And that's as rare and welcome as a well-crafted three-minute pop song." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Aug 14, 2009

    Fresh
    3/4

    Fresh
    90%

    District 9 (2009)

    " The wildest science-fiction film to come out all year." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Aug 14, 2009

    Fresh
    3/4

    Fresh
    72%

    I Sell the Dead (2009)

    " Movie fans of all kinds will appreciate a film that knows the differences among 'terror,' 'terrible' and 'terribly good fun.'" — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Aug 7, 2009

    Fresh
    2.5/4

    Rotten
    58%

    A Perfect Getaway (2009)

    " A Perfect Getaway is one of those very clever whodunits that keeps you guessing for quite awhile. But on the way home, as you replay its tricks, you may feel more conned than charmed." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Aug 7, 2009

    Fresh
    3/4

    Fresh
    76%

    Cold Souls (2009)

    " For all its quirks and laughs, there's something in this film you haven't seen in many others during this long summer. A soul." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Aug 7, 2009

    Fresh
    3/4

    Fresh
    75%

    Julie & Julia (2009)

    " It's Julia who truly delights, and who we want seconds of. Like the food she dishes up, she's warm and spicy, hearty and satisfying." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Aug 7, 2009

    Rotten
    1.5/4

    Rotten
    37%

    G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra (2009)

    " A movie that's more sci-fi than semper fi -- and possibly the most proudly mindless epic of the year." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Aug 7, 2009

    Rotten
    1.5/4

    Rotten
    28%

    Aliens in the Attic (2009)

    " Unfortunately the child actors aren't particularly engaging, and the gags aren't entirely fresh." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Jul 31, 2009

    Fresh
    2.5/4

    Fresh
    65%

    Adam (2009)

    " Hugh Dancy, so often just a bland safe boyfriend in femme-oriented films, gives an ironically heartfelt performance as the emotionally insulated Adam." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Jul 31, 2009

    Fresh
    3/4

    Fresh
    86%

    Lorna's Silence (2009)

    " This is a familiar crisis for characters in the movies of Jean-Pierre and Luc Dardenne, the Belgian brothers whose grubbily realistic films often focus on the lives of the desperate." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Jul 31, 2009

    Fresh
    3/4

    Fresh
    95%

    The Cove (2009)

    " This film is less a work of journalism than a call to activism; movies like The Cove, to a certain extent, preach to the converted." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Jul 31, 2009

    Fresh
    2.5/4

    Fresh
    90%

    Gotta Dance (2009)

    " Although the movie's editing and photography are lively, and its subjects are interesting, life didn't cooperate by offering up much drama." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Jul 31, 2009

    Fresh
    3/4

    Fresh
    83%

    Thirst (2009)

    " At a time when so much of popular culture is turning the vampire into just another gently exotic, vulnerable lover, Park brings things back to bloody basics." — Newark Star-Ledger

    Posted Jul 31, 2009
     
     
    • Sort by Rating:

      Sort results by this critic's rating. This option is only available for critics with a rating system (4 star, letter grade, 1-10, etc.)

    • Sort by T-meter:

      Sort results by the Tomatometer (percentage of critics recommending a certain movie)

     
     

    Best to Worst Sampling

    Best to Worst Sampling

    4/4

    Revolutionary RoadOffsite

    3.5/4

    DoubtOffsite

    3/4

    CheOffsite

    2.5/4

    Yes ManOffsite

    2/4

    The SpiritOffsite

    1.5/4

    Seven PoundsOffsite

    1/4

    The UnbornOffsite

    Best Reviewed

    Best Reviewed

    4/4

    Revolutionary RoadOffsite

    4/4

    WALL-EOffsite

    4/4

    The Assassination of Jesse James by...Offsite

    4/4

    The Willow TreeOffsite

    4/4

    The Lives of OthersOffsite

    4/4

    Pan's LabyrinthOffsite

    4/4

    Notes on a ScandalOffsite

    4/4

    Good Night. And, Good LuckOffsite

    More…

    Worst Reviewed

    Worst Reviewed

    0/4

    Expelled: No Intelligence AllowedOffsite

    0/4

    Romance & CigarettesOffsite

    0/4

    ShottasOffsite

    0/4

    They're Just My FriendsOffsite

    0/4

    The Heart is Deceitful Above All ThingsOffsite

    0/4

    DoogalOffsite

    0/4

    GigliOffsite

    1/4

    The Fourth KindOffsite

    1/4

    ShrinkOffsite

    1/4

    Transformers: Revenge of the FallenOffsite

    More…

    Sponsored Links

     
     
    About| Site Map| Help| RT To Go| Contact Us| Critics Submission| Linking to RT| Licensing| Movie List| Games| Celebs List| Newsletter
    IGN Logo

    IGN.com | GameSpy | Comrade | Arena | FilePlanet | GameSpy Technology
    TeamXbox | Planets | Vaults | VE3D | CheatsCodesGuides | GameStats | GamerMetrics
    AskMen.com | Rotten Tomatoes | Direct2Drive | Green Pixels


    By continuing past this page, and by the continued use of this site, you agree to be bound by and abide by the User Agreement.
    Copyright 1998-2009, IGN Entertainment, Inc. About IGN | Support | Advertise | Privacy Policy | User Agreement | Subscribe to RT's XML feed! IGN RSS Feeds
    IGN's enterprise databases running Oracle, SQL and MySQL are professionally monitored and managed by Pythian Remote DBA
    Certain product data ©1995-present Muze, Inc. For personal use only. All rights reserved.