Critics » Ed Gibbs » Rotten
Ed Gibbs

Ed Gibbs

Agrees with the Tomatometer 79% of the time.

Biography:
Ed Gibbs has been a film and music critic for over 15 years, both in London and Sydney. His love of movies stretches back to childhood in his native England, where he devoured the likes of Hitchcock, Spielberg et al before studying film in Scotland and the US. Ed has edited several film-related magazines, regularly hosts major film events (for the innovative Popcorn Taxi), is often asked to vent his filmic spleen on live radio, and worked on ?The Latest and Greatest? movie show, for the Showtime TV network. He also contributes to a wide variety of international publications, including Empire (he?s been a senior contributor since its launch in Australia in 2001), Rolling Stone, GQ, Men?s Style, Time Out (London) and The Sunday Telegraph (Sydney), among many others.
Publications:
Empire Magazine , Empire Magazine Australasia , Rotten Tomatoes , Sydney Morning Herald , The Age (Australia) , The National , The Sun Herald , The Sunday Age
Total Reviews:
79

Worst Reviewed Films

Showing 1 - 50 of 79
Previous | Next
Rating T-Meter Title | Year Add Date
1/10 11% Gone (2012) " There's little to recommend this B-grade, formulaic affair. The plot is tosh, the dialogue hackneyed at best. " — The National
Posted Feb 29, 2012
1/10 2% One for the Money (2012) " With yet another ho-hum run at the multiplexes, Katherine Heigl's big-screen resumé is fast looking like an insider's gag. " — The Sun Herald
Posted Feb 19, 2012
1/10 11% The Darkest Hour (2011) " The title of this teen disaster-by-numbers affair could not be more apt - as a collective omen for all those involved" — The Sun Herald
Posted Jan 24, 2012
1/5 12% W.E. (2012) " Madonna, for all her faults, cast this self-funded feature with uncharacteristic cinematic poise. Otherwise, though, it's a disappointment" — The National
Posted Feb 15, 2012
2/10 3% Jack and Jill (2011) " Hastily assembled, uneven and severely lacking in charm and laughs, Jack and Jill is one of Sandler's weakest outings to date. Which is saying something." — The Sun Herald
Posted Dec 4, 2011
1/5 11% Killers (2010) " A bloated mess that's not remotely funny -- or suspenseful." — Empire Magazine Australasia
Posted Jul 27, 2010
3/10 56% The Lorax (2012) " Given its inevitable merchandise tie-ins, this animated eco-preachy affair carries with it more than a whiff of questionable intent." — The Sun Herald
Posted Mar 25, 2012
3/10 11% Hoodwinked Too! Hood vs Evil (2011) " As with the wicked witch, there's something inherently untrustworthy, even slapdash, about this whole affair." — The Sun Herald
Posted Dec 18, 2011
3/10 70% The Inbetweeners (2011) " It manages to spectacularly abandon all its small-screen smarts and charm. " — The Sun Herald
Posted Dec 10, 2011
3/10 61% The Beaver (2011) " This is a wholly wasted opportunity for Gibson -- and a disappointing misfire from Foster." — Sydney Morning Herald
Posted Aug 1, 2011
2/5 41% Bel Ami (2012) " A trifle of a romp, strictly for Pattinson obsessives who can't hold out until November (when Twilight takes its final bow)." — The Sunday Age
Posted May 20, 2012
4/10 26% Arthur (2011) " In this rehash of the 1981 smash - which featured fellow English comic Dudley Moore in the title role - Brand looks and sounds comparatively bland." — The Sun Herald
Posted Dec 18, 2011
2/5 —— Winnie () " The source material is Anne Marie du Preez Bezdrob's biography, and the period detail is spot on. Yet Winnie: the movie opts to wear its heart openly on its sleeve, and play it absurdly safe." — Guardian [UK]
Posted Sep 21, 2011
5/10 41% Dark Shadows (2012) " If Burton had ever worried that his celebrated brand of eccentricity might one day feel dated or even irrelevant, that unthinkable day may indeed have come." — The Sun Herald
Posted May 13, 2012
5/10 74% Trishna (2012) " Despite some typical visual flair, and an affecting soundtrack to boot, Trishna lacks the emotional punch of Hardy's novel, with Pinto and Ahmed's pairing feeling contrived." — The Sun Herald
Posted May 6, 2012
5/10 20% The Lucky One (2012) " Sparks's books are more Mills & Boon than The Deer Hunter, with his characters little more than mere sketches. Only the women even vaguely register dramatically here. " — The Sun Herald
Posted Apr 15, 2012
2.5/5 69% This Must Be The Place () " The film seems to be aiming for a whimsical flourish on an otherwise unpleasant subject. Its premiere at Cannes met with a mixed response. I remain underwhelmed." — The Sunday Age
Posted Apr 9, 2012
5/10 75% The Adventures of Tintin (2011) " After all the expectation, this Tintin feels strangely flat and lifeless. A War Horse it is not." — The Sun Herald
Posted Dec 18, 2011
3/5 45% Iron Sky () " The production values are extraordinary. Yet for all its chutzpah, matters begin to go awry once the Nazi army descends on Earth, where they lose their sense of comedic power." — The Sunday Age
Posted May 6, 2012
3/5 25% This Means War (2012) " McG's film ticks the expected action boxes easily enough but, as per usual, is not designed to be taken remotely seriously." — The National
Posted Feb 26, 2012
3/5 51% Contraband (2012) " Fond nods to Wahlberg's cinematic past ("It's like the size of a Mini Cooper") are thrown in, and it's imaginatively shot, yet it all feels rather too familiar. " — The National
Posted Feb 19, 2012
3/5 29% The Vow (2012) " The Vow never veers far from its heart-on-sleeve leanings, particularly with Tatum's overbearing voice-over, but McAdams is typically reliable." — The National
Posted Feb 13, 2012
6/10 25% This Means War (2012) " The man whose biggest claim to fame remains the fun but frothy Charlie's Angels pushes all the requisite buttons, while never straying too far from the party line." — The Sun Herald
Posted Feb 13, 2012
6/10 25% The Change-Up (2011) " We may have seen this stuff before but it could have been so much worse." — Sydney Morning Herald
Posted Sep 6, 2011
6/10 23% Conan the Barbarian (2011) " A respectable (if unnecessary) reboot that's brutal, well acted and not overly serious." — Sydney Morning Herald
Posted Aug 25, 2011
3/5 —— Separation City (2009) " Some great moments of comic timing provide for a pleasant, if flawed, bittersweet comedy of errors." — Empire Magazine Australasia
Posted Mar 2, 2010
3/5 91% Precious: Based on the Novel Push by Sapphire (2009) " Self-conscious, uneven and confusing at times -- but Sidibe's fine performance has to be seen, regardless. She is, quite simply, astonishing." — Empire Magazine Australasia
Posted Jan 31, 2010
3/5 75% $9.99 (2008) " Playful, light-hearted and fun, with an impressive cast of Aussie stars and some fine stop-motion animation. As it stands, at 74 minutes, it's not quite as smart (or rewarding) as one would hope." — Empire Magazine Australasia
Posted Sep 13, 2009
3/5 43% Shorts (Shorts: The Adventures of the Wishing Rock) (2009) " Dives straight into whiz-bang gizmoland, opting for "pause, rewind" flourishes. Cute and enjoyable family fare, then, if a little forced." — Empire Magazine
Posted Sep 1, 2009
7/10 68% Salmon Fishing in the Yemen (2012) " For those who prefer their otherwise bitter politics lightly coated with sugar, this should suffice. A bolder remit wouldn't have hurt, though, given the source material." — The Sun Herald
Posted Apr 9, 2012
3.5/5 85% 21 Jump Street (2012) " While hardly raising the bar in action-comedy, it's still a fun, irreverent, laugh-out-loud take on the beloved, small-screen original." — The Sunday Age
Posted Mar 21, 2012
7/10 85% 21 Jump Street (2012) " While hardly raising the bar in action-comedy, it's still a fun, irreverent, laugh-out-loud take on the beloved, small-screen original." — The Sun Herald
Posted Mar 11, 2012
7/10 26% Project X (2012) " It's the party you've only dreamed about, the tagline says. And if you were 17 years old again, you might be inclined to agree." — The Sun Herald
Posted Mar 4, 2012
7/10 61% Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows (2011) " Infinitely more watchable than its predecessor, with Downey, Law and, now, Fry all on top form. Yet McAdams is sorely missed." — The Sun Herald
Posted Jan 1, 2012
7/10 91% Source Code (2011) " Were it supremely confident of knowing when to show its trump card, the film could have gone even further." — The Sun Herald
Posted Dec 18, 2011
7/10 72% Rio (2011) " You'd be the world's biggest grinch not to get a kick out of this feather fest." — The Sun Herald
Posted Dec 18, 2011
7/10 36% Restless (2011) " With a tighter grip on proceedings, one imagines Restless would have Van Sant troubling the Academy all over again. As it stands, it's a sweet, gentle film." — The Sun Herald
Posted Nov 27, 2011
7/10 95% Moneyball (2011) " Despite the hoopla surrounding its premiere at this year's Toronto International Film Festival, this fact-based baseball drama remains a rather dry, if serviceable, affair." — The Sun Herald
Posted Nov 6, 2011
7/10 58% Red State (2011) " For those who believe self-styled indie filmmaker Kevin Smith to be a one-trick pony - and there are many - this curious horror-thriller will come as something of a shock." — The Sun Herald
Posted Oct 9, 2011
7/10 60% Real Steel (2011) " A father-son family yarn that shares the same sweet sentiment as the recent Crazy, Stupid, Love: that the best things in life are far from free - or easy - to obtain." — The Sun Herald
Posted Oct 2, 2011
7/10 44% Cowboys & Aliens (2011) " There is nothing that fascinating about Favreau's treatment, nor his source material, but compared with similar blockbuster fare of recent months, this curious exercise in genre bending is very watchable." — Sydney Morning Herald
Posted Aug 19, 2011
8/10 96% Silent Souls (2011) " The finale may leave some unfulfilled, but this is an intuitive visual essay that begs to be experienced." — Empire Magazine Australasia
Posted May 20, 2012
8/10 65% The Woman in Black (2012) " A gothic horror tale that studiously avoids any modern gimmicks in favour of classically themed motifs, with a neat twist to Hammer its point home." — The Sun Herald
Posted May 20, 2012
8/10 93% Marvel's The Avengers (2012) " Joss Whedon marshals matters effectively throughout, without losing sight of that other key demographic: those who dispensed with their comic books long ago." — The Sun Herald
Posted Apr 29, 2012
8/10 78% Cafe de Flore () " Vanessa Paradis is superb, playing the tough, single mother struggling in a prejudiced and very un-swinging '60s Paris as if her life depended on it." — The Sunday Age
Posted Apr 22, 2012
4/5 78% A Dangerous Method (2011) " Restraint is not something we've come to expect from David Cronenberg. Yet here, the Canadian sticks with his more measured tone of late." — The Sunday Age
Posted Mar 25, 2012
8/10 89% Margin Call (2011) " Smart, sharp and dark, J C Chandor's ensemble drama - eliciting defined, defiant performances from an A-grade cast - summons the spirit of David Mamet's Glengarry Glen Ross." — The Sun Herald
Posted Mar 11, 2012
8/10 92% Headhunters (2012) " A super-slick thriller that doesn't let up, with exceptional performances all round. Make sure you catch it before the inevitable US remake rears its head." — The Sun Herald
Posted Mar 4, 2012
8/10 85% The Tree of Life (2011) " A bold, epic exercise that Malick comes close to pulling off. It may not stack up against his best, but it doesn't fail to incite feelings of awe in its audience, either." — The Sun Herald
Posted Dec 18, 2011
8/10 70% Oranges And Sunshine (2011) " Jim Loach's feature debut presents the horrific injustice of forced child migration in a calm, measured manner." — The Sun Herald
Posted Dec 18, 2011
Showing 1 - 50 of 79
Previous | Next
  • Sort by Rating:

    Sort results by this critic's rating. This option is only available for critics with a rating system (4 star, letter grade, 1-10, etc.)

  • Sort by T-meter:

    Sort results by the Tomatometer (percentage of critics recommending a certain movie)

Help | About | Jobs | Newsletter | Critics Submission | API | Licensing | Mobile