Critics » John J. Puccio
John J. Puccio

John J. Puccio

Agrees with the Tomatometer 83% of the time.

Biography:
Teacher, English and Film Study, retired. Classical Music Editor, $ensible Sound magazine. Review Editor, DVDTOWN.com. Member, Online Film Critics Society (www.ofcs.org). Bright, quiet, loyal, dependable. Easily trained. Will fetch. Make offer. Home theater: Sony KDL-40XBR6 widescreen HD television, Toshiba HD-A35 HD-DVD player, Panasonic DMP-BD50 Blu-ray player, Onkyo TX-SR705 A/V receiver, 7.1 Boston Acoustics Reference Series speakers with Energy e:XL subwoofer, Harmony One universal remote, Monster Cable speaker wire and interconnects. Primary target: The ICBM missile complex at Lapuda. My earliest recollection of motion pictures having a profound and moving impact on me was in about 1951 or 52 when my dad took me to see "All Quiet on the Western Front," the 1930 film in rerelease. I remember the lobby was filled with display memorabilia--World War I uniforms, rifles, a small cannon of some sort--fascinating stuff to an eight-year-old kid. I loved the movie, I loved the action, I loved the main character, and I was totally shocked and shaken when at the end he was killed! This was the hero. Heroes didn't die. Not in the movies. Not anywhere. It wasn't for another day or two that the second revelation sunk in. The hero was a German. Understand, I saw this film only seven or eight years after the Second World War, and the Germans had been our enemies. When my friends and I played army men, the bad guys were always Germans or Japanese. (Never mind that I was Italian; the Italians, as far as I was concerned, had never even been in WWII, let alone fought against us.) Anyway, "All Quiet's" hero, Paul Baumer, was a German, yet I was totally sympathetic toward him. It wouldn't be for another few years that I would recognize the significance in my life of books and literature in quite the same way as I had by then learned the value of movies. And they were lessons I would never forget. I tend to wonder sometimes if I'd be teaching English and Film today if it weren't for that hand reaching out to the butterfly. Sweet, touching, funny, exciting, romantic, unforgettable, and ofttimes monumentally poignant images make good films what they are, different and precious for everyone who watches them.
Favorites:
Some favorite films: Casablanca, Citizen Kane, The Godfather I & II, The Third Man, 2001, Star Wars, The Wizard of Oz, Dr. Strangelove, Snow White, Fantasia, Pinocchio, A Night at the Opera, Some Like It Hot, To Kill a Mockingbird, M. Hulot's Holiday, Psycho, Cabaret, Day for Night, The Lord of the Rings trilogy, The Chronicles of Narnia, The Maltese Falcon, The Big Sleep, The Music Man, The Outlaw Josey Wales, The Haunting (1963), The Uninvited, True Lies, Contact, Moonstruck, Cool Hand Luke, Alien, Dark City, Devil in a Blue Dress, My Fair Lady, The Treasure of the Sierra Madre, Singin' in the Rain, Stardust, Pan's Labyrinth, and about a thousand more. Not-so-guilty pleasures: Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein, The Ghost Breakers, Them! John
Publications:
Movie Metropolis
Critics' Group:
Online Film Critics Society
Total Reviews:
4085
Total QuickRatings:
197
Location:
Martinez, CA

Listing Of All Reviews & Articles

Showing 1 - 50 of 4085
Previous | Next
Rating T-Meter Title | Year Add Date
5/10 69% A Very Harold & Kumar Christmas (2011) " If only the writers could find a way to be funny and at least a touch witty without the infantile vulgarity, they might be onto something. (Blu-ray Combo edition)" — Movie Metropolis
Posted Feb 2, 2012
5/10 69% A Very Harold & Kumar Christmas (2011) " For me, this was the best 'Harold & Kumar' film yet. Unfortunately, the film still comes off as too juvenile in its humor to have pleased this adult for very long." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Feb 2, 2012
5/10 —— Jim's Gift () " As a kids' television movie it works well enough, and children might just find it pleasurable." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Jan 30, 2012
8/10 100% Rebecca (1940) " ...a gothic romance in the classic sense. (Blu-ray edition)" — Movie Metropolis
Posted Jan 30, 2012
8/10 100% Rebecca (1940) " While the film offers no overt violence or thrills, it is a model of sustained mystery and eerie suspense." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Jan 30, 2012
4/10 57% Love Story (1970) " ...drippy, slow, unrealistic, unbelievable, poorly written, and badly acted. I mean, other than that, it's OK. (Blu-ray edition)" — Movie Metropolis
Posted Jan 24, 2012
4/10 57% Love Story (1970) " If you're going to make a serious tearjerker, somebody's got to die. It's in the handbook of romantic platitudes." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Jan 24, 2012
6/10 97% Wings (1927) " ...viewed for its action, dogfights, and combat sequences alone, 'Wings' is a remarkable achievement. (Blu-ray edition)" — Movie Metropolis
Posted Jan 16, 2012
6/10 97% Wings (1927) " ...as big as they came in 1927, with a host of extras in the battle scenes and aerial footage that is often stunning." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Jan 16, 2012
4/10 67% Paranormal Activity 3 (2011) " How many times in these movies can the filmmakers repeat the same things? (Blu-ray Combo edition)" — Movie Metropolis
Posted Jan 12, 2012
4/10 67% Paranormal Activity 3 (2011) " For me, it was a matter of diminishing returns on a product that wasn't very good to begin with." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Jan 12, 2012
6/10 —— Reach for the Sky (1957) " ...often a stirring account of one man's struggle to do his best and prove his worth under the most trying circumstances." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Jan 4, 2012
6/10 —— Reach for the Sky (1957) " Kenneth More's performance is at the heart of it all, a bigger-than-life realization that is hard to resist." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Jan 4, 2012
6/10 84% Contagion (2011) " Kind of a mixed bag. It's got the right ingredients for a convincing real-life thriller, yet it seems too detached. (Blu-ray Combo edition)" — Movie Metropolis
Posted Dec 31, 2011
6/10 84% Contagion (2011) " A first-rate cast, excellent acting, and a reasonably taut pace help a somewhat lackluster and sometimes melodramatic story line over its more-predictable soft spots." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Dec 31, 2011
3/10 —— Santa Claus (1959) " The fact that VCI have reproduced it in a widescreen, high-definition Blu-ray transfer only makes it seem all the more bizarre. (Blu-ray edition)" — Movie Metropolis
Posted Dec 28, 2011
3/10 —— Santa Claus (1959) " I couldn't help feeling as I watched it that it must have a strong cult following somewhere simply because it's so...strange." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Dec 28, 2011
6/10 60% Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows (2011) " If viewers go in expecting another cerebral Holmes, star Robert Downey, Jr.'s vigorous portrayal of the character will surely seem unsettling. Forewarned is forearmed." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Dec 21, 2011
6/10 83% Dolphin Tale (2011) " Mostly, the movie is about friendships, new and old, about bonding, about overcoming adversity through love and family. (Blu-ray Combo edition)" — Movie Metropolis
Posted Dec 17, 2011
6/10 83% Dolphin Tale (2011) " While some adults may get impatient with it, kids will undoubtedly find it appealing." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Dec 17, 2011
6/10 60% Final Destination 5 (2011) " It works as a good carnival house of horrors might work, giving participants a vicarious thrill a minute. (Blu-ray Combo edition)" — Movie Metropolis
Posted Dec 14, 2011
6/10 60% Final Destination 5 (2011) " It's a neat, tidy, tightly wound little horror picture with a single-minded intent to startle you out of your seat while causing you to laugh immoderately." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Dec 14, 2011
5/10 81% Kung Fu Panda 2 (2011) " Cute, fun, not very original or engrossing for this adult but gorgeous to look at and listen to in high def. (Blu-ray edition) " — Movie Metropolis
Posted Dec 8, 2011
5/10 81% Kung Fu Panda 2 (2011) " The characters do a lot of chasing around, running, punching, and kicking, making the movie more exhausting than exciting." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Dec 8, 2011
7/10 70% Mission: Impossible III (2006) " More stuff blows up in the first twenty minutes of this one than in the first two movies combined. (Extreme Blu-ray Trilogy)" — Movie Metropolis
Posted Dec 5, 2011
7/10 70% Mission: Impossible III (2006) " The best of the first three for its nonstop action and sometimes pulse-pounding excitement." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Dec 5, 2011
6/10 61% Mission Impossible (1996) " If you like Cruise, it's his movie. (Extreme Blu-ray Trilogy)" — Movie Metropolis
Posted Dec 5, 2011
6/10 61% Mission Impossible (1996) " What used to be an IMF team effort turned into another star vehicle for Tom Cruise." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Dec 5, 2011
3/10 35% The Hangover Part II (2011) " If you liked the first movie, you're liable to like the second one; it's the same film. (Blu-ray Combo Pack)" — Movie Metropolis
Posted Nov 29, 2011
3/10 35% The Hangover Part II (2011) " ...almost the same gang of dimwits are up to the same shenanigans, with Thailand substituting for Vegas." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Nov 29, 2011
7/10 —— Silver Fleet () " ...an inspiring story of courage under pressure, of heroism during the Resistance, of self-sacrifice above all." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Nov 22, 2011
7/10 —— Silver Fleet () " A good, taut little WWII thriller that makes unique and worthwhile viewing." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Nov 22, 2011
6/10 71% Mutiny on the Bounty (1962) " Brando practically scuttles the ship as the brooding Mr. Christian with the bad English accent. (Blu-ray edition)" — Movie Metropolis
Posted Nov 13, 2011
6/10 71% Mutiny on the Bounty (1962) " It's best to watch it for its glorious cinematography and settings, and forget about Brando's participation." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Nov 13, 2011
7/10 82% Super 8 (2011) " You almost expect Richard Dreyfuss to show up looking for UFO's. (Blu-ray Combo edition)" — Movie Metropolis
Posted Nov 10, 2011
7/10 82% Super 8 (2011) " While it's often tense and exciting, it's also more than a little exaggerated and corny at the end. You take what you get." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Nov 10, 2011
8/10 96% Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows - Part 2 (2011) " Whether we needed to have the book divided into two parts is open to question, but we have what we have, and it's pretty darn good. (Blu-ray Combo edition)" — Movie Metropolis
Posted Nov 6, 2011
8/10 96% Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows - Part 2 (2011) " It makes a fitting conclusion to a series that most of the film-going public has been following for over a decade." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Nov 6, 2011
7/10 64% Scrooged (1988) " Bill Murray in a satiric send-up of Charles Dickens's 'A Christmas Carol' is too good to pass up. (Blu-ray edition)" — Movie Metropolis
Posted Nov 4, 2011
7/10 64% Scrooged (1988) " It's got Bill Murray, and that's always a good thing." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Nov 4, 2011
6/10 78% Crazy, Stupid, Love. (2011) " It may just earn Steve Carell the respect of a few moviegoers who have grown tired of his usual sad-sack portrayals" — Movie Metropolis
Posted Nov 1, 2011
6/10 78% Crazy, Stupid, Love. (2011) " The characters and their predicaments rather grow on you. Silly? Yeah, a little. Touching? Yeah, a lot." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Nov 1, 2011
3/10 —— Alien Outlaw (1976) " ...fairly defines the notion of a B-movie, with its threadbare budget, indifferent acting, lackluster script, and corny action." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Oct 27, 2011
3/10 —— Alien Outlaw (1976) " Yes, of course, there is gratuitous nudity. What respectable pulp sci-fi B-movie would be without it." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Oct 27, 2011
7/10 79% Captain America: The First Avenger (2011) " ...good humored and uncomplicated, it concentrates on a single character, a single villain, a clear path to the present. (Blu-ray 3-D Combo edition)" — Movie Metropolis
Posted Oct 19, 2011
7/10 79% Captain America: The First Avenger (2011) " Because of its period atmosphere and its successful combination of characterization and action, it tops my list of best superhero films of the year." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Oct 19, 2011
5/10 —— The Riddle of the Sands () " This 1979 film adaptation of the classic spy thriller is rather too plain and dry to capture all of the tale's adventure." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Oct 13, 2011
5/10 —— The Riddle of the Sands () " Perhaps director Tony Maylam was being too literal in adapting the novel to the screen, a novel that didn't translate well." — Movie Metropolis
Posted Oct 13, 2011
5/10 69% Horrible Bosses (2011) " The final third of the film lets it down, the three main characters suddenly turning into bumbling idiots. (Blu-ray Combo edition)" — Movie Metropolis
Posted Oct 7, 2011
Showing 1 - 50 of 4085
Previous | Next
  • Sort by Rating:

    Sort results by this critic's rating. This option is only available for critics with a rating system (4 star, letter grade, 1-10, etc.)

  • Sort by T-meter:

    Sort results by the Tomatometer (percentage of critics recommending a certain movie)

Help | About | Jobs | Newsletter | Critics Submission | API | Licensing | Blog | Developers | Mobile