RottenTomatoes.com
Log In | Register | What is RT?
Check out the new RT Community
  • Home
  • Movies
  • DVD
  • Celebrities
  • News
  • Critics
  • Trailers & Pictures
  • CommunityBeta
RT Search Powered by Google
help icon Enhanced RT
searches on Google
Click here to turn on enhanced search results from RT on your Google searches.
 
Critics / John P. McCarthy
No picture available

    JOHN P. MCCARTHY

    Agrees with the Tomatometer 77% of the time.

    Biography: Film Critic, ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Publications: Boxoffice Magazine, ReelTalk Movie Reviews, Variety

    Total Reviews: 411

    LISTING OF ALL REVIEWS & ARTICLES

    • All
    • Movies
    • Best
    • Worst
    • Unquoted
    # a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z
    Results for All Genres
    Showing 1 - 50 of 411
    Previous | Next
    Rating T-Meter Title | Year Add Date (default)

    Fresh

    Fresh
    90%

    Fantastic Mr. Fox (2009)

    " Wes Anderson's idiosyncratic style and children's author Roald Dahl's cozy-yet-edgy imagination are a perfect fit in this enjoyable and altogether unusual movie experience." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Nov 10, 2009

    Rotten
    1.5/5

    Rotten
    48%

    The Box (2009)

    " Sci-fi lovers should find it risible, and those who devalue the genre will have their biases confirmed." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Nov 5, 2009

    Rotten

    Rotten
    55%

    The Men Who Stare at Goats (2009)

    " Neither absurdist enough as a comedy nor trenchant enough as a war satire, this effort elicits a few chuckles but little else." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Nov 5, 2009

    Fresh

    Fresh
    87%

    Precious: Based on the Novel PUSH by Sapphire (2009)

    " Sidibe and Mo'Nique deliver outstanding performances here. They compel the audience to cut through the hype and connect with their characters' plights." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Nov 5, 2009

    Fresh

    Fresh
    80%

    Michael Jackson's This Is It (2009)

    " This documentary movie can only help Jackson's artistic reputation, and the concerts, had he lived to perform them, would likely have done the same." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Nov 2, 2009

    Fresh
    3/5

    Rotten
    13%

    Gentlemen Broncos (2009)

    " Its quirkiness preceding and very nearly swallowing it whole, Gentlemen Broncos is less warped than it thinks it is yet still provides enough bizarre, painstakingly designed schlock to tickle the willing." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Oct 29, 2009

    Rotten

    Rotten
    17%

    Amelia (2009)

    " Those expecting a stirring portrait of a feminist pioneer will be disappointed by the ethereal ambiguity of 'Amelia.'" — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Oct 26, 2009

    Fresh
    3.5/5

    Fresh
    100%

    Rembrandt's J'accuse (2009)

    " What starts out as an audaciously polemical, radically inventive film project ultimately feels more like the most elaborate and earnest art history lecture ever delivered." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Oct 23, 2009

    Fresh

    Fresh
    70%

    Where the Wild Things Are (2009)

    " There's no coddling going on in this immersive live-action film, which, like a dream, is both eerily matter-of-fact and fantastical." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Oct 15, 2009

    Rotten
    2.5/5

    N/A

    Ball Don't Lie (2009)

    " Ball Don’t Lie has what you might call an excess of street cred." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Oct 9, 2009

    Fresh
    3/5

    Rotten
    34%

    St. Trinian's (2009)

    " St. Trinian’s is a hoot, but it’s thrown-together, haphazard feel will only grate on the sensibilities of cineastes or aesthetic and moral prudes bent on decrying “yoof” culture -- although it’s only moderately rude by contemporary standards." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Oct 9, 2009

    Rotten
    1.5/5

    Rotten
    12%

    Couples Retreat (2009)

    " At least Vince Vaughn, Jon Favreau and their fellow cast and crewmates were able to spend time on a gorgeous tropical island while making this mirthless, half-hearted relationship comedy." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Oct 9, 2009

    Fresh

    Fresh
    82%

    Whip It (2009)

    " There's poignant interaction between the generations, puppy-love lyricism, and just enough edginess to keep adolescents engaged." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Oct 1, 2009

    Rotten

    Rotten
    55%

    The Invention of Lying (2009)

    " Ultimately, the atheist gospel according to Ricky Gervais is too preachy for its own good." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Oct 1, 2009

    Rotten

    Rotten
    28%

    Fame (2009)

    " 'Fame 2009' is the cinematic equivalent of Muzak and will leave many viewers longing for the next episode of TV's 'Glee.'" — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Sep 29, 2009

    Rotten
    2/5

    Rotten
    50%

    The Providence Effect (2009)

    " Providence-St. Mel's achievements are truly laudable, but its inspirational lessons get watered down by the uncritical approach taken by director/producer Rollin Binzer." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Sep 24, 2009

    Rotten
    2/5

    Rotten
    0%

    If One Thing Matters: A Film About Wolfgang Tillmans (2009)

    " Heiko Kalmbach’s video portrait of the German-born, London-based photographer frustrates because of the way it hovers between the esoteric and the quotidian." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Sep 24, 2009

    Rotten
    1.5/5

    Rotten
    35%

    Blind Date (2009)

    " Merely a depressing curiosity." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Sep 24, 2009

    Rotten

    Fresh
    75%

    Capitalism: A Love Story (2009)

    " Michael Moore paints with too-wide a conceptual brush, which in turn explains why 'Capitalism: A Love Story' goes off point so often." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Sep 23, 2009

    Fresh

    Fresh
    85%

    Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs (2009)

    " While the mutated food on display isn't always appetizing, the animation is a veritable feast for the eyes." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Sep 18, 2009

    Fresh

    Rotten
    45%

    Jennifer's Body (2009)

    " More funny than scary, 'Jennifer's Body' is a bodacious tease." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Sep 17, 2009

    Rotten
    2/4

    Rotten
    18%

    The Other Man (2009)

    " Near the end, Peter issues this verdict on his romantic rival, “Appalling…but also rather wonderful.” Applied to the film itself, he’s half right." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Sep 11, 2009

    Fresh
    3/5

    Fresh
    62%

    Tyler Perry's I Can Do Bad All By Myself (2009)

    " Despite a plot that’s arguably Perry’s most predictable, I Can Do Bad All By Myself is genuinely affecting when the gospel spirit takes hold and is a marked improvement over his last two pieces of moral burlesque." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Sep 11, 2009

    Fresh

    Rotten
    56%

    9 (2009)

    " Soulful, streamlined and brilliantly executed, "9" is a contender for best action film of the year." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Sep 9, 2009

    Fresh
    4/5

    Fresh
    86%

    The Baader Meinhof Complex (2009)

    " For their part, Edel and Eichinger have given an under-explored episode in recent European history a serious and seriously entertaining treatment that stands on its own cinematically and historically." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Aug 28, 2009

    Fresh
    3/5

    Fresh
    86%

    At the Edge of the World (2009)

    " A collective profile in courage." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Aug 28, 2009

    Rotten
    1.5/5

    Rotten
    59%

    The Headless Woman (2009)

    " Ethereal to a fault. Consternation carries the day." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Aug 21, 2009

    Fresh

    Fresh
    90%

    District 9 (2009)

    " The special effects are terrific and don't overwhelm the harrowing story, which is surprisingly emotional." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Aug 16, 2009

    Fresh

    Rotten
    36%

    G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra (2009)

    " You get your money's worth and then some. As for the movie's stars, Tatum is suitably studly and Miller acquits herself quite well in her first turn in a blockbuster." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Aug 10, 2009

    Fresh

    Fresh
    75%

    Julie & Julia (2009)

    " The cuisine may be French but the spirit is as American as apple pie." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Aug 6, 2009

    Fresh

    Rotten
    58%

    A Perfect Getaway (2009)

    " What looks like a 'Survivor' rip-off is actually an ideal summer flick boasting beautiful scenery, hard bodies and shrewdly deranged minds." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Aug 6, 2009

    Rotten

    Rotten
    25%

    The Collector (2009)

    " Lacks coherence and subtext, failing to trigger either revulsion or fear." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Jul 30, 2009

    Rotten

    Rotten
    15%

    The Ugly Truth (2009)

    " This asinine romantic comedy doesn't have an original bone in it's body." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Jul 23, 2009

    Fresh
    4/5

    Fresh
    91%

    The Way We Get By (2009)

    " Contains more useful, homespun philosophizing and genuine sentiment than a year’s worth of narrative films. That it’s so well made is a bonus." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Jul 17, 2009

    Fresh

    Fresh
    83%

    Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince (2009)

    " The effects are sufficiently dazzling and the script's balance between humor and peril nicely calibrated." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Jul 14, 2009

    Fresh

    Fresh
    67%

    Brüno (2009)

    " Putting his hairless self in harm's way, Sacha Baron Cohen sets the bar for guerilla comedy as high and as low as it can go." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Jul 10, 2009

    Rotten

    Rotten
    45%

    Ice Age: Dawn of the Dinosaurs (2009)

    " Enough is swiped from Pixar to render this adequate kiddy fare." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Jul 1, 2009

    Rotten

    Fresh
    67%

    Public Enemies (2009)

    " For all its surface beauty and energetic shootouts, this underwritten picture doesn't cut very deep and is strangely inert." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Jul 1, 2009

    Fresh
    4.5/5

    Fresh
    92%

    Séraphine (2008)

    " A list of the striking images that Provost composes would be long and enticing, even though words cannot do them or the movie justice." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Jun 12, 2009

    Fresh
    3/5

    Fresh
    96%

    Herb & Dorothy (2009)

    " Herb and Dorothy certainly proves there's more than one way to be an art collector. It just doesn't probe deeply enough and ask thorny questions about the nature of collecting and the nature of art, and how they relate to one another." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Jun 12, 2009

    Fresh
    3.5/5

    Fresh
    60%

    BLAST! (2008)

    " Combining hard science, human interest and suspense, BLAST! is a stimulating introduction to astrophysics and a fine tribute to scientists of all stripes who engage in taxing fieldwork." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Jun 12, 2009

    Fresh
    3.5/5

    Rotten
    52%

    The Taking of Pelham 1 2 3 (2009)

    " You can always count on a Scott, in this case Ridley's little bro Tony, to jangle your nerves." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Jun 12, 2009

    Fresh

    Rotten
    38%

    Imagine That (2009)

    " Long and certainly predictable, yet quite effective -- a family film with more depth than you might envisage." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Jun 11, 2009

    Rotten
    2.5/5

    Rotten
    26%

    Land of the Lost (2009)

    " Land of the Lost amounts to a $100 million bet that Will Ferrell’s brand of sketch comedy can survive contact with the day-glo sludge Sid & Marty Krofft purveyed. And vice versa." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted Jun 5, 2009

    Rotten

    Rotten
    10%

    My Life in Ruins (2009)

    " This shambles of a romantic comedy ends up mostly as a trip to comedy hell." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Jun 4, 2009

    Fresh

    Fresh
    78%

    The Hangover (2009)

    " A fantastic blend of raunch and more cerebral, off-the-wall humor, this isn't a case of reinventing the wheel but shaping it so that it rolls pure." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted Jun 4, 2009

    Fresh

    Fresh
    98%

    Up (2009)

    " In the hands of Peter Docter and gang, the exploits of a grumpy widower and an eager eight-year-old become incredibly entertaining in 'Up.'" — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted May 28, 2009

    Rotten

    Rotten
    32%

    Terminator Salvation (2009)

    " The script is lacking and the acting merely serviceable in 'Terminator Salvation.'" — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted May 25, 2009

    Rotten
    2.5/5

    Rotten
    18%

    Dance Flick (2009)

    " Pro forma and tasteless, if not excessively vulgar, the movie loses its urgency when it becomes an almost verbatim example of the melodrama it's skewering." — Boxoffice Magazine

    Posted May 22, 2009

    Fresh

    Rotten
    36%

    Angels & Demons (2009)

    " A luridly compelling yarn that, for the purposes of the multiplex if not the pulpit or the laboratory, effectively bridges belief and reason." — ReelTalk Movie Reviews

    Posted May 20, 2009
    Results for All Genres
    Showing 1 - 50 of 411
    Previous | Next
     
     
    • Sort by Rating:

      Sort results by this critic's rating. This option is only available for critics with a rating system (4 star, letter grade, 1-10, etc.)

    • Sort by T-meter:

      Sort results by the Tomatometer (percentage of critics recommending a certain movie)

     
     

    Best to Worst Sampling

    Best to Worst Sampling

    4.5/5

    WALL-EOffsite

    4/5

    2 Days In ParisOffsite

    3.5/5

    The TV SetOffsite

    2.5/4

    Inland EmpireOffsite

    3/5

    Who the #$&% is Jackson Pollock?Offsite

    2.5/5

    UnknownOffsite

    2/4

    The Other ManOffsite

    2/5

    Two WeeksOffsite

    1.5/5

    Blood and ChocolateOffsite

    1/5

    Good Luck ChuckOffsite

    .5/5

    Repo! The Genetic OperaOffsite

    Best Reviewed

    Best Reviewed

    4.5/5

    SéraphineOffsite

    4.5/5

    Must Read After My DeathOffsite

    4.5/5

    WALL-EOffsite

    More…

    Worst Reviewed

    Worst Reviewed

    .5/5

    Miss MarchOffsite

    .5/5

    Repo! The Genetic OperaOffsite

    1/5

    Little AshesOffsite

    1/5

    Street Fighter: The Legend of Chun-LiOffsite

    1/5

    New in TownOffsite

    1/5

    Dark StreetsOffsite

    1/5

    NoiseOffsite

    1/5

    Choose ConnorOffsite

    1/5

    Good Luck ChuckOffsite

    More…

    Sponsored Links

     
     
    About| Site Map| Help| RT To Go| Contact Us| Critics Submission| Linking to RT| Licensing| Movie List| Games| Celebs List| Newsletter
    IGN Logo

    IGN.com | GameSpy | Comrade | Arena | FilePlanet | GameSpy Technology
    TeamXbox | Planets | Vaults | VE3D | CheatsCodesGuides | GameStats | GamerMetrics
    AskMen.com | Rotten Tomatoes | Direct2Drive | Green Pixels


    By continuing past this page, and by the continued use of this site, you agree to be bound by and abide by the User Agreement.
    Copyright 1998-2009, IGN Entertainment, Inc. About IGN | Support | Advertise | Privacy Policy | User Agreement | Subscribe to RT's XML feed! IGN RSS Feeds
    IGN's enterprise databases running Oracle, SQL and MySQL are professionally monitored and managed by Pythian Remote DBA
    Certain product data ©1995-present Muze, Inc. For personal use only. All rights reserved.