David Edelstein

Agrees with the Tomatometer 74% of the time.

Biography:
I started way back at the Harvard Crimson, then moved on to the Boston Phoenix, then the Village Voice, then the New York Post, then oblivion, then Slate and Fresh Air. I also wrote a book with Christine Vachon called Shooting to Kill and a couple of plays, chiefly Blaming Mom (a comedy).
Favorites:
The Lady Eve, The General, McCabe and Mrs. Miller, Shop Around the Corner, The Godfather, Smiles of a Summer Night, Rules of the Game, Jaws, Ride the High Country, His Girl Friday, Bride of Frankenstein, Seven Samurai, Ashes and Diamonds, Touch of Evil, Singing in the Rain, Night of the Living Dead, and about 100 others.
Publications:
New York Magazine , NPR's Fresh Air , Slate
Critics' Group:
National Society of Film Critics
Total Reviews:
1272

Best Reviewed Films

Showing 1 - 50 of 977
Previous | Next
Rating T-Meter Title | Year Add Date
85% Farewell (L'affaire Farewell) (2010) " Ward plays Reagan as not just engaged but swaggering and overexcitable -- a fun revisionist performance. But this is Kusturica's movie." — New York Magazine
Posted Jul 26, 2010
62% Salt (2010) " Salt is a senseless blast." — New York Magazine
Posted Jul 26, 2010
90% Winnebago Man (2010) " [A] frustrating, borderline exploitative, madly entertaining documentary." — New York Magazine
Posted Jul 14, 2010
69% Life During Wartime (2010) " Solondz conjures a world that's rotting away from the inside, in which only the children -- freckle-faced Dylan Riley Snyder and Emma Hinz -- weep over the loss of moral authority." — New York Magazine
Posted Jul 12, 2010
100% Racing Dreams (2010) " The journey is thrilling -- even if, on some level, you know that these kids are going in circles." — New York Magazine
Posted Jul 5, 2010
93% The Kids Are All Right (2010) " The title, like Nicole Holofcener's Please Give, is one that trails you out of the theater and gives you something to brood on." — New York Magazine
Posted Jul 5, 2010
96% Restrepo (2010) " Restrepo is, on its own terms, a stunning piece of work, but to get even more from it you should buy Junger's book, WAR, which expands on the footage we see." — New York Magazine
Posted Jun 18, 2010
99% Toy Story 3 (2010) " The gags are all of a piece, right up to the forlorn yet enchanting finale." — New York Magazine
Posted Jun 18, 2010
76% Let it Rain (Parlez-moi de la pluie) (2010) " This wistful little film is at just the right temperature." — New York Magazine
Posted Jun 7, 2010
91% Joan Rivers: A Piece Of Work (2010) " This is a thoroughly exhilarating, thoroughly depressing portrait of the agony and ecstasy of celebrity." — New York Magazine
Posted Jun 7, 2010
94% Winter's Bone (2010) " For all the horror, it's the drive toward life, not the decay, that lingers in the mind. As a modern heroine, Ree Dolly has no peer, and Winter's Bone is the year's most stirring film." — New York Magazine
Posted Jun 7, 2010
53% Agora (2010) " Given all the weighty colloquia, Agora has remarkably few bad laughs, and the CGI re-creations of ancient Alexandria are so detailed I wanted to freeze the frame and linger on the city's layout." — New York Magazine
Posted May 24, 2010
82% Solitary Man (2010) " It's smoothly written and smartly paced, and Michael Douglas is riveting." — New York Magazine
Posted May 17, 2010
51% Holy Rollers (2010) " Holy Rollers fuses a somber, old-world palette with a jittery urban unease -- a good mix of tones. It's also wonderfully acted." — New York Magazine
Posted May 17, 2010
95% Best Worst Movie (2010) " It seems that the hunger for celebrity is so fierce that people will exploit anything -- even their most embarrassing moments -- to attain some measure of it." — New York Magazine
Posted May 10, 2010
90% Beetle Queen Conquers Tokyo (2009) " I'm not wholly clear on the link between a jellied green thing wriggling along a tree branch and the oneness of life, but Shinto Buddhist ruminations sound good in almost any context, and the film is entrancing." — New York Magazine
Posted May 10, 2010
83% Casino Jack And The United States Of Money (2010) " Casino Jack is audience-friendly without turning into a Michael Moore-ish clown show." — New York Magazine
Posted May 10, 2010
69% Babies (2010) " Presents itself as an ethnographic meditation on the first year of life but is better approached as an "oooooh" and "awww" fest..." — New York Magazine
Posted May 10, 2010
81% Anton Chekhov's The Duel (2010) " Though it's not all it could be, Anton Chekhov's The Duel is convincingly--yes--Chekhovian." — New York Magazine
Posted May 4, 2010
79% Mother and Child (2010) " Mother and Child is suffused with grief and loss. It's also suffused with compassion and insight." — New York Magazine
Posted May 3, 2010
73% Iron Man 2 (2010) " It doesn't come close to the emotional heft of those two rare 2s that outclassed their ones: Superman 2 and Spider-Man 2. But Iron Man 2 hums along quite nicely." — New York Magazine
Posted May 3, 2010
64% Harry Brown (2010) " Caine makes a grave, soulful vigilante avenger, and first-time director Daniel Barber gives the film a dank, streaky, genuinely unnerving palette." — New York Magazine
Posted Apr 26, 2010
87% Please Give (2010) " An engagingly high-strung comedy about lack of empathy and the gnawing guilt that can attend it." — New York Magazine
Posted Apr 26, 2010
74% Handsome Harry (2010) " David has honed this script for 30 years, and every word he utters is momentous. Handsome Harry transcends its somewhat melodramatic narrative." — New York Magazine
Posted Apr 19, 2010
76% Kick-Ass (2010) " Kick-Ass is a compendium of all sleazy things, and it sings like a siren to our inner Tarantinos." — New York Magazine
Posted Apr 12, 2010
96% Exit Through The Gift Shop (2010) " Narrated by Rhys Ifans with the dryness of a dessicated toad, Exit Through the Gift Shop is both an exhilarating testament to serendipity and an appalling testament to art-world inanity." — New York Magazine
Posted Apr 12, 2010
53% The Thorn in the Heart (2010) " This is an extraordinary film." — New York Magazine
Posted Apr 5, 2010
61% Leaves of Grass (2010) " Leaves of Grass is part goofy drug comedy, part shocking bloodbath. It's a riot of tones and genres, but unlike that other recent hybrid, Pineapple Express, the parts add up to something larger." — New York Magazine
Posted Mar 29, 2010
92% Vincere (2010) " The movie, a near-masterpiece, is a monument to intoxication: of sexual conquest, of military conquest, and, most of all, of cinema." — New York Magazine
Posted Mar 22, 2010
79% Office Space (1999) " A take-this-job-and-shove-it movie about the crushing malevolence of the corporate environment, it's on the verge of being really good." — Slate
Posted Mar 12, 2010
53% Green Zone (2010) " It's only the adrenaline-inducing techniques that conceal the lack of imagination." — New York Magazine
Posted Mar 8, 2010
84% The Art Of The Steal (2010) " Calculated to enrage and pulling it off like gangbusters..." — New York Magazine
Posted Mar 1, 2010
67% The Yellow Handkerchief (2010) " The first half of The Yellow Handkerchief is the half-movie of the year, and the rest isnâ(TM)t bad -- just more sentimental, more ordinary." — New York Magazine
Posted Mar 1, 2010
51% Alice in Wonderland (2010) " Burton, bless him, knows you can't CG a soul." — New York Magazine
Posted Mar 1, 2010
97% A Prophet (Un prophete) (2010) " Rahim is an exciting, unpredictable presence, and Arestrup's César has a stature that's nearly Shakespearean." — New York Magazine
Posted Feb 15, 2010
76% Kundun (1997) " The music ties together all the pretty pictures, gives the narrative some momentum, and helps to induce a kind of alert detachment, so that you're neither especially interested nor especially bored." — Slate
Posted Feb 1, 2010
58% Edge of Darkness (2010) " Edge of Darkness is a meathead revenge picture, but it's very satisfying." — New York Magazine
Posted Feb 1, 2010
74% Banlieue 13 - Ultimatum (District 13: Ultimatum) (2009) " It's campier than its predecessor, but its gung ho union of black, white, and Asian gangs against reactionaries who'd destroy them is a virtuosic assertion of punky Parisian multiculturalism." — New York Magazine
Posted Feb 1, 2010
37% From Paris with Love (2010) " Morel will inevitably be compared to John Woo, whom he trounces. He has fewer mannerisms and a keener eye; his fastest, most kinetic shots flow together like frames in a flipbook." — New York Magazine
Posted Feb 1, 2010
27% Extraordinary Measures (2010) " Anyway, I cried. A lot. What can I say? I'm a sucker for kids on ventilators." — New York Magazine
Posted Jan 25, 2010
38% Wonderful World (2010) " The movie is unfailingly likable and finally impressive. Goldin doesn't settle for easy answers, and he makes you think that no one should." — New York Magazine
Posted Jan 11, 2010
66% Youth in Revolt (2010) " I love this new breed of dirty movie. It goes beyond leering, beyond sexism, to the core tension of a culture that ricochets between Puritanism and promiscuity. And it has in Michael Cera a sterling mascot." — New York Magazine
Posted Jan 11, 2010
90% Fish Tank (2010) " The final scenes have a transcendent mixture of hope and sadness. I've never seen anything like Mia's final dance, or the leave-taking with her little sister that follows." — New York Magazine
Posted Jan 11, 2010
70% Sherlock Holmes (2009) " By now we've seen so many good, bad, and indifferent Sherlocks that it's almost a relief to get something different, however wrongheaded. And there's no such thing as too much Downey." — New York Magazine
Posted Dec 28, 2009
83% Avatar (2009) " The narrative would be ho-hum without the spectacle. But what spectacle! Avatar is dizzying, enveloping, vertiginous ... I ran out of adjectives an hour into its 161 minutes." — New York Magazine
Posted Dec 21, 2009
91% Up in the Air (2009) " Clooney -- slim, dark, perfectly tailored -- glamorizes insincerity in a way that makes you want to go out and lie." — New York Magazine
Posted Nov 30, 2009
62% Brothers (2009) " Sheridan pulls you so deep into Brothers so fast that there isn't time for the alarm bell to go off that says: "Warning! Another Traumatized-Vet Movie!" You never catch Sheridan or Benioff grandstanding, only observing." — New York Magazine
Posted Nov 30, 2009
50% Mammoth (Mammut) (2009) " Too many films exploit the perils faced by children when the social contract is ruptured, but Mammoth earns its cruel, sensationalistic turns and then some." — New York Magazine
Posted Nov 23, 2009
81% Broken Embraces (2009) " Pedro Almodóvar's Broken Embraces is a lush, deeply romantic noir dense with nods to films past, yet it plays as if it sprung fully formed from the director's unconscious." — New York Magazine
Posted Nov 23, 2009
88% Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call New Orleans (2009) " If there's a sure thing in movies, it's that if you cast Nicolas Cage in a role in which he goes crazy, he'll rise to the occasion and keep on rising until he seems even loonier than his character." — New York Magazine
Posted Nov 16, 2009
Showing 1 - 50 of 977
Previous | Next
  • Sort by Rating:

    Sort results by this critic's rating. This option is only available for critics with a rating system (4 star, letter grade, 1-10, etc.)

  • Sort by T-meter:

    Sort results by the Tomatometer (percentage of critics recommending a certain movie)

Help | About | Jobs | Critics Submission | API | Licensing | Mobile