Ed Gibbs

Ed Gibbs

Agrees with the Tomatometer 80% of the time.

Biography:
Ed Gibbs has been a film and music critic for over 15 years, both in London and Sydney. A film fanatic since childhood, he studied film in Scotland and the US (while running a cinema club, for good measure). As a magazine editor, events programmer and media consultant, he was instrumental in relaunching leading mastheads for the Australian market, including GQ, having cut his teeth in London across industry titles. Now a popular mainstay on the international festival circuit, he writes and broadcasts for The Sun-Herald and The Sunday Age (as their resident film critic); their daily counterparts The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age; film bible Empire; its musical cousin Rolling Stone; various news outlets in London (The Guardian, The Independent), as well as media in the Middle East and beyond. A regular voice on television and radio, he?s also currently working across a number of original features, shorts and documentary projects for TV and theatrical release.
Publications:
Empire Magazine , Empire Magazine Australasia , Guardian [UK] , Rotten Tomatoes , Sydney Morning Herald , The Age (Australia) , The National , The Sun Herald , The Sunday Age
Total Reviews:
188

Worst Reviewed Films

Showing 1 - 50 of 188
Previous | Next
Rating T-Meter Title | Year Add Date
1/10 11% Gone (2012) " There's little to recommend this B-grade, formulaic affair. The plot is tosh, the dialogue hackneyed at best. " — The National
Posted Feb 29, 2012
1/10 2% One for the Money (2012) " With yet another ho-hum run at the multiplexes, Katherine Heigl's big-screen resumé is fast looking like an insider's gag. " — The Sun Herald
Posted Feb 19, 2012
1/10 12% The Darkest Hour (2011) " The title of this teen disaster-by-numbers affair could not be more apt - as a collective omen for all those involved" — The Sun Herald
Posted Jan 24, 2012
1/5 —— Interior. Leather Bar. () " Interior. Leather Bar ultimately rings hollow in its diatribe and agenda because its chief instigator refuses to open up." — Guardian [UK]
Posted Jan 21, 2013
1/5 12% Alex Cross (2012) " Late-night TV fodder for insomniacs, perhaps, nothing more." — The National
Posted Oct 31, 2012
1/5 22% The Words (2012) " A dreadful misfire, particularly for Cooper, who is otherwise pursuing an interesting career trajectory away from The Hangover series. " — The National
Posted Oct 5, 2012
1/5 13% W.E. (2012) " Madonna, for all her faults, cast this self-funded feature with uncharacteristic cinematic poise. Otherwise, though, it's a disappointment" — The National
Posted Feb 15, 2012
2/10 3% Jack and Jill (2011) " Hastily assembled, uneven and severely lacking in charm and laughs, Jack and Jill is one of Sandler's weakest outings to date. Which is saying something." — The Sun Herald
Posted Dec 4, 2011
1/5 11% Killers (2010) " A bloated mess that's not remotely funny -- or suspenseful." — Empire Magazine Australasia
Posted Jul 27, 2010
1.5/5 55% Bachelorette (2012) " Unpleasant, repellent viewing that, surprisingly, offers only repugnant characters and toxic protagonists, nothing more." — The Sunday Age
Posted Oct 28, 2012
3/10 54% Dr Seuss' The Lorax (2012) " Given its inevitable merchandise tie-ins, this animated eco-preachy affair carries with it more than a whiff of questionable intent." — The Sun Herald
Posted Mar 25, 2012
3/10 11% Hoodwinked Too! Hood vs Evil (2011) " As with the wicked witch, there's something inherently untrustworthy, even slapdash, about this whole affair." — The Sun Herald
Posted Dec 18, 2011
3/10 54% The Inbetweeners (2012) " It manages to spectacularly abandon all its small-screen smarts and charm. " — The Sun Herald
Posted Dec 10, 2011
3/10 61% The Beaver (2011) " This is a wholly wasted opportunity for Gibson -- and a disappointing misfire from Foster." — Sydney Morning Herald
Posted Aug 1, 2011
2/5 75% Goddess () " Surprisingly, it is singer Ronan Keating who provides the sole saving grace, in a film that otherwise chokes and splutters with cliches and tired routines." — The Sunday Age
Posted Mar 10, 2013
4/10 64% Anna Karenina (2012) " Wright's staged version tries desperately to gain one's attention (which it does) and engage one's affection (which it doesn't)." — The Sun Herald
Posted Feb 10, 2013
2/5 67% A.C.O.D. () " Stu Zicherman's amusing but formulaic man-in-crisis comedy has neither a fully realised protagonist nor a clear message." — Guardian [UK]
Posted Jan 30, 2013
2/5 43% jOBS () " This is far from the bomb some would have envisaged, but neither is it the character illumination one would wish for." — Guardian [UK]
Posted Jan 28, 2013
2/5 39% Here Comes the Boom (2012) " There's hardly a serious message being made about the plight of America's education system here, which makes one wonder what the point of it is." — The National
Posted Oct 31, 2012
2/5 43% To Rome with Love (2012) " A largely forgettable letdown that could have, should have been a contender." — The Sunday Age
Posted Oct 14, 2012
2/5 51% Savages (2012) " Although typically loud, brash and flat-footed, the Oscar-winning filmmaker oddly opts for hokey romance over stinging critique. " — The National
Posted Sep 30, 2012
2/5 74% Hope Springs (2012) " While it may feel familiar to some, such awkward home truths do not a great viewing experience make. Jones is bereft of charm, while Streep seems misplaced as his loyal wife. " — The National
Posted Sep 19, 2012
2/5 16% The Watch (2012) " This little-green-men mash-up shows that in space, no one can hear you laugh." — The Sunday Age
Posted Sep 9, 2012
2/5 83% The Chef (Comme un chef) () " This is French farce in its most straightforward form, rather than the radical, cutting satire some would wish for." — The National
Posted Aug 4, 2012
2/5 29% Bel Ami (2012) " A trifle of a romp, strictly for Pattinson obsessives who can't hold out until November (when Twilight takes its final bow)." — The Sunday Age
Posted May 20, 2012
4/10 26% Arthur (2011) " In this rehash of the 1981 smash - which featured fellow English comic Dudley Moore in the title role - Brand looks and sounds comparatively bland." — The Sun Herald
Posted Dec 18, 2011
2/5 0% Winnie (2012) " The source material is Anne Marie du Preez Bezdrob's biography, and the period detail is spot on. Yet Winnie: the movie opts to wear its heart openly on its sleeve, and play it absurdly safe." — Guardian [UK]
Posted Sep 21, 2011
5/10 40% The Call (2013) " A tense psychological chiller that ratchets up the tension before collapsing with a predictable finale." — The Sun Herald
Posted May 12, 2013
2.5/5 38% Hyde Park on Hudson (2012) " The issue of FDR's fidelity remains a thorny topic for traditionalists and historians, never mind the light, fluffy - and ultimately disposable - version of events." — The Sunday Age
Posted Mar 24, 2013
5/10 37% The Incredible Burt Wonderstone (2013) " Bizarrely, its biggest flaw lies with casting. Carrell is too familiar to convince as a Lothario, Buscemi looks vaguely lost, while Carrey is too long in the tooth. " — The Sun Herald
Posted Mar 17, 2013
2.5/5 68% Great Expectations (2013) " A fresh rendering of the Dickens classic, designed to mark the 200th anniversary of the writer's birth, plays it far too safe to ever challenge Lean's definitive take." — The Sunday Age
Posted Mar 10, 2013
5/10 30% Broken City (2013) " Aside from feeling bemused and confused by the end, the web of deceit that's presented is not even vaguely believable." — The Sun Herald
Posted Mar 10, 2013
2.5/5 46% The Sweeney (2013) " Fans of the original 1970s TV show will not be amused. Casual observers may simply shrug with indifference. " — The Sunday Age
Posted Feb 10, 2013
2.5/5 63% Hitchcock (2012) " Disappointingly flat. Hitchcock the man feels best left where he himself enjoyed being most: behind the camera." — The Sunday Age
Posted Jan 6, 2013
5/10 49% The Man With the Iron Fists (2012) " Crowe has a blast - and has never been better - in this oversteamed paean to chop-socky classics. With its severe edit, though, the narrative proves almost incomprehensible." — The Sun Herald
Posted Dec 2, 2012
2.5/5 87% Arbitrage (2012) " It boasts solid performances from Gere and Sarandon, yet feels overly familiar, even predictable, at times. " — The Sunday Age
Posted Sep 23, 2012
2.5/5 31% Total Recall (2012) " Wiseman loves a chase - the film is littered with them - but forgets the rest. The author Philip K Dick would not be impressed, although Farrell emerges unscathed." — The National
Posted Aug 31, 2012
5/10 31% Total Recall (2012) " The film's downfall lies in its inability to do anything more than titillate with a continuous series of chase sequences." — The Sun Herald
Posted Aug 26, 2012
2.5/5 40% Tonight You're Mine (2012) " We're left with the deflated feeling that we've witnessed something initially promising that proves wholly inconsequential." — The Sunday Age
Posted Jul 15, 2012
5/10 38% Dark Shadows (2012) " If Burton had ever worried that his celebrated brand of eccentricity might one day feel dated or even irrelevant, that unthinkable day may indeed have come." — The Sun Herald
Posted May 13, 2012
5/10 67% Trishna (2012) " Despite some typical visual flair, and an affecting soundtrack to boot, Trishna lacks the emotional punch of Hardy's novel, with Pinto and Ahmed's pairing feeling contrived." — The Sun Herald
Posted May 6, 2012
5/10 20% The Lucky One (2012) " Sparks's books are more Mills & Boon than The Deer Hunter, with his characters little more than mere sketches. Only the women even vaguely register dramatically here. " — The Sun Herald
Posted Apr 15, 2012
2.5/5 68% This Must Be The Place (2012) " The film seems to be aiming for a whimsical flourish on an otherwise unpleasant subject. Its premiere at Cannes met with a mixed response. I remain underwhelmed." — The Sunday Age
Posted Apr 9, 2012
5/10 75% The Adventures of Tintin (2011) " After all the expectation, this Tintin feels strangely flat and lifeless. A War Horse it is not." — The Sun Herald
Posted Dec 18, 2011
3/5 56% Oblivion (2013) " Joseph Kosinski's ode to classic 1970s sci-fi lacks serious tension, but does offer visual flair and elegance, with a typically arresting performance from Andrea Riseborough." — The Sunday Age
Posted Apr 14, 2013
6/10 80% Warm Bodies (2013) " An occasionally funny romantic zombie comedy (or rom-zom-com) that offers a fresh twist on Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet." — The Sun Herald
Posted Apr 7, 2013
3/5 78% Thérèse Desqueyroux (2013) " A respectable swansong for the late Claude Miller, who passed away just weeks before it premiered at Cannes. " — The Sunday Age
Posted Apr 7, 2013
6/10 68% Trance (2013) " A hugely entertaining but dreadfully convoluted crime romp, in which logic flies out the door as wandering illusions of the mind take hold. " — The Sun Herald
Posted Mar 31, 2013
6/10 45% Beautiful Creatures (2013) " LaGravenese elicits some wonderfully hammy turns, particularly from Irons and Thompson, although a tighter edit wouldn't have gone amiss" — The Sun Herald
Posted Feb 24, 2013
3/5 68% Great Expectations (2013) " Faithfully and tastefully performed, without ever threatening the legacy of David Lean's definitive 1946 version." — The National
Posted Jan 16, 2013
Showing 1 - 50 of 188
Previous | Next
  • Sort by Rating:

    Sort results by this critic's rating. This option is only available for critics with a rating system (4 star, letter grade, 1-10, etc.)

  • Sort by T-meter:

    Sort results by the Tomatometer (percentage of critics recommending a certain movie)

Help | About | Jobs | Critics Submission | API | Licensing | Mobile