Gabriel Shanks

Gabriel Shanks

""The story is the star." - William Goldman"

Agrees with the Tomatometer 72% of the time.

Biography:
Gabriel is a resident film critic at Modern Fabulousity (http://modernfabulousity.blogspot.com) and for That's Life Magazine. He was a founder of Cinemarati: The Web Alliance for Film Commentary and has written for Mixed Reviews, That's Life Mag, and the Village Voice. He is a member of the Online Film Critics Society.
Favorites:
Auntie Mame, Apocalypse Now, Singin' in the Rain, Lilies, Dog Day Afternoon. Recent movies: Spring Summer Fall Winter and Spring, Solaris, Raising Victor Vargas, No Country For Old Men.
Publications:
Mixed Reviews , Modern Fabulousity
Total Reviews:
262
Total QuickRatings:
14
Location:
New York City

Listing Of All Reviews & Articles

Showing 51 - 100 of 262
Rating T-Meter Title | Year Add Date
C 76% Transamerica (2006) " Issues of gender differrence are employed only to reinforce less original dilemmas -- family dysfunction, dating woes and (eek) meeting the grandparents." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Oct 30, 2005
A+ 50% The Dying Gaul (2005) " Rarely has a film exposed the tender, brutal line between love and cruelty so magnificently." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Oct 30, 2005
B 89% Paradise Now (2005) " Essential cinema not because it answers questions about terrorist ideology, but because it discovers those questions are disturbingly similar to those about ourselves." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Oct 30, 2005
A 84% Mysterious Skin (2005) " A raw and unadorned look at child abuse and its idiosyncratic repercussions." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Oct 30, 2005
B 57% Breakfast on Pluto (2005) " Effortlessly nailing coquettish mannerisms and employing a hilarious come-hither vocal quality, Murphy is magnetizing, fascinating, and eminently likeable." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Oct 30, 2005
B+ 68% North Country (2005) " An unusually taut film about misogyny that, for the most part, escapes the clichés that often bog down the battle of the sexes." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Sep 29, 2005
69% The Adventures of Felix (Drôle de Félix) (2001) Mixed Reviews
Posted Sep 28, 2005
B-- 65% Dorian Blues (2005) " Ultimately has little insight into the experience it chronicles. News flash: growing up gay is rough. Who did not know this already?" — Mixed Reviews
Posted Sep 19, 2005
C- 43% Three Dancing Slaves (Le Clan) (2005) " Darkly rich in character and mood, provocative in intent...but ultimately foiled by inattention to its own story." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Aug 6, 2005
C- 33% The Baxter (2005) " It argues, ironically, that pretty people should only end up with pretty people, and the best we can do is hope that the temp with bad hair will find us equally nerd-hot." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Aug 1, 2005
B 38% The Brothers Grimm (2005) " Bombastic, whimsical, and delicious, The Brothers Grimm is really a comic ghost story wrapped in the postmodern folds of Shakespeare In Love." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Aug 1, 2005
C 26% Fantastic Four (2005) " You can feel the flopsweat of the screenwriters, laboring to make their jokes work and their scenes interesting." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jul 7, 2005
B+ 82% Hustle & Flow (2005) " Meditative and fierce, quiet and pounding, HUSTLE AND FLOW runs the board in a way that few films even attempt." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jul 1, 2005
D 74% War of the Worlds (2005) " The man who gave human dimension to the effects of holocaust in Schindler's List has now prostituted human extermination for entertainment. Bread and circuses, indeed." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jul 1, 2005
A 55% Lords of Dogtown (2005) " Reaches beyond the cinematic frame as far as it can to catch big air, giving its audience a you-are-there viscerality." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jun 4, 2005
C+ 86% Howl's Moving Castle (2005) " The straightforward narrative constantly seems at odds with Miyazaki's dreamy landscapes and fanciful flourishes." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jun 3, 2005
C 64% Heights (2005) " At times the film seems to have nothing more on its mind than the predictable rhythms of soap opera." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jun 3, 2005
C- 39% Kingdom of Heaven (2005) " Ultimately, KINGDOM OF HEAVEN can't change actual history. So instead, everyone has to grow a conscience...even the Crusaders have to feel bad about the Crusading." — Mixed Reviews
Posted May 8, 2005
B+ 80% Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith 3D (2013) " An unexpectedly sweet pleasure... a dark and gripping slice of space opera, it successfully avoids the pitfalls of its predecessors." — Mixed Reviews
Posted May 5, 2005
B+ 78% Sin City (2005) " As close to a museum-quality work of visual art as Hollywood as ever seen." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Apr 5, 2005
B- 90% Kung Fu Hustle (2005) " With everything bigger and grander in Chow's singular universe, it's easy to overlook one small detail...that Kung Fu Hustle is less satisfying than its predecessors." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Mar 20, 2005
C 64% Bride and Prejudice (2005) " It's got moments, it's got performances to recommend, but they still haven't figured out how to create the magic of Bollywood in a form for the US market." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Mar 6, 2005
B+ 64% Robots (2005) " A smart, snappy energy to the dialogue that gives the film a zesty flavor rarely found in the genre." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Mar 6, 2005
A 44% Nabbeun namja (Bad Guy) (2001) " Desire, violence, revenge, and obsession play out against a map of sex and love." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Feb 14, 2005
D+ 5% Harry + Max (Harry and Max) (2005) " You can almost hear the filmmakers exhale with nervous relief, having made it through a film about incest without actually having an opinion on the subject." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jan 25, 2005
C 72% William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice (2004) " Radford has made a grim drama with some incomprehensible moments of failed levity." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Dec 12, 2004
C- 88% The Woodsman (2004) " Although The Woodsman's subject matter is shocking and disturbing, perhaps the most unsettling quality is its matter-of-fact attitude" — Mixed Reviews
Posted Dec 7, 2004
A 59% Enduring Love (2004) " Love is a delicate thing, and identity even more so. Enduring Love breathtakingly tears both asunder to find them anew...it is, in a word, exquisite." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Dec 5, 2004
C+ 43% Beyond the Sea (2004) " A vain attempt not only to restore Darin's place in history, but to improve upon it... Colick's underdeveloped screenplay has trouble placing Darin's life onto a heroic scale." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Nov 28, 2004
B+ 68% The Assassination of Richard Nixon (2004) " A moving, poignant parable of another America, where the dreams aren't quite so rosy." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Nov 25, 2004
C 84% The Sea Inside (Mar Adentro) (The Sea Within) (2004) " As beautiful, assured, and professional as it is, the film lacks edge and power, ending up being significantly less affecting than it should be." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Nov 20, 2004
29% Last Dance (1996) Mixed Reviews
Posted Nov 17, 2004
B 90% Kinsey (2004) " Instead of approaching the radical and groundbreaking scientist with an equally innovative spirit, Condon's film opts for the generic trademarks of biopic melodrama." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Nov 14, 2004
C- 96% Sideways (2004) " It is, in almost every way, less than it could or should be." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Nov 14, 2004
A- 80% Last Dance (2002) " Stripped of pretentions, Last Dance offers up a wholly human, tantalizingly imperfect struggle to create beauty and resonance." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Nov 9, 2004
B+ 83% Finding Neverland (2004) " Intertwines imaginative fantasy with real life -- and like Neverland itself, it is a beguiling, intoxicating mix." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Oct 29, 2004
A 88% Bad Education (La Mala educación) (2004) " Even when he's paying homage to other great filmmakers, it still remains an indisputably Almodovar experience." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Oct 27, 2004
B+ 73% Primer (2004) " There are stumbles in this twisting science fiction tale about the perils of prescience, but even so, Primer is one of the most auspicious debuts in recent memory." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Oct 11, 2004
B 62% I Heart Huckabees (2004) " Think of it less as a deconstruction of philosophies, and more like an episode of Last Comic Standing where the jokesters are Nietzsche, Heidegger and Kant." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Oct 11, 2004
A+ 88% House of Flying Daggers (2004) " Yimou's explosive imagination threatens to burst the seams of the movie screen...sublime, luscious filmmaking." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Oct 11, 2004
C 76% Tropical Malady (2005) " A purposefully incomplete vision of magic, myth, and love that requires the viewer to fill in the gaps." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Oct 6, 2004
C++ 55% Undertow (2004) " Lacks the gravity and the power to transcend its genre roots." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Oct 5, 2004
B- 63% Stage Beauty (2004) " one can see the potential in the idea of Stage Beauty, as well as the lines that demarcate Eyre's moderately good film from the extraordinary one it could have been." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Sep 27, 2004
C+ 92% Vera Drake (2004) " Even with his film's solid foundation, Leigh seemingly cannot resist the pulpy histrionics." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Sep 25, 2004
C 76% Being Julia (2004) " If A Room with a View looked inside the repressed passions of its characters, Being Julia seems content to just put a frame around them and call it a day." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Sep 23, 2004
B+ 72% Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow (2004) " Both a throwback and a leap forward, an odd yet satisfying marriage of now and then." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Sep 21, 2004
A- 84% The Motorcycle Diaries (Diarios de Motocicleta) (2004) " Eloquently and remarkably captures the budding ethical, emotional, and political sensibilities of a legendary man of history." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Sep 5, 2004
A- 95% Mou gaan dou (Infernal Affairs) (2002) " Recalls classics like Serpico and The French Connection, but features a contemporary sophistication and of-the-moment vivacity that sets it apart." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Sep 3, 2004
D+ 0% Merci Docteur Rey (2002) " Lacks the sophistication it needs to be truly effective, hopelessly lost in its unfunny gags and weak plotting." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Sep 2, 2004
B- 57% Cowboys & Angels (2003) " Without anything unique to add to the dramatic landscape, Gleeson's film is a fleeting glimpse at a world we already know...it is a film in search of a reason to exist." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Sep 2, 2004
C+ 70% Criminal (2004) " Produced by Soderbergh, Criminal bears an uncanny resemblance to the master's films." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Sep 1, 2004
B 85% Outfoxed - Rupert Murdoch's War on Journalism (2004) " If Michael Moore is the shaggy dog hero of the Left these days, then Robert Greenwald is the pit bull." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Aug 18, 2004
B 51% Code 46 (2004) " On one level it's a science fiction story about cloning...but on another level, it's a complex discussion of authoritarianism in a global economy." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Aug 9, 2004
A- 72% Open Water (2004) " The filmmakers' remarkable storytelling is not lost amidst the terrors of the deep; what emerges is a glimpse into the psychological struggle when faced with unwinnable odds." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Aug 4, 2004
C 81% The Manchurian Candidate (2004) " Even in Hollywood, the more things change (technology, end of the Cold War, corporate influence), the more things stay the same (greed, avarice, powerlust)." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Aug 2, 2004
B 86% Collateral (2004) " From its classy, crisp opening moments, Collateral bombards the viewer with bold imagery and sounds...we are in Mann country." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Aug 1, 2004
B+ 81% The Bourne Supremacy (2004) " A buffed-up, kick-a** version of our modern collective consciousness." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jul 24, 2004
C 58% I, Robot (2004) " Despite an admirable effort on the part of its creative team, this new technological thriller is at odds with itself from the very first moments." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jul 18, 2004
C- 36% Touch of Pink (2004) " I'd like to believe that the world has moved past being scandalized by otherness -- Those nutty Indians! Those outrageous gays! -- but Touch of Pink doesn't think so." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jul 18, 2004
A 48% A Home at the End of the World (2004) " The finest cinematic study of relationships to come along in quite some time." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jul 13, 2004
B 31% King Arthur (2004) " Makes an argument against religious absolutism, against the prideful righteousness that was part of Christianity at the time...and, implicitly, of modern-day Christianity." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jul 7, 2004
A- 95% Before Sunset (2004) " Before Sunset has an immediacy that makes other movies feel comatose." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jul 3, 2004
C- 43% The Clearing (2004) " A thriller nearly devoid of thrills...Despite having great actors and a beautiful visual sensibility, The Clearing offers no foundation to wrap them around." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jul 1, 2004
B 48% De-Lovely (2004) " Delightful, and delicious, and probably for most mass audiences, de-irritating. As Cole might have said, however...there's no accounting for taste." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jun 24, 2004
D+ 43% I'll Sleep When I'm Dead (2004) " A languid study in remorse and revenge that loses its way pretty quickly, sludging through an impenetrable veneer of icy listlessness." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jun 24, 2004
C- 92% Tarnation (2004) " Tarnation coalesces into a pop-art diary, the self-made soap opera, the arthouse version of a reality show. A fascinating but bloated movie." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jun 22, 2004
B- 71% Napoleon Dynamite (2004) " The most fascinating outcast since Harold and Maude. Trouble is, Harold and Maude were going someplace; their story had a direction." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jun 3, 2004
B+ 88% Tying the Knot (2004) " Exhibits an accomplished maturity from the first-time director, deftly applying a dry wit, a healthy sense of irony, and a nonexploitive approach to emotionality." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jun 2, 2004
B+ 50% Samaria (Samaritan Girl) (2004) " A wholly unique tale that gives expressive voice to the pains of childhood and the parents forced to bear witness. " — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jun 2, 2004
B- 53% Bulgarian Lovers (2003) " Won't leave you disappointed, but it may leave you hungry for something more substantial." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jun 1, 2004
B 67% Sleepy Hollow (1999) " Burton's visual sensibilties are always breathtaking." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Jun 1, 2004
C+ 61% Saved! (2004) " Not without its charms, but it's a middling effort...In Hollywood, the road to cinematic hell is paved with great pitch ideas." — Mixed Reviews
Posted May 30, 2004
D 21% Poco più di un anno fa (Adored: Diary of a Porn Star) (2003) " An unfortunate exercise in ego run amok, coupled with inexperience and ineptitude." — Mixed Reviews
Posted May 28, 2004
A- 45% The Day After Tomorrow (2004) " Emmerich's escapist fantasy is a global catastrophe as thrillingly scary as it is tremendously entertaining." — Mixed Reviews
Posted May 24, 2004
B- 75% The Other Side of the Street (2004) " An eloquent social statement, quietly railing against an uncaring and increasingly impersonal society that overlooks the humanity in all of us." — Mixed Reviews
Posted May 23, 2004
B- 63% À cause d'un garçon (You'll Get Over It) (2002) " Resonates with earnest truthfulness and packs a surprising dramatic punch." — Mixed Reviews
Posted May 21, 2004
B- 54% Troy (2004) " Inspired by one of the great pieces of classic literature, it's pure Hollywood formula. Just barely worthwhile." — Mixed Reviews
Posted May 16, 2004
A- 89% Shrek 2 (2004) " More than a worthy successor to the original, and more than just a modern-day fairy tale." — Mixed Reviews
Posted May 13, 2004
B+ 77% Bear Cub (Cachorro) (2004) " A complex, finely woven tale of nontraditional family. Such enjoyments are far too rare." — Mixed Reviews
Posted May 11, 2004
F 21% The 24th Day (2004) " An ethically repugnant, relentlessly monotonous chamber drama that manages the difficult trick of boring and irritating its viewers simultaneously." — Mixed Reviews
Posted May 11, 2004
B+ 77% The Mother (2004) " Roger Michell may be the most underrated director working today." — Mixed Reviews
Posted May 6, 2004
B 68% Searching for the Wrong-Eyed Jesus (2005) " Entrancing cinematography is accompanied by what is, hands down, the best film music of 2004...underscores the brutality of being left out of the American Dream." — Mixed Reviews
Posted May 5, 2004
D+ 87% Zatôichi (The Blind Swordsman: Zatoichi) (2003) " Zatoichi finds a legacy diminished by his new, updated masters. " — Mixed Reviews
Posted May 4, 2004
B- 96% Control Room (2004) " Reveals the humanity of the opponents on both sides...and government's attempt to deny that humanity at all costs." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Apr 29, 2004
B+ 93% Super Size Me (2004) " Spurlock's light touch keeps Super Size Me entertaining and educational, without sacrificing one for the other. " — Mixed Reviews
Posted Apr 28, 2004
A+ 76% Brother to Brother (2004) " May just be the most sophisticated and compelling movie about the lives of black gay men ever made." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Apr 27, 2004
B- 91% Baadasssss! (2003) " While Mario Van Peebles' gauzy adoration for his father causes BAADASSSSS! to be less defined than it should be, the obvious affection makes the uneven film heartfelt." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Apr 26, 2004
C- —— Bored in Brno () " Subtitled "a comedy about defying fate," Bored in Brno really should have spent more time trying to defy conventionality. " — Mixed Reviews
Posted Apr 24, 2004
B- 26% Poster Boy (2006) " By the final half-hour, Poster Boy manages a surprising amount of magnetism." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Apr 23, 2004
B 80% America Brown (2004) " The rites of passage into adulthood have rarely been so textured." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Apr 22, 2004
B- 64% Coffee and Cigarettes (2004) " The short films in this collection are dreamily affecting curiosities, stilted and just enough off-kilter to keep the viewer attentive." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Apr 21, 2004
C 44% Connie And Carla (2004) " So cliché-ridden and obvious that any sparks the performers may have are quickly smothered in dullness." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Apr 21, 2004
B- 84% Kill Bill, Volume 2 (2004) " VOL. 1 was inherently more fun -- more action, more style, more cool combat -- but even so, this latest effort is deeper, more resonant, and more complex." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Apr 14, 2004
C- 30% The Alamo (2004) " As exciting as a big, flat cyclorama exhibit at your local historical society. " — Mixed Reviews
Posted Apr 11, 2004
A+ 95% Spring, Summer, Fall, Winter... and Spring (2003) " Arrives with the gale force winds that signal a major new international talent in Kim Ki-Duk." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Apr 10, 2004
C- 39% Seeing Other People (2004) " Feels like an extended pilot episode for a not-quite-Thirtysomething series: meandering plots and wacky supporting players." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Apr 8, 2004
B- 90% This So-Called Disaster: Sam Shepard Directs the Late Henry Moss (2004) " Perhaps the most shocking revelation is that an artist of Shepherd's stature can still feel unsure of himself, fumbling his way to a constantly refining vision of his world." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Apr 8, 2004
C+ 55% The Ladykillers (2004) " Skimming the surface of its subjects, The Ladykillers is really little more than an acting showcase for its ensemble." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Apr 2, 2004
C 24% Walking Tall (2004) " There are points to be made about the rapidly transforming cultural landscape, but painting them with Color-By-Numbers simplicity is neither entertaining nor interesting." — Mixed Reviews
Posted Mar 30, 2004
Showing 51 - 100 of 262
  • Sort by Rating:

    Sort results by this critic's rating. This option is only available for critics with a rating system (4 star, letter grade, 1-10, etc.)

  • Sort by T-meter:

    Sort results by the Tomatometer (percentage of critics recommending a certain movie)

Help | About | Jobs | Critics Submission | API | Licensing | Mobile