Jeffrey Overstreet

""If Jesus came back and saw what was being done in his name, he'd never stop throwing up." - Max Von Sydow in "Hannah and Her Sisters""

Agrees with the Tomatometer 81% of the time.

Biography:
Jeffrey Overstreet's first book about his career as a film critic--"Through a Screen Darkly"--is now available at Amazon.com and fine bookstores everywhere. Publisher's Weekly gave the book a coveted "Starred Review." His first novel--"Auralia's Colors"--is due from Random House in Sept. '07. Jeffrey publishes frequent film and music reviews at LookingCloser.org and lookingcloser.wordpress.com, and reviews films for Christianity Today, Paste, Risen, and Seattle Pacific University's "Response" Magazine.
Favorites:
Wings of Desire, Raiders of the Lost Ark, Three Colors: Blue, The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring, Code Unknown, Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Back, Apocalypse Now Redux, The New World, The Fisher King, Midnight Run, Blade Runner, Monty Python and the Holy Grail, Stevie, Down by Law, Into Great Silence.
Publications:
Christianity Today , Comment , Filmwell , Image , Looking Closer , Paste Magazine , Patheos , Response
Total Reviews:
595
Total QuickRatings:
1
Location:
Shoreline, Washington

Worst Reviewed Films

Showing 1 - 50 of 595
Previous | Next
Rating T-Meter Title | Year Add Date
F 19% The Life of David Gale (2003) " The filmmakers work so hard to bewilder and to preach that they give us no opportunity to think clearly about the serious life-and-death issues that the film claims to address." — Looking Closer
Posted Jan 15, 2005
0/4 9% Catwoman (2004) " The summer that gave us what is arguably the best comic book movie of all time -- Spider-Man 2 -- has now choked up what is arguably the worst." — Looking Closer
Posted Jul 23, 2004
D- 33% Entropy (1999) " Since the main character makes foolish decisions, and then makes worse decisions, his pleas for our sympathy are annoying and unsuccessful." — Looking Closer
Posted Sep 21, 2007
D- 30% Dreamcatcher (2003) " I challenge you to name a movie with a more convoluted or preposterous storyline." — Looking Closer
Posted Jan 15, 2005
0.5/4 8% The Reaping (2007) " When Ben exclaims, 'There's still three plagues to go! We gotta get outta here!', most viewers will have already come to that same conclusion..." — Christianity Today
Posted Apr 5, 2007
D 0% Hangman's Curse (2003) " ... [these] are Christian filmmakers stooping to use the same manipulative storytelling tactics that anti-Christian filmmakers often use to express their own bias." — Christianity Today
Posted Sep 19, 2007
D 40% The Island (2005) " It seems to assume that its audience is made of idiots, constantly reminding us of the simple plot details and having characters define things for each other." — Looking Closer
Posted Sep 12, 2007
D 78% Sin City (2005) " Eager to blaze trails for desktop moviemaking, what did these artists do? Throw fuel on the fires of viewers' basest appetites." — Looking Closer
Posted Sep 7, 2007
D 62% Arlington Road (1999) " It merely exploits our fears and emotions to jerk us around." — Looking Closer
Posted Jan 15, 2005
D 43% Anger Management (2003) " [It's] like going to the NBA All-Star Game and seeing a fantastic team take the floor, but when the game begins you realize they left their brains in the locker room." — Looking Closer
Posted Jan 15, 2005
D 54% Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back (2001) " I feel a strange disturbance in the Force." — Looking Closer
Posted Jan 15, 2005
D 45% The Cell (2000) " It's not the villain but the director who seems most interested in these grisly spectacles. He was certainly uninterested in his characters." — Looking Closer
Posted Jan 15, 2005
D 39% Men in Black II (2002) " Sadly, the movie has no new ideas worth mentioning." — Looking Closer
Posted Jan 15, 2005
D 51% Kiss of the Dragon (2001) " We are coaxed to rejoice in the name of vengeance." — Looking Closer
Posted Jan 15, 2005
D 57% From Hell (2001) " They want it to feel like one really bad dream ... and by the film's end we're too dizzy to think, to see if it all lines up." — Looking Closer
Posted Jan 15, 2005
D 68% Red Dragon (2002) " Hopkins should know better than to lessen the impact of these performances with redundant encores." — Looking Closer
Posted Jan 15, 2005
D 41% K-PAX (2001) " It tries to frighten us into doing the right thing by declaring that there is no grace, no forgiveness, and no escape from our lives once we are done living." — Looking Closer
Posted Jan 15, 2005
D 42% The Fighting Temptations (2003) " You might think this prodigal would learn to take responsibility for his lies ... or humbly accept the consequences of his crimes and change. Nope." — Looking Closer
Posted Jan 15, 2005
D 54% What Dreams May Come (1998) " This is what happens when you try to make a philosophical movie about spirituality without making anybody uncomfortable." — Looking Closer
Posted Jan 15, 2005
D 73% Snatch (2001) " It's rather like the favorite pastime of this movie's villain ... throwing wild dogs into a pit and watching them fight until there's only one left standing." — Looking Closer
Posted Dec 6, 2004
1/4 27% Evening (2007) " Evening feels artificial from the very first shot. ... It looks like a contest to see which actress can shed the [Oscar-winng] tears. " — Christianity Today
Posted Jun 29, 2007
81% Oldboy (2005) " Its tentacles are still wriggling in my memory, as if I just ate something that should never have been served in the first place." — Looking Closer
Posted Oct 31, 2005
D+ 61% American Pie (1999) " American Pie is the latest in a long tradition of immature, self-indulgent comedies that celebrate the recklessness of adolescents." — Looking Closer
Posted Jan 15, 2005
C- 33% Terminator Salvation (2009) " This franchise, like its villains, has become more machine than man. " — Filmwell
Posted Jun 15, 2012
C- 44% Casa de mi padre (2012) " It's not just boring ... it's frustrating, because we now how much better Ferrell can be when he's given creative material." — Looking Closer
Posted Mar 17, 2012
C- 38% Cars 2 (2011) " Cars dazzled my eyes and warmed my heart. Cars 2 ... inspired resistance instead of welcome." — Looking Closer
Posted Nov 23, 2011
C- 57% X-Men: The Last Stand (2006) " When Jean Grey starts gasping, 'Kill me!' it's like she's the voice of the franchise...." — Looking Closer
Posted Jun 21, 2006
C- 87% Brokeback Mountain (2005) " Essentially, [this] is the same as most stories of lust and infidelity -- two people who 'can't control' their desires end up hurting others, lying, and denying responsibility for their actions." — Looking Closer
Posted Dec 30, 2005
C- 52% Titan A.E. (2000) " ... flat characters, flat animation, a bland rock soundtrack ... Titan A.E. might as well be Titanic A.E. (as in, the ship that sunk, not the movie that scored.)" — Looking Closer
Posted Jan 15, 2005
C- 52% The Lost World - Jurassic Park (1997) " If you liked Jurassic Park, you'll probably like this one a little less. What the first film did poorly, this film does worse." — Looking Closer
Posted Jan 15, 2005
C- 86% The Wings of the Dove (1997) " The problem is this: We're given no reason to care about these two yearning hearts. Our only evidence of their love is a garish display of hormones." — Looking Closer
Posted Jan 15, 2005
C- 46% What Lies Beneath (2000) " If the ghost can go hunt for the villain by itself, why does it bother writing cryptic messages to strangers?" — Looking Closer
Posted Jan 15, 2005
C- 87% The Blair Witch Project (1999) " They just want to scare us by confusing us, disorienting us, and by playing a simple trick on our inner ear." — Looking Closer
Posted Jan 15, 2005
C- 57% Mission: Impossible 2 (2000) " This sequel seems afraid of confusing people, so much so that it dumbs down the plot to an insulting level." — Looking Closer
Posted Dec 6, 2004
C- —— Joseph - King of Dreams (2000) " ... fails to bring Joseph and his brothers to life the way Moses and Rameses came to life in The Prince of Egypt. Sappy, run-of-the-mill songs drown out any subtleties." — Looking Closer
Posted Dec 6, 2004
C- 70% Dodgeball - A True Underdog Story (2004) " For every good punchline, there are fifteen that sound like they were scraped off the walls of mens' room stalls." — Looking Closer
Posted Dec 6, 2004
C- 60% Little Secrets (2002) " These character live in an unblemished neighborhood, where everyone has bite-sized problems that can easily be resolved with a few kind words, a hug, and some tears." — Looking Closer
Posted Dec 6, 2004
C- 50% The Emperor's Club (2002) " While it does trumpet good virtues and offer good lessons, it does so without grit, passion, or originality." — Looking Closer
Posted Dec 6, 2004
C- 25% Godzilla (1998) " Godzilla ... is so poorly written and so un-original that it makes Independence Day sound like Shakespeare." — Looking Closer
Posted Dec 6, 2004
C- 88% American Beauty (1999) " A stylish film about an American family that pretends to be moral and enlightened, but revels in its mean-spirited sarcasm and its championing of self-interest." — Looking Closer
Posted Dec 6, 2004
C- 56% The Mexican (2001) " The Mexican fails because the entire movie changes its tone from one moment to the next." — Looking Closer
Posted Dec 6, 2004
C- 68% Treasure Planet (2002) " Hey mom, I went to another planet and found money for you to buy back the family farm. Sure, I blew up the planet in the process, but aren't you proud of me?" — Looking Closer
Posted Dec 6, 2004
C- 33% Ace Ventura - When Nature Calls (1995) " ... if you want to watch something brainless, this isn't a total waste." — Looking Closer
Posted Dec 6, 2004
C- 45% Daredevil (2003) " The relationship between Murdock and Elektra could have made for an interesting film." — Looking Closer
Posted Dec 6, 2004
C- 60% Old School (2003) " Will Ferrell ... makes about ten minutes of this movie side-splittingly hilarious. That's like finding a few pieces of crunchy cereal in a bowl of sour milk." — Looking Closer
Posted Dec 6, 2004
C- 29% The Devil's Own (1997) " The line 'This is not an American story, it's an Irish one' means nothing ... it is a story as American as McNuggets -- all extra-crispy coating and no real meat underneath." — Looking Closer
Posted Dec 6, 2004
C- 54% Troy (2004) " Troy is an empty and dispiriting game, a contest of steroid-ingesting brutes who have made themselves gods in their own minds." — Looking Closer
Posted Dec 6, 2004
1.5/4 82% Vicky Cristina Barcelona (2008) " Woody Allen's work should be taking him deeper into complex and revealing stories about the heart. Instead, he's becoming more preoccupied with the lurid and the lewd." — Christianity Today
Posted Aug 15, 2008
1.5/4 52% Margot at the Wedding (2007) " Margot at the Wedding is a story told from a perspective that's as viciously condescending and critical as Margot's own worldview." — Christianity Today
Posted Nov 21, 2007
1.5/4 29% Madison (2005) " Madison only reinforces stereotypes that 'old-fashioned' and 'small-town' mean 'good' while 'modern' and 'big city' mean 'bad.'" — Christianity Today
Posted Apr 26, 2005
Showing 1 - 50 of 595
Previous | Next
  • Sort by Rating:

    Sort results by this critic's rating. This option is only available for critics with a rating system (4 star, letter grade, 1-10, etc.)

  • Sort by T-meter:

    Sort results by the Tomatometer (percentage of critics recommending a certain movie)

Help | About | Jobs | Critics Submission | API | Licensing | Mobile