INTRODUCTION
BEST OVERALL
wide releases   

limited releases
BY GENRE
action/adventure

animation

comedies

documentaries

dramas

foreign

horror

kids/family

romance

sci-fi/fantasy

thriller
COMPLETE LISTING
MOLDY TOMATO AWARDS
USER TOMATO AWARDS
ARCHIVES
Tomato Awards 2004

Tomato Awards 2003

Tomato Awards 2002

Tomato Awards 2001

Tomato Awards 2000
The Best Reviewed Comedy of 2005
The 40 Year-Old Virgin
Best in Comedies

Light-hearted, good-natured, and definitely thick-skinned, comedy is among the genres most impervious to bad reviews, with box office earnings not necessarily mirroring the critical consensus. This year's winner of the Golden Tomato Award for the best-reviewed comedy, however, arrives with an adjusted score of 76.82, a strong Tomatometer of 84%, and 7th-place ranking among 2005's wide releases. With a title that says it all, "The 40 Year-Old Virgin" proves that Steve Carell has the comedic chops to carry a movie and provide a good share of laughs. Raunch done right is rare, but James Berardinelli of ReelViews proclaimed, "If you're looking for a successor to 'There's Something About Mary' and 'American Pie,' look no further." Meanwhile, Tyler Hanley of the Palo Alto Weekly gave a "big salute to rookie director Judd Apatow and funnyman Steve Carell for reinvigorating the R-rated comedy."

While "Virgin" combines humor with sweetness, the runner-up in the comedy category serves up a darker, more wicked dish of laughs. "Kiss Kiss, Bang Bang," directed by the screenwriter of "Lethal Weapon," Shane Black, is both an homage to hard-boiled noir and a wink-wink, nudge-nudge satire, set on the streets of L.A. David Thomas of filmcritic.com said it "does for the action genre what 'Scream' did for the slasher flick." "Kiss Kiss, Bang Bang" has an adjusted score of 74.47 and rates an 83% on the Tomatometer.

You can perform comedy, you can dissect it, or you can do both at once. In third place is "The Aristocrats," with an adjusted score of 72.86 and a Tomatometer score of 80%. Various comedians take their turn riffing on an old joke, and the results are both obscene and enlightening. As Josh Bell of the Las Vegas Weekly pointed out about the movie, "It's funny and it makes you think; isn't that the definition of a good joke?"

For more results, check out the list below.

Best to Worst Comedies of 2005
RankScoreTitleT-meter
1.76.82The 40 Year-Old Virgin84%
2.74.47Kiss Kiss, Bang Bang83%
3.72.86The Aristocrats80%
4.69.31Wedding Crashers74%
5.65.42The Matador76%
6.61.47Everything is Illuminated65%
7.60.80Roll Bounce65%
8.60.06Sarah Silverman: Jesus is Magic64%
9.55.65Mrs. Henderson Presents57%
10.53.27The Family Stone53%
11.51.85The Producers51%
12.48.89Bad News Bears47%
13.48.42Ice Harvest46%
14.46.44Just Friends42%
15.45.85Guess Who43%
16.45.02The Ringer38%
17.44.49Beauty Shop40%
18.40.80Waiting...32%
19.40.00Pretty Persuasion30%
20.37.17Fun with Dick and Jane29%
21.36.66Be Cool30%
22.35.07The Longest Yard29%
23.31.78Man of the House10%
24.31.74Bewitched25%
25.31.14Rumor Has It...18%
26.29.34Rebound15%
27.29.09Diary of a Mad Black Woman17%
28.27.24The Man13%
29.26.92Underclassman7%
30.26.58Honeymooners13%
31.25.98Monster-in-Law17%
32.25.90Miss Congeniality 2: Armed and Fabulous16%
33.25.60Deuce Bigalow: European Gigolo10%
34.22.81The Wedding Date11%
35.22.52Son of the Mask4%

Data collected on January 5, 2006
7th Annual Golden Tomato Awards Awards Home

» NEXT (The Best Documentary of 2005)