INTRODUCTION
BEST OVERALL
wide releases   

limited releases
BY GENRE
action/adventure

animation

comedies

documentaries

dramas

foreign

horror

kids/family

romance

sci-fi/fantasy

thriller
COMPLETE LISTING
MOLDY TOMATO AWARDS
USER TOMATO AWARDS
ARCHIVES
Tomato Awards 2004

Tomato Awards 2003

Tomato Awards 2002

Tomato Awards 2001

Tomato Awards 2000
The Best Reviewed Documentary of 2005
March of the Penguins
Best in Documentaries

No longer just a dry succession of droning talking heads, current documentaries demonstrate that they can entertain as well as educate. Moviegoers and critics alike are taking notice of the recent evolution of this film genre, as the best-reviewed documentary (and second place limited release) of 2005 was also one of the year's biggest commercial surprises; "March of the Penguins," a tale of Emperor penguins enduring great trials just so they can reproduce, earned an adjusted score of 84.43 and a 95% on the Tomatometer. Cherryl Dawson and Leigh Ann Palone of TheMovieChicks.com described it as being "every bit as beautiful as 'Winged Migration' only with more emotion as you watch the survival of the fittest and cutest." Stephanie Zacharek of Salon.com declared, "There's more drama, and more heartbreak, in 'March of the Penguins' than in most movies that are actually scripted to tug at our feelings."

The second-best-reviewed doc, "Murderball," is a sports movie with a healthy dose of grit. Henry Alex Rubin and Dana Adam Shapiro's film follows the exploits of a group of tough-as-nails quadriplegic rugby players who give lie to the term "physical limitations." Ty Burr of the Boston Globe described the film as "tough, terse, funny, ribald, and heartbreaking." "Murderball" has an adjusted score of 84.28 and a Tomatometer of 97%, and also triumphed as the number three limited release of 2005.

"Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room," a muckraking film about the rise and spectacular fall of the bankrupt energy company, comes in at third place, with an adjusted score of 83.73 and a Tomatometer of 97%. Colin Covert of the Minneapolis Star Tribune warned, "You might expect this film to be mildly informative; coming out you'll feel you've seen the horror movie of the year."

For more results, check out the list below.

Best to Worst Documentaries of 2005
RankScoreTitleT-meter
1.84.43March of the Penguins95%
2.84.28Murderball97%
3.83.73Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room97%
4.80.50Grizzly Man93%
5.79.61Wild Parrots of Telegraph Hill94%
6.74.67Gunner Palace85%
7.72.73Mad Hot Ballroom82%
8.71.63Rize82%
9.71.05Tell Them Who You Are86%
10.70.99Inside Deep Throat79%
11.70.52Rock School82%
12.64.11Mondovino72%
13.61.40My Date With Drew68%
14.57.39Dust to Glory60%

Data collected on January 5, 2006
7th Annual Golden Tomato Awards Awards Home

» NEXT (The Best Drama of 2005)