CANNES: Richard Kelly's "Southland Tales" Fails Lofty Goals
By now the disastrous opening of Richard Kelly's "Southland Tales" at Cannes is infamous, with the majority of the viewing press vastly disappointed, if not entirely appalled, by Kelly's much-anticipated follow up to cult hit "Donnie Darko."
Those who loved "Darko" for its quirky, unsettling ideas and themes of time travel, self-sacrifice, and tragic destiny may actually find similar bits and pieces to love in "Southland." That said, with its grotesquely excessive 160 minutes, over-the-top near-futuristic sets and characters, and a misplaced gravitas inlaid with manic comedy, Kelly's ambitious effort will unfortunately be remembered as his sophomore slump.

"Southland Tales" opens in the year 2005 in Abilene, Texas, as a neighborhood full of families celebrates with a Fourth of July block party. Fun and jubilance are soon interrupted by an explosion and a looming mushroom cloud, the marker of a worldwide fuel war that will usher in the next few years of border militance, omnipresent Big Brother-style surveillance, and increasing political unrest. Cue narration by war veteran Pilot Abilene -- the delicate, deliberately Southern-tinged voice of everyone's favorite pop sensation-cum-actor, Justin Timberlake -- and Kelly launches into an overlong expository montage to set up his near-future dystopia, with Timberlake's early promises of doom and gloom, Armageddon, the end of the world, all set in -- where else? --Los Angeles.
But this set up happens in the first ten minutes or so, and we have a loooong way to go before the film's oft-repeated T.S. Eliot line, "This is the way the world ends," mercifully comes to fruition. First we must meet famous actor Boxer Santaros (Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson), who wakes up in Hermosa Beach with a case of amnesia, a porn-star lover, and a movie script he's written, entitled "The Power," which uncannily imitates/predicts events in the present and foretells the end of the world in three days.

In the next two plus hours we will meet Boxer's wife, Madeline Frost (Mandy Moore), her NSA head mother Nana Mae (Miranda Richardson), her up-for-reelection senator husband (Holmes Osborne), and his eccentric German industrialist partner Baron Von Westphalen (Wallace Shawn). Across town, Boxer's forgotten his identity and taken up with the adult actress/aspiring media conglomerate, Krysta Now (Sarah Michelle Gellar), who's got ties to a network of discontented Neo-Marxists (Cheri Oteri and many of her fellow "SNL" alums) who have set a disastrous plan in motion to bring down the government in a bloody Fourth of July coup.
Oh yeah, and the Neo-Marxists have kidnapped LAPD officer Roland Taverner and are using his twin brother Ronald (both played by Seann William Scott) as a pawn in their revolution.

Kelly's attempts to weave together too many convergent storylines (a Neo-Marxist blackmail conspiracy, the discovery of a limitless fuel source, Boxer Santaros' noir-ish adventure, Ronald's quest to find his brother) give him tenuous cause to add a cacophony of supporting characters to the mix (yes, in addition to the central figures already mentioned). Never again will you see Kevin Smith, John Larroquette, Christopher Lambert, Zelda Rubenstein, Bai Ling, and Booger from "Revenge of the Nerds" in the same movie, which alone may or may not be a reason to give "Southland" at least one viewing.
Further confusing things is the mash-up of genres in these "Tales:" science fiction, political thriller, action, comedy, musical and spiritual drama all vie for attention in Kelly's epic, resulting not in a satisfactory balance of genre flavors but in a case of severe tonal indigestion. While the overt references to Eliot's "The Hollow Men" and the Biblical-literary musings of Pilot Abilene do lend the story a central, if ambiguous, sense of purpose, any philosophical meaning Kelly meant to infuse his film with are lost within the confused mishmash -- not unlike his "Donnie Darko," whose metaphysical ideas worked better on a much smaller, less ambitious scale.
If anything, Kelly's critical reaming at Cannes has reportedly led to him taking "Southland" back to the editing room, where one hopes he can trim his epic down to a more endurable two hours. I'll also cross my fingers that he keeps one of the best and unpredictable scenes in the film, a spirited and melancholy "music video" of The Killers' "All These Things That I've Done" -- performed beautifully and wrenchingly by none other than Justin Timberlake.
Those who loved "Darko" for its quirky, unsettling ideas and themes of time travel, self-sacrifice, and tragic destiny may actually find similar bits and pieces to love in "Southland." That said, with its grotesquely excessive 160 minutes, over-the-top near-futuristic sets and characters, and a misplaced gravitas inlaid with manic comedy, Kelly's ambitious effort will unfortunately be remembered as his sophomore slump.

"Southland Tales" opens in the year 2005 in Abilene, Texas, as a neighborhood full of families celebrates with a Fourth of July block party. Fun and jubilance are soon interrupted by an explosion and a looming mushroom cloud, the marker of a worldwide fuel war that will usher in the next few years of border militance, omnipresent Big Brother-style surveillance, and increasing political unrest. Cue narration by war veteran Pilot Abilene -- the delicate, deliberately Southern-tinged voice of everyone's favorite pop sensation-cum-actor, Justin Timberlake -- and Kelly launches into an overlong expository montage to set up his near-future dystopia, with Timberlake's early promises of doom and gloom, Armageddon, the end of the world, all set in -- where else? --Los Angeles.
But this set up happens in the first ten minutes or so, and we have a loooong way to go before the film's oft-repeated T.S. Eliot line, "This is the way the world ends," mercifully comes to fruition. First we must meet famous actor Boxer Santaros (Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson), who wakes up in Hermosa Beach with a case of amnesia, a porn-star lover, and a movie script he's written, entitled "The Power," which uncannily imitates/predicts events in the present and foretells the end of the world in three days.

In the next two plus hours we will meet Boxer's wife, Madeline Frost (Mandy Moore), her NSA head mother Nana Mae (Miranda Richardson), her up-for-reelection senator husband (Holmes Osborne), and his eccentric German industrialist partner Baron Von Westphalen (Wallace Shawn). Across town, Boxer's forgotten his identity and taken up with the adult actress/aspiring media conglomerate, Krysta Now (Sarah Michelle Gellar), who's got ties to a network of discontented Neo-Marxists (Cheri Oteri and many of her fellow "SNL" alums) who have set a disastrous plan in motion to bring down the government in a bloody Fourth of July coup.
Oh yeah, and the Neo-Marxists have kidnapped LAPD officer Roland Taverner and are using his twin brother Ronald (both played by Seann William Scott) as a pawn in their revolution.

Kelly's attempts to weave together too many convergent storylines (a Neo-Marxist blackmail conspiracy, the discovery of a limitless fuel source, Boxer Santaros' noir-ish adventure, Ronald's quest to find his brother) give him tenuous cause to add a cacophony of supporting characters to the mix (yes, in addition to the central figures already mentioned). Never again will you see Kevin Smith, John Larroquette, Christopher Lambert, Zelda Rubenstein, Bai Ling, and Booger from "Revenge of the Nerds" in the same movie, which alone may or may not be a reason to give "Southland" at least one viewing.
Further confusing things is the mash-up of genres in these "Tales:" science fiction, political thriller, action, comedy, musical and spiritual drama all vie for attention in Kelly's epic, resulting not in a satisfactory balance of genre flavors but in a case of severe tonal indigestion. While the overt references to Eliot's "The Hollow Men" and the Biblical-literary musings of Pilot Abilene do lend the story a central, if ambiguous, sense of purpose, any philosophical meaning Kelly meant to infuse his film with are lost within the confused mishmash -- not unlike his "Donnie Darko," whose metaphysical ideas worked better on a much smaller, less ambitious scale.
If anything, Kelly's critical reaming at Cannes has reportedly led to him taking "Southland" back to the editing room, where one hopes he can trim his epic down to a more endurable two hours. I'll also cross my fingers that he keeps one of the best and unpredictable scenes in the film, a spirited and melancholy "music video" of The Killers' "All These Things That I've Done" -- performed beautifully and wrenchingly by none other than Justin Timberlake.
Related Items
| Movie: | Donnie Darko |
| Cannes Film Festival 2006: Rotten Tomatoes Eat France! | |
| Celeb: | Sarah Michelle Gellar |
| Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson | |
| Seann William Scott | |
| Richard Kelly |
|
Decade_e_a writes: on May 27 2006 01:37 PM I think it sounds cool. I'll see it. But that much stuff in a movie can be very hard to swallow. (Reply to this) |
|
darcko writes: on May 27 2006 02:12 PM It seems like this will be another cult hit... I bet you in five or so years, people will be talking about this movie like it's one of the best things to ever happen in its mish-mash genre. (Reply to this) |
|
my nine inches writes: on May 28 2006 10:07 AM [b]darko[/b] indeed, im pretty sure thats exactly what will happen. when darko came out in got the same negative responce but lets be honest that movie is adored as a cult hit (Reply to this) |
|
lovelykeira writes: on May 28 2006 10:57 AM Sounds like it definitely has too much going on and a big weird cast. I'll see anything once and I"m always interested in films from Cannes that either get a lot of good buzz, or that get a ton of bad buzz. (Reply to this) |
|
screamsinthenight writes: on May 28 2006 03:00 PM The Killers video by Timberlake already has me excited. (Reply to this) |
|
supermanofsteel writes: on May 28 2006 10:20 PM It's a shame. I was really hoping this would finally be the Rock's breakout hit. (Reply to this) |
|
cowsfan writes: on May 29 2006 02:44 AM Here comes the softmore slump. This seems to happen when a director takes way too long to finish a follow-up film to a cult classic. I felt the same way about Don Roos 'Happy Endings'. An ambitious but overlong and very flawed follow-up to 'The Opposite Of Sex'. I've anticipated this movie for a long time and will go see it. However, this news is a bummer. Kind of a strange cast. (Reply to this) |
|
boxman writes: on May 29 2006 08:28 AM Actually, Roos followed The Oppsoite of Sex with Bounce in 2000. That was his sophomore directing job. (Reply to this) |
|
Reel 2/Dialogue 2 writes: on May 29 2006 12:25 PM [b]This Cannes not be![/b] This is turning out to be a strangely bizarre year for esoteric directors. Sofia Coppola gets booed for [i]Antoinette[/i], Linklater receives less enthusiatic early buzz on [i]Scanner Darkly[/i], now this. What's next, Aronofsky's [i]Fountain[/i]? Methinks the air at Cannes be thinner than usual. (Reply to this) |
|
RoadDogXVIII writes: on May 29 2006 01:49 PM I don't believe this. I've been anticipating "Southland Tales" for a while, and Gellar can be a scream. There was even Oscar buzz from what I've heard, though I forget the name of the source. But now it's getting trashed. I think it's like one of Tyler Perry's movies: a bullshit dramedy with 1,000 subplots. (Reply to this) |
|
Functionally Godarded writes: on May 29 2006 04:06 PM I trust that, through recuts, the two-hour movie will sit better with critics. Richard was rushed to get the movie to Cannes in time, so I'm sure that has something to do with the bad reviews. Give him time. This is still my most anticipated movie of 2006. (Reply to this) |
|
fynejackie writes: on May 29 2006 09:23 PM [b]southland tales[/b] I'll still see that movie (Reply to this) |
|
phill01 writes: on Jun 29 2006 05:44 PM The cast is a odd mix of what I consider to be acting lightweights, (Gellar,the rock, Seann William Scott) however the story sounds intruiging enough to make me want to see it at least once. (Reply to this) |
| You must be registered to post comments. Login or Register. |








