The Secret Garden - Movie Reviews - Rotten Tomatoes

The Secret Garden Reviews

Page 1 of 210
Super Reviewer
September 6, 2010
When I was a kid everyone was always saying how fantastic this movie was, but I didn't think it was all that cool. It's an okay family movie, but it could be a lot better.
Daniel Mumby
Super Reviewer
November 26, 2010
There is a long tradition in British cinema of great films being made as a collaboration between British and foreign talent. Many films which are considered classics are distinctive because of this marriage of different national and cultural outlooks: Michael Powell had Emeric Pressburger, and James Ivory had Ishmael Merchant.

It therefore makes absolute sense for The Secret Garden, a quintessentially English story by Frances Hodgson Burnett, to be scripted by a Briton but directed by a Pole. Like her contemporary Krzysztof Kieslowski, Agnieszka Holland is a director who knows how to bring out the delicate humanity of any given scene. Her sensitive approach to the material and knack for working with child actors combine beautifully, to create a masterful adaptation on a par with Shadowlands and Three Colours - Blue.

The Kieslowski comparison is not a frivolous one, since Holland collaborated with him on the screenplay for Three Colours - Blue. And while her body of work is nowhere near as powerful or consistent, she shares Kieslowski's humanist sensibility and an understanding of the subtleties of human emotion. She has the same knack for expressing complex themes through the most subtle and innocent of interactions, conveyed through visuals which are effortlessly beautiful. There is also an incidental link in the casting: Irene Jacob, who appears briefly as Mary's mother, played the central role in Three Colours - Red.

The Secret Garden is a beautiful film from whichever angle you approach it. It was shot by Roger Deakins, who would later win a BAFTA for his work on No Country for Old Men. Deakins contrasts the early, drained-out footage of the gardens, filled with pale greens and faded browns, with later lush images of what seems like the whole world in bloom. The film also includes some beautiful time-lapse footage of the garden changing from winter to spring, with flowers blooming and butterflies emerging from cocoons.

The film has a genuine sense of wonder which is tragically absent from many more contemporary children's films. This point can be illustrated perfectly by comparing The Secret Garden with the family films of Chris Columbus. Regardless of Columbus' other shortcomings as a director (of which there are many), his attempts at 'wonder' or 'fantasy' feel incredibly manufactured. The first two Harry Potter films feel like they have been test-screened to within an inch of their lives, and all the imagination has been sucked out in a bid to not offend the fans.

The Secret Garden, on the other hand, manages to be faithful to its source material without taking off any of its dark or slightly rough edges. Like all great children's films, there is a balance between joy and tragedy, and the film doesn't shy away from letting the audience share in the characters' misery. Just like James and the Giant Peach, the story starts with the parents of the central character being tragically killed (in the book it is cholera, in the film it's an earthquake). We follow Mary through the lonely aftermath as she struggles to fit into the forbidding new world that is laid before her, and as with James it takes something quite magical to bring her round.

But despite its references to Indian religion and the rather uncomfortable scene of the children 'summoning' Colin's father, the film's 'magic' is rooted firmly in Christianity. Burnett was a prominent exponent of Christian Science, a doctrine of Christianity rooted in the belief that all of God's creation (that is, all nature) is made in His image and therefore inherently good. While this proposal might seem hard to stomach, The Secret Garden does have a very prominent Christian thread running through it, which is no more threatening or disagreeable than the fiction of C. S. Lewis (hence the Shadowlands comparison).

Viewed through a Biblical prism, the garden at Misslethwaite Manor starts out as essentially Eden, with Colin's parents more or less as stand-ins for Adam and Eve. The tragic death of Colin's mother (a literal Fall, if you like) causes 'man' in the form of his father to leave the garden and barricade it up. He is shutting out all that is good because of his own guilt and shame, choosing the darkness as penance for what he believes he has done.

When Mary enters the garden, finding it overgrown and in desperate need of care, she is like Lucy when she first wanders through the wardrobe: the world is special and has signs of life, but the overall mood is one of sorrow and neglect. She rediscovers the joy of nature through her innocence and curiosity, and in discovering the 'magic' she learns to live with herself and to appreciate the good in others, rather than spurning them or treating them as servants.

From a slightly different angle, the scenes involving Colin reuniting with his father could be compared with Jesus' time in the Garden of Gethsemane - perhaps what the garden had to go through to regain its former glory. These scenes are of a father rediscovering his son having turned his face away for so long, returning to a place that once embodied death and not only finding life but being welcomed. The final conversation between Mary and Lord Craven is like the encounter between Jesus and Mary Magdalene outside the tomb: the line about Mary "bringing them back to life" may be corny, but it does convey the idea of redemption through acceptance.

But there is more to The Secret Garden than just good old-fashioned morals. The film is thoroughly entertaining, thanks to the elegant dialogue in Caroline Thompson's screenplay. The three child actors are all highly enjoyable and convincing, with Kate Maberly and Heydon Prowse showing wisdom and grace beyond their years. Maberly may spend the first half-hour constantly in a strop, but she has a Puck-like quality which keeps her character interesting. The adult performers are also entertaining, with Maggie Smith turning in a typically domineering performance as Mrs. Medlock and John Lynch holding his own as Lord Craven (even if his long hair and moustache make him unduly resemble Colin Farrell).

There are a couple of small faults with The Secret Garden. Although it does generally succeed in being charming under its own steam, it does drift into Disney convention as more animals appear. There's only so many times you can show cuddly deer before we start to feel manipulated. The ending is sentimental and a little cloying, and highlights once again the presence of unnecessary narration. It may be a children's film, but that doesn't mean you have to state the bleeding obvious at any given moment.

The Secret Garden is a very fine children's film which recalls the best work of Richard Attenborough and Lionel Jeffries. Its Christian morals are presented in a very subtle way for such a prominently allegorical work, and it is every bit as fresh and entertaining now as when first released. As a spiritual film about or involving children it is on a par with Shadowlands, and as a children's film in general it is an amiable companion to The Railway Children. The film is touching, charming and captivating in equal measure, and despite its little faults it is essential viewing.
Super Reviewer
May 24, 2009
For a child's film, this is beautifully done. Rich colors, amazing mansion and fantastic acting on all parts. Especially Maggie Smith, naturally.
Super Reviewer
July 1, 2010
The Secret Garden is a terrific film for all ages. A film with an enchanting tale, The Secret Garden is a terrific film with a great cast of young actors. What attracts you into the film is a world of classic beauty. Everything is atmospheric in this film. I myself have never read the book, but I still think that this is a terrific film with a simple, yet effective story that unfolds before us. I find it hard to hate this film because this is a film that just shows you don't need a big, complicated storyline to create a terrific film. This film along with The Sandlot will always remain classics from my childhood.
Super Reviewer
December 1, 2009
It is such a lovely Movie. I totally forget everything around me when I watch this Movie on DVD.
Super Reviewer
August 1, 2009
The key to this movie is the great story. the book itself is known worldwide and consumer and critically acclaimed. And this is the thing to look for in the film. Don't look for incredible performances by the actors, they aren't. Don't look for an amazing score, it's not. Don't look for groundbreaking camerawork, there isn't any. The set is the exception to this, the garden looks amazing. However, in this film, don't look at all those other things. If you want a great score, get thee to 2001 A Space Odyssey. If you want ground breaking camera work go to The Blair Witch Project. If you crave an amazing performance from an actor/actress, there are a myriad of films to choose from. When you're watching this film, look for the story. As it's really close to the book it's got great structure and beautiful moments between characters. This isn't the best film ever, but it's not bad.

Defining Scene:
When the boy gardener shows the girl that the garden is still alive, reminding us that even though our outer layers may be brown and dead, we are all still green inside. awww
Super Reviewer
August 10, 2007
I loved this movie when I was younger.
Super Reviewer
August 3, 2007
Fine version of venerable old story. Lovely and worthwhile.
Super Reviewer
December 12, 2006
Director Agnieszka Holland creates a truly gorgeous, remarkably subtle and stately version of the children's classic.
See Spot Run 3/5 - Hilarious! Some great laughs with the mailman (David Arquette) and the FBI agent dog, but except Michael Duncan Clarke's character is a bit ridiculous.
Super Reviewer
½ August 16, 2008
This should be seen by every family that enjoys sitting down with the family and watching family movies, you can go wrong.
Super Reviewer
½ January 1, 2008
The secret garden is discovered by a group of children. Beautiful adaptation of the novel.
Super Reviewer
½ October 28, 2007
oof course u cant say this film is anything below ok its sweet though that brat gets on my nerves but it is sweet and sad and just really good
Super Reviewer
August 5, 2007
It's good but reading the book is better.
Super Reviewer
January 29, 2007
When characters are purportedly "learning" to laugh and/or cry, don't you think that the audience should be laughing and/or crying from time to time? Once even? One dismal adaptation. Haydon Prowse and the various and sundry children have a charisma factor of minus three stars. I give it one mega star for Maggie Smith. Her performance functions on a higher level than any others in the film. Seriously, the greatest interest factor is split between Smith and the beautiful animals in this production. It's the animals who rate the second star. But even they can't save this one.
Super Reviewer
½ October 17, 2006
I love this movie...
Super Reviewer
½ July 16, 2011
Super Reviewer
September 25, 2012
Production values are pretty good. In terms of the overall storyline, I'm afraid that I have lost some of the magic of youth that allows this to be appreciated.
August Seria
Super Reviewer
½ April 15, 2012
Sweet and enchanting tale inside and outside its deeper theme. The Secret Garden brings you to a magical world of secrets and an adventure towards revival of one's soul.
Super Reviewer
December 27, 2007
This is an important film in my childhood. I can't remember why, but it was. This has deeply spiritual connotations.
Super Reviewer
October 7, 2007
I love the book.
Page 1 of 210