News » Columns » Weekly Ketchup » Weekly Ketchup: Del Toro, Penn, & Carrey as Larry, Moe, & Curly

Weekly Ketchup: Del Toro, Penn, & Carrey as Larry, Moe, & Curly

Plus casting news for Anne Hathaway, Amber Tamblyn, and Anthony Hopkins

This Week's Ketchup is chock full of casting news (over 15 actors and actresses), as well as the expected comic book adaptations, biopics and a remake.


#1 OSCAR WINNERS IN TALKS TO PLAY THE THREE STOOGES

Two time Academy Award winner Sean Penn, Golden Globe nominee Jim Carrey and Academy Award winner Benicio Del Toro are MGM's choices to star as Larry, Curly and Moe in their Farrelly Brothers-directed relaunch of The Three Stooges. Yes, really. Sean Penn, who might have seemed the least likely of the three, is the first to be signed, and Carrey and Del Toro are in negotiations. Jim Carrey is also planning on gaining 40 pounds to acquire the physical look of Curly. These casting choices are remarkably inspired, with Penn in particular actually bearing a remarkable facial resemblance to Larry Fine. Benicio Del Toro's gruff demeanor can also easily be seen as translating quite easily to the role of Moe Howard, the Stooges' eye-poking and face-slapping leader. The Farrelly Brothers have been trying to get their dream project, The Three Stooges (which is not a biopic, but a modern relaunching of the characters in comedic misadventures) for a decade now, with the project formerly being at both WB and Columbia before landing at MGM. Production is expected to start this fall, 2009 in time for a release in 2010.


#2 THE COEN BROS TO REMAKE THE DUKE'S TRUE GRIT

The Coen Bros' (No Country for Old Men) next project after the recently-wrapped A Serious Man will be a remake of the classic John Wayne western True Grit, for which The Duke won his Oscar. The twist that the Coen Bros. are striving to make a more faithful adaptation of the original novel by Charles Portis, focusing more on the girl who narrated the novel. Paramount Pictures, which distributed the 1969 movie, is also handling this remake. True Grit is the story of a 14-year-old girl in 1873 who teams up with two lawmen to find the man who murdered her father, a trail that takes them into dangerous Indian territory. Although No Country for Old Men could be described as a modern Western, True Grit will be the Coens' first period piece Western.


#3 TOM HANKS TO PLAY OBSCURE TOY, MAJOR MATT MASON

Mattel is matching its competitor Hasbro's very exhaustive adaptation of toy properties with Universal Pictures, with the announcement that Tom Hanks will star as Major Matt Mason, a live action adaptation of a relatively obscure toy line from the 1960s about a Moon explorer. Graham Yost (Speed; cowriter of Mission to Mars) is working on the script. Major Matt Mason stands out from the rest of the Mattel properties being developed (He-Man, Hot Wheels, etc.) as it is not a property that most people today remember. However, that is no doubt why Tom Hanks was cast as Mason, since the project can be propelled on his star power, nearly as if it is an entirely original property. Mattel likely has plans to relaunch Major Matt Mason as a new toy line in connection to the movie, which might be aided by NASA's current plans to return to the Moon in the future.


#4 BRYAN SINGER TO DIRECT MECH RACING FREEDOM FORMULA

New Regency and 20th Century Fox have acquired the rights to the futuristic comic book series Freedom Formula: Ghost of the Wasteland as a directorial project for Bryan Singer (X-Men, Superman Returns). Freedom Formula is set in a future where fighter jets have been replaced by battle suits pilotted by genetically modified soldiers. So, basically, it sounds a bit like Iron Man as a futuristic war movie by way of titles like Robotech. The script is being worked on by Michael Finch, who recently made a large deal for his cowritten script Medieval, an action movie set in the Middle Ages.


#5 ANNE HATHAWAY TO GET HAPPY AS JUDY GARLAND

Although there is no writer or director for the project yet, The Weinstein Company has cast Anne Hathaway as singer-actress Judy Garland in a biopic called Get Happy, based on a 2001 biography by Gerald Clarke. Get Happy is also be a Broadway musical, although it is unclear which project will be produced first. Clarke's biography was chosen as the source material because it draws heavily upon Garland's own writings, giving the project a voice unique to previous adaptations of Garland's life, such as like the 2001 TV movie Life with Judy Garland, starring Judy Davis. Anne Hathaway's performance at this year's Oscars with Hugh Jackman was given as an example of proof of her singing chops. One aspect of Hathaway's casting that I can't help but notice is that at 5' 8", she stands considerably taller than Judy Garland, who was a mere 4' 11". Perhaps they'll be using really tall actors around her, or those fancy camera tricks used on the Hobbits in The Lord of the Rings?


#6 RICHIE CUNNINGHAM TO DESCEND INTO THE STRANGE WORLD OF H.P. LOVECRAFT?

Universal Pictures and Imagine Entertainment are teaming up to pick up the rights to the upcoming Image Comics graphic novel The Strange Adventures of H.P. Lovecraft, a fictionalized adventure inspired by the life of pulp-era horror writer, H.P. Lovecraft, best known for his bizarre Cthulhu mythos and stories, in which humans are confronted by evils beyond their comprehension and which often lead to them going insane. The Strange Adventures of H.P. Lovecraft depicts the author as finding a book that curses him, letting loose the monsters he creates upon the real world. John Carpenter's In the Mouth of Madness, an homage to H.P. Lovecraft, actually told a similar story, except with the fictional author character being the film's villain. Imagine is producing the project with an eye toward it possibly being a directorial project for Imagine partner Ron Howard, whose early films include Willow and Cocoon, and the more recent religious-themed thrillers The Da Vinci Code and Angels and Demons. The Strange Adventures of H.P. Lovecraft would be Howard's first direct foray into straight-out horror, however. Universal is said to be excited about H.P. Lovecraft because of parallels to their classic monsters (The Mummy, Dracula, Frankenstein, etc), but Lovecraftian horror is actually quite different, in my opinion.


#7 ANTHONY HOPKINS TO PLAY PAPA AS HEMINGWAY

Sir Anthony Hopkins will star as author Ernest Hemingway in Hemingway & Fuentes, a biopic about his last ten years, focusing on his friendship with fishing boat captain Gregorio Fuentes, to be played by Andy Garcia, who is also writing, directing and producing the independent drama. Annette Bening is also in talks to costar as Hemingway's fourth wife, Mary Welsh. This is not the first time Hopkins has been announced to play Hemingway, as there was also Papa, a project announced in 2004 that would have costarred Meg Ryan, but which was never actually filmed.




#8 KICK-ASS TEAM REUNITING FOR AMERICAN JESUS

Comics writer/creator Mark Millar (Wanted) is reuniting with Matthew Vaughn, the director working on the adaptation of Millar's Kick-Ass, for a movie version of American Jesus, his comic trilogy about the return of Jesus as an American teenager. American Jesus got its start as a 2004 mini-series called Chosen, but with two more mini-series following that (the second, Resurrection, is due to start in the fall of 2009), the total package is now called American Jesus. Although the comic books are only one third published, production of American Jesus could begin as early as this summer, 2009, with the production being made outside the studio system to reduce interference, similar to what was done with Kick-Ass.


#9 PERCY JACKSON STARTS FINDING HIS PANTHEON

Percy Jackson, Fox 2000's adaptation of The Lightning Thief, a children's novel by Rick Riordan, is an adventure about a young boy who finds out he is the half-son of Poseidon, and gets involved in preventing a coming war of the Olympian Gods. Several of those gods or mythological figures were cast this week: Sean Bean (Zeus), Kevin McKidd (Poseidon), Melina Kanakarides (Athena), Uma Thurman (Medusa) and Pierce Brosnan (Chiron the Centaur). Casting of Hades, Aries and Persephone are still underway. Percy Jackson is being directed by Chris Columbus (the first two Home Alone and Harry Potter movies), aiming for a February, 2010 release date. It's also worth noting that Percy Jackson will soon be joined in Greek god casting by the Clash of the Titans remake, which is also set for a 2010 release date.


#10 AMBER TAMBLYN, ORLANDO BLOOM HIT MAIN STREET

Academy Award winning screenwriter and playwright Horton Foote (To Kill a Mockingbird, Tender Mercies) died earlier this month, but production of his final script, Main Street, is proceeding right along. This week, Orlando Bloom, Amber Tamblyn, Colin Firth, Ellen Burstyn, Patricia Clarkson and Andrew McCarthy were all announced as being in various stages of negotiations to star or costar. Main Street is the story of the residents of a small, economically struggling North Carolina town whose lives are changed when a stranger comes to town. British Broadway director Tony Doyle is directing, and filming is scheduled to start in April in Durham, North Carolina. The source material will probably be strong, but will anyone believe Orlando Bloom is a small town cop with a Carolina accent?


For more Weekly Ketchup columns by Greg Dean Schmitz, check out the WK archive, and you can contact GDS through his MySpace page or via a RT forum message and Greg also blogs about the TV show Lost, at TwoLosties.Blogspot.com.

jokerboy1991

jokerboy1991 on 03-27-2009 07:58 PM

Come on Greg! Where's your enthusiasm for The Three Stooges?!? Its got Harvey Milk, The Wolfman, and the Yes Man all together! Sounds genius. I am kind of surprised that Bryan Singer is going to work with FOX again after they kind of screwed him over on X3.

Speaker for the Films

Speaker for the Films on 03-28-2009 11:11 PM

They didn't screw him over, he quit to do Superman Returns.

jokerboy1991

jokerboy1991 on 03-29-2009 12:12 PM

I heard he had time to do X3, but FOX wouldn't let him because he was doing Superman for Warners.

Brian S.

Brian S. on 03-27-2009 08:29 PM

Jim Carrey hasn't been nominated for an Oscar, as far as I know.


Floor Man

Floor Man on 03-27-2009 09:01 PM

Correct. He has not. Just Golden Globes.

blattman

blattman on 03-28-2009 09:04 PM

Let's not forget several Nick Kids Choice Awards

blattman

blattman on 03-28-2009 09:06 PM

Let's not forget several Nick Kids Choice Awards.
Ledawg, check out Fast Times At Ridgemont High. Sean Penn as a serious actor once took the world by storm.

Playboy Slim

Playboy Slim on 03-28-2009 10:18 PM

Oh yeah. Well, he's proven he can be funny.

Playboy Slim

Playboy Slim on 03-27-2009 09:15 PM

Anne Hathaway as Judy Garland? No.

While the Three Stooges could fail epically, I think seeing Sean Penn doing slapstick sounds too good to pass up. When you see a serious actor doing comedy, it's funny!

"Freedom Formula" sounds like a goofy fun movie. I hope. Singer's last comic book film was "Superman Returns", which was a diaster because it was too serious.

Lastly, "True Grit" in the hands of the Coen's sounds LEGNDARY!

jokerboy1991

jokerboy1991 on 03-27-2009 09:17 PM

Yeah, I mean George Clooney is pretty awesome doing comedy. I love his slap stick humor, so maybe Sean Penn can pull a Clooney and end up being funny.

greg_dean_schmitz

greg_dean_schmitz on 03-27-2009 09:31 PM

Oops, my bad about Jim Carrey.

Anyway, I didn't sound enthusiastic enough... ? I did say "remarkably inspired" : ). But yes, I am indeed excited about Sean Penn as Larry, in particular. Good to see a movie he might have actual fun with, for sure.

Jeremy H.

Jeremy H. on 03-27-2009 09:38 PM

I always saw Jim Carrey as Moe, Adam Sandler as Larry and Jack Black as Curly.

Jeremy H.

Jeremy H. on 03-27-2009 09:39 PM

I always saw Jim Carrey as Moe, Adam Sandler as Larry and Jack Black as Curly.

Censured

Censured on 03-27-2009 10:37 PM

I'll watch anything by the Coens.

On a side note, is this a contest? Usually when you see four numbers by a username it is indicative of the year said user was born.

Duckett H.

Duckett H. on 03-28-2009 09:52 AM

Jim Carrey truly deserved an Oscar nomination for his role in The Truman Show.

Playboy Slim

Playboy Slim on 03-28-2009 11:08 AM

I agree. One of these days the Academy will give him something. If he stops doing things like "The Number 23".

hhg

hhg on 03-30-2009 03:46 PM

You have got to be kidding me. The Truman Show is one of the worst movies of all time and you can't give an Oscar to someone can only make faces. Wait until he decides to take up acting.

Playboy Slim

Playboy Slim on 03-30-2009 04:07 PM

You obviously haven't seen "The Truman Show."

John N.

John N. on 03-28-2009 01:39 PM

Jim Carrey in Eternal Sunshine is Oscar material

FinalDestination019

FinalDestination019 on 03-28-2009 05:33 PM

Jim Carrey has won 2 Golden Globes, but deserved Oscar nominations for The Truman Show and Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind.

LakersFan-BostonSucks

LakersFan-BostonSucks on 03-28-2009 10:45 PM

The Coen brothers are the most overrated filmmakers to date! Raising Arizona is the only movie of theirs I can tolerate!

mjprogue

mjprogue on 03-29-2009 12:15 PM

Ummm...I can't remember ever seeing such a ridiculous lineup for a film.

None of these guys has any chance of playing their respective Stooge with anything like competance. Unless the modern re-imagining plan involves a complete redefining of each character and not just the Stooges plopped into today...and if thats the case...why bother?

HP Lovecraft and Judy Garland...not two names you expect to be seen together, but they both look promising.

American Jesus being made outside the studio system to avoid interfereance? More likely they couldn't find a studio to make it. Has anybody actually read these comics? Pure garbage...and in no way is any potential religious issue involved in that opinion...the comics are just dumb.

Suckitbaby needs to be a professional film critic...seriously...not many folks are willing to say anything bad about the Coens...but your comment was dead on.

josuepilk

josuepilk on 03-29-2009 12:16 PM

To this day Jeff Spicoli is still a god from Imperial to Redondo. Carrey deserved the Oscar for Man on the Moon and he wasn't even nominated. Russel Crowe was, is and always will be douche.

dylan m.

dylan m. on 03-29-2009 01:34 PM

The Coens don't make bad movies, true grit will be good, end of story. As for the stooges, how can the movie be bad? 3 stooges is ridiculous slapstick, and nobody does it anymore, just in cartoons, well and i guess chevy chase, chris farley....but he's dead...i'm not looking for oscar worthy performances from penn, carrey, del toro, i just want to laugh my *** off, and the stupider it is, the better, thank you farrelly bros.

JUDGE DREDD

JUDGE DREDD on 03-30-2009 04:12 AM

An EXCELLENT cast! I can see it working. It was made for Carrey! Wonder if he'll wear a fat suit?

Cory B.

Cory B. on 03-30-2009 03:18 PM

I cannot believe anybody thinks this is going to turn out well. The concept is horrible, the casting calls are horrible, and the guys in charge do comedy that's more stupid and less funny than the old 3 Stooges.

This is an early frontrunner for Worst Movie of 2010. Even if it ends up being funny, I highly doubt it will effectively capture the comedic methods of the old stooges.

murray m.

murray m. on 03-31-2009 05:06 AM

always preferred shemp instead of curly myself.

murray m.

murray m. on 03-31-2009 05:09 AM

maybe del toro would be better as shemp ?

murray m.

murray m. on 04-4-2009 05:40 PM

wasnt shemp the original stooge before curly ?

What's Hot On RT

Critics Consensus
Critics Consensus

Journey 2 Not Worth the Trip

Luis Guzman
Luis Guzman

What are his 10 best movies ever?

<em>Amazing Spider-Man</em>
Amazing Spider-Man

See the all-new action-packed trailer!

The Avengers!
The Avengers!

Five new Marvelous pictures

Help | About | Jobs | Newsletter | Critics Submission | API | Licensing | Blog | Developers | Mobile