ROTTEN TOMATOES: Even Earth is Heavenly in Lovely Bones Comments

Even Earth is Heavenly in Lovely Bones

by Fred Topel | January 15, 2008

Summary

Soairse Ronan goes from the acclaim of Atonement to tackling Peter Jackson's adaptation of the beloved novel The Lovely Bones. Ronan plays Susie Salmon, the murdered girl who watches her family cope from heaven. She is still awaiting production on heaven, but even shooting the earth scenes have been magical. Back to Article

(1-17 of 17 posts) | Reply

KGattise writes:
on Jan 15 2008 12:22 PM

I haven't seen Atonement yet, so I don't know Ronan's potential as an actress. But, since Peter Jackson is directing it, I can't wait. His vision is absolutely remarkable. I'm kind of excited how he will portray heaven. He made LOTR with such great emotional elements, and I hope he will do the same here.

(Reply to this)

Jen Yamato writes:
on Jan 15 2008 12:25 PM

Atonement is excellent, and so is Ronan.

(Reply to this)

Ruckas356 writes:
on Jan 15 2008 12:31 PM

I always hear something about "the lovly bones" but people act like everyone knows what its about. Like everyone reads books.

(Reply to this)

jimmers_205 writes:
on Jan 15 2008 12:38 PM

Ronan was drop dead amazing in Atonement. I can't wait to see her in this!

(Reply to this)

Bardego writes:
on Jan 15 2008 12:40 PM

It's not *that* surprising, Ruckas. The Lovely Bones a huge hit when it first came out.

(Reply to this)

Bardego writes:
on Jan 15 2008 12:41 PM

EDIT: was a huge hit when it first came out.

(Reply to this)

sobek1 writes:
on Jan 15 2008 01:45 PM

is it just me, or does she say the word "stuff" a whole lot?

(Reply to this)

glhxckid writes:
on Jan 15 2008 02:13 PM

sobek... that's the first thing I noticed.

(Reply to this)

lavatory love machine writes:
on Jan 15 2008 02:15 PM

I saw atonement last night and I found her to be extremly annyoning, but then again that's what the character supposed to be

so either she's a very good actress or a very annyoning person

(Reply to this)

rt_hire_me writes:
on Jan 15 2008 02:22 PM

'beloved novel' Didn't like it, and I know that's swimming upstream because everyone liked it. I was waiting for Harvey to get his comeuppance, and I don't want to spoil anything... let's just say noone gets their finger bit off or falls into a lava pit or swats a plane.

(Reply to this)

rsav1976 writes:
on Jan 15 2008 03:28 PM

I thought the first half of the novel was very good, but it sort of limped on in the second half and turned into a dysfunctional family drama until the end. The end with Mr Harvey should be cool on film though. I always believed that the story was better suited as a movie than a book. There's a ton of potential here, but anyone expecting this to be some great epic action movie like LOTR will be sorely disappointed. This is as much a love story, maybe more so, as it is a thriller. I hope Jackson livens it up, but the story is good enough to carry the film.

(Reply to this)

h-town24 writes:
on Jan 15 2008 04:07 PM

Sweet!

(Reply to this)

BowieSwimmer writes:
on Jan 15 2008 05:12 PM

LOVED Atonement.
Love Ronan.
Hope Jackson can deliver on one of my favorite books [except I hope he cuts out Sebold's only misstep, where Susan's character inhabits the body of her friend, You'll know what I'm talking about if you've read the book]. We all know he can do the big-budget, epic fantasy films, but hopefully he'll surprise on his first smaller project.
That being said, Ronan's comments sound marvelous.
I'm beyond excited.

(Reply to this)

Jimbo93 writes:
on Jan 15 2008 05:22 PM

In reply to this comment (#1472751)
This is hardly Jackson's first "small project:, BowieSwimmer. Remember "Heavenly Creatures", about 2 imaginative girls in New Zealand who commit murder? That's hardly a big budget fantasy epic, but its very good. I think Jackson will do a great job, but I want the read the book sometime.

(Reply to this)

TheMisfortuneTeller writes:
on Jan 15 2008 10:18 PM

I have no interest whatsoever in "back from the grave" or "looking on from 'heaven'" scenarios. Death loses all its power and emotional affectiveness absent its finality. When people die, they stop. They don't "start up" again -- sort of -- somewhere -- somehow. As well, inarticulate actors who populate their inane utterances with redundant references to "stuff" leave me uninterested in seeing any movies in which they appear. Thanks for the warning, though.

(Reply to this)

jasperoosterveld writes:
on Jan 16 2008 12:55 AM

Good choise :)

(Reply to this)

Kimmycat24 writes:
on Jan 17 2008 09:30 AM

I read the book several years ago and loved it. She was fantastic in "Atonement" and I think she will be great in "The Lovely Bones". She has a bright future ahead of her.

(Reply to this)

Related Links

The Lovely Bones

Related Articles

Most Discussed

Latest News

Latest Interviews

Latest Features

Sponsored Links