Click to read the article
Smart People (2008)
Tomatometer
How does the Tomatometer work ![]()
Reviews Counted:136
Fresh:67
Rotten:69
Average Rating:5.6/10
Consensus: Despite its sharp cast and a few laughs, Smart People is too thinly plotted to fully resonate.
Rated: R [See Full Rating] for language, brief teen drug and alcohol use, and for some sexuality
Runtime: 1 hr 35 mins
Genre: Comedies
Theatrical Release:Apr 11, 2008 Wide
Box Office: $9,496,882
Synopsis: Dennis Quaid stars as a bitter, washed out widower in SMART PEOPLE, a film that tackles the lives of several seriously unhappy people in surprisingly funny and touching ways. A hated literature... Dennis Quaid stars as a bitter, washed out widower in SMART PEOPLE, a film that tackles the lives of several seriously unhappy people in surprisingly funny and touching ways. A hated literature professor at Carnegie Mellon, Lawrence Wetherhold has been earning the scorn of his students, colleagues, and family since the death of his wife several years ago. The only person on his side is his teenage daughter Vanessa (Ellen Page), whose loyalty and similarities to her father belie her tender age. Between running the Young Republicans club and aiming for a perfect SAT score, the over-achieving high school student knows no life beyond the insular world of family. When the film begins, the family dynamics are well established, with Lawrence merely going through the motions of his life, unable to muster up any passion for parenting or even his literary expertise. It takes a seizure, an unexpected visit from his adopted brother (Thomas Haden Church), and a new romantic interest (Sarah Jessica Parker) to shake things up and stir Lawrence from his constant misery. Driven by a clever script and fine performances, SMART PEOPLE is set in the land of academia, a place where both Lawrence and Vanessa have taken refuge and plunged themselves into as escape from the external world. In spite of their high IQs, both father and daughter are equally clueless when it comes to navigating relationships. This becomes obvious as Vanessa develops a line-blurring relationship with her uncle, and Lawrence stumbles in romancing his doctor. If Vanessa wants a shot at happiness and Lawrence wants to make things work in his love life, both will have to adopt new attitudes or risk further alienation. Church is hilarious as Chuck, Lawrence's adopted slacker brother, adding a funny but heartfelt element to the otherwise serious film. [More]
Starring: Dennis Quaid, Sarah Jessica Parker, Thomas Haden Church, Ellen Page
Starring: Dennis Quaid, Sarah Jessica Parker, Thomas Haden Church, Ellen Page, Ashton Holmes
Director: Noam Murro
Director: Noam Murro
Screenwriter: Mark Jude Poirier
Producer: Bridget Johnson, Michael Costigan, Michael London, Bruna Papandrea
Composer: Nuno Bettencourt
Studio: Miramax Films
Get This Movie
Reviews for Smart People
The director's recurrent habit of flooding his soundtrack with songs whose lyrics emphatically inform the viewer precisely what the characters are feeling is a repeated turn-off.
Smart People was supposed to be comedic drama with a splash of romance. Instead, I have been misled. It's a blandly scripted "poor me" with an attempt at a plot and some glitzy Hollywood names thrown in for good box-office measure.
And since, like 99 percent of all other Sundance-type indies, Smart People is shot in the dreariest grays possible ... the movie's not much to look at, either.
More false than Ms. Hilton's "accidental" panty-flashings, Noam Murro's dull, meandering dramedy reduces love to a montage and mourning to Quaid's inability to ride shotgun
It's impossible to tell whether the film's ending is happy because it's happy or because it's ending.
It wanders all over the place before ending abruptly. With the talent involved, it seems like such a waste.
The film offers some witty one-liners, but it's largely a by-the-numbers affair that really just made me feel better about myself.
It's not a stupid film, but it could have come off much more smartly.
The film certainly feels like it had more to say with these complex characters, only to be gutted by an undefined entity more interested in infuriating brevity than fulfilling storytelling.
The overreaching script by novelist Mark Poirier is intermittently funny. One gets the sense that Poirier was aiming for Scrabulous dialogue but his movie is barely of Boggle quality.
Smart People serves up everything you'd want in a shrewd indie picture but is strangely inert.
The film brandishes the same anti-intellectual cliché we've heard time and again: Extremely smart folks are inherently unpleasant, uptight and unhappy. 'Tis better to be a touch dumb.
Novelist-turned-screenwriter Mark Poirier gives the capable, eclectic cast some real zingers to play with, but he also loads his script with some plot contrivances that are simply too hard to accept.
Though the principals are so appealing with their smart, comical exchanges, the film's forced situations keep it from being the clever, engaging tale it aspires to be.
Somebody should have told screenwriter Mark Poirier that it's oxymoronic to trumpet a Republican character as a "smart" person in this well-acted but underwhelming comedy.
Smart People isn't so much anti-intellectual as it is hyper-ignorant of the ways in which people interact and behave.
Latest News for Smart People
September 22, 2008:
CGunderground.com: A cast of such sad sacks, that it's pretty astonishing when the lusty sparks begin to fly between any of them, and with an overload of brain power coming across as some kind of mental impairment. ![]()
More...
August 11, 2008:
RT on DVD: New South Park, The Wire, and an Exclusive Look at Smart People,
This week we bring you an exclusive look from the DVD release of Smart People, starring Dennis Quaid and Ellen Page as a father and daughter whose intellect outweighs their... More...
August 08, 2008:
A cast of such sad sacks, that it's pretty astonishing when the lusty sparks begin to fly between any of them, and with an overload of brain power coming across as some kind of mental impairment. Sarah Jessica Parker's Sex and the UniverCity comedown. ![]()
More...
April 12, 2008:
A cast of such sad sacks, that it's pretty astonishing when the lusty sparks begin to fly between any of them, and with an overload of brain power coming across as some kind of mental impairment. Sarah Jessica Parker's Sex and the UniverCity comedown. ![]()
More...
| Tomatometer Percentage | Movie | Date |
|---|---|---|
| 83% 83% | The Princess and the Frog | 12/11 |
| 83% 83% | A Single Man | 12/11 |
| 64% 64% | The Lovely Bones | 12/11 |
| | Invictus | 12/11 |
| | Avatar | 12/18 |
RT On Current TV
DIRECTV 358 | Comcast 107 | DISH Network 196 | More...
What’s Hot On RT
Other News
CloseSponsored Links
Around The Network
- Smart People at Rotten Tomatoes
- Smart People at IGN
Fresh Links
Featured

The director talks about puppetry perfection and his film, Fantastic Mr. Fox

Hollywood.com ponders whether or not an animated film could win Best Picture.

Richard Corliss previews the season's best offerings and hottest tickets.

The AV Club's Mike D'Angelo airs his beefs with Alfonso Cuaron's Children of Men.
Promos

Get the latest Tomatometer updates on upcoming movies!



Top Critic



