RottenTomatoes.com
Log In | Register | What is RT?
RT's Blu-ray HQ
  • Home
  • Movies
  • DVD
  • Celebrities
  • News
  • Critics
  • Trailers & Pictures
  • CommunityBeta
  • Features
  • | Columns
  • | Guides
RT Search Powered by Google
help icon Enhanced RT
searches on Google
Click here to turn on enhanced search results from RT on your Google searches.
 
News / Columns / Critics Consensus
Critics Consensus: Pelham 1 2 3 Doesn't Quite Take
Plus, Imagine That could use a little more imagination.
by Tim Ryan | June 11, 2009
Discuss Article

This week at the movies, we've got a railway heist (The Taking of Pelham 1 2 3, starring Denzel Washington and John Travolta) and some magical financial advice (Imagine That, starring Eddie Murphy and Yara Shahidi). What do the critics have to say?


52%
Template Image
Rotten

The Taking of Pelham 1 2 3

The Taking of Pelham One Two Three, from 1974, was a stylish mix of comedy and thrills that, despite its reputation, is just dated enough to warrant a remake. However, critics say that Tony Scott's take, while slick and hyperkinetic, lacks the grit and cool of the original. John Travolta stars as Ryder, who takes control of a New York City subway car and its passengers, demanding a hefty ransom. Meanwhile, subway dispatcher Garber (Denzel Washington) tries to thwart Ryder's plot. The pundits say the film is well-acted but has little sense of economy or patience; it's a well-made but empty exercise. (See our feature "A Hundred Years of Heist Films," in which we break down the caper genre by decade.)


38%
Template Image
Rotten

Imagine That

Imagine That has an intriguing premise, especially in these economically tumultuous times: what if a child's fantasy world could predict the ebb and flow of the stock market? Unfortunately, critics say Imagine That does little with its setup, despite solid work from Eddie Murphy and newcomer Yara Shahidi. Murphy stars as Evan Danielson, a financial advisor who spends little time with his daughter. That changes when he discovers that her drawings and imaginary friends appear to have a preternatural understanding of the investment world. But will Evan learn to become a better dad? The pundits say Murphy is admirably restrained, and Shahidi is a natural, but the film around them is only sporadically amusing; it's also overly gimmicky and predictable. (Check out this week's Total Recall, in which we count down Murphy's best-reviewed films.)


Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Youssou N'Dour: I Bring What I Love, a documentary about the great Senegalese singer and his attempt to bridge the musical divide between the sacred and the secular, is at 100 percent.
  • Food Inc., a doc about corporate control (and the lack of governmental oversight) over the food industry, is at 95 percent.
  • Moon, starring Sam Rockwell and Kevin Spacey in a dark thriller about corporate skullduggery on the lunar surface, is at 90 percent.
  • Sex Positive, a doc about the complex life and times of gay health activist Richard Berkowitz, is at 67 percent.
  • Blast!, a doc about a team of tenacious scientists and their search for the origins of life on Earth, is at 60 percent.
  • Francis Ford Coppola's latest, Tetro, starring Vincent Gallo as a man living in Buenos Aires and haunted by his past, is at 50 percent.

Related Items
Movie: Imagine That
Food, Inc.
Sex Positive
Tetro
BLAST!
Youssou N'Dour: I Bring What I Love
Moon
Bookmark and Share
Comments (1-20 of 30 posts) | Reply
MovieMaster
MovieMaster writes:
on Jun 11 2009 04:45 PM

Despite the reviews I'll be seeing Taking of Pelham 1 2 3 this weekend. But Eddie Murphy needs to pick some better movies soon if he still wants to have a career.

(Reply to this)
thisguyjones
thisguyjones writes:
on Jun 11 2009 06:03 PM

"Wants" a career? Shouldn't it be over at this point?

"Meet Dave"
"Norbit"
"The Haunted Mansion"
"The Adventures of Pluto Nash"

All major bombs.

I guess he is getting a fair amount of grace from the Shreks, Daddy
Day Cares and Dr.Dolittles.



(Reply to this)
De4ective Detectiv3
De4ective Detectiv3 writes:
on Jun 11 2009 06:05 PM

Taking of Pelham 1 2 3 screamed of underwhelming remake since the first time I saw the trailer. Does Denzel Washington really think he can fill Walter Malthau's shoes!??!?!?

If they really had an interesting take on the heist movie they wouldn't need to do a remake.


(Reply to this)
tomwaitsjr
tomwaitsjr writes:
on Jun 11 2009 06:40 PM

IMAGINE THAT, the family film with Eddie Murphy, is using a cover of Billy Idol's song about masterbation, "Dancing with myself." as its theme/during commercials. HA!

I'm still not going to see it!

Rather watch HANGOVER again! Can repeat the funny lines to the screen.


(Reply to this)
Chris B.
Chris B. writes:
on Jun 11 2009 07:35 PM

wow tomwaitsjr i guess it must be nice to know that kind of information. i wish i could go see pelham BUT i'm and currently broke and i'd rather save my money and go see transformers in a couple weeks. i'll prolly wait for the dvd.

(Reply to this)
Mr. Bo Ziffer
Mr. Bo Ziffer writes:
on Jun 11 2009 07:38 PM

If Eddie Murphy keeps picking these movies, pretty soon Charlie Murphy will have a better movie track record. THAT'S DEPRESSING! Also, as much as I like Tony Scott, he has been making the same movie over and over again since Enemy Of The State. I do like him paired up with Denzel Washington, but they need a real script to work with, not something Scott made ten years ago, or what someone else made thirty-five years ago.

(Reply to this)
Boxman
Boxman writes:
on Jun 11 2009 07:47 PM

Even though Pelham 123 looks like a good old fashion thriller with good actors like denzel and travolta it looks kind of predicable and forgettable so i think i'll wait til it comes on dvd. An im not even gonna bother seeing Eddie Murphy's movie not even when it come out on dvd cause it looks so bad. Eddie must think just because he has kids playing with with him in a movie he gonna do well at the boxoffice which it doesn't at all.

(Reply to this)
lamont j.
lamont j. writes:
on Jun 11 2009 07:48 PM

In reply to this comment (#2512543)
Denzel can fill anybody's shoes!...have you actually watched any of his movies?

(Reply to this)
Hans M.
Hans M. writes:
on Jun 11 2009 07:59 PM

The wide releases this week never sounded interesting to me form the beginning, no matter what the critics say. I'm glad to see Moon get good reviews. I had high hopes for that. His first short film ("Whistle") showed great promise.

(Reply to this)
fullmetal_medji
fullmetal_medji writes:
on Jun 11 2009 08:34 PM

I want to see Pelham 123 because it looks somewhat interesting. I like washington and Travolta anyway. Imagine That isn't as bad as Murphy's kid film, but that's not saying a lot. Murphy needs to go back to what he does best: standup comedy. Coppola has a new movie out it's rotten. I don't think Coppola has had a good movie since Godfather 3. Hell that movie wasn't very good either. :(

(Reply to this)
tomwaitsjr
tomwaitsjr writes:
on Jun 11 2009 08:39 PM

In reply to this comment (#2512564)
hey! It's a great song, off Rebel yell if I remember right.

Lots of people get screwed up meanings from songs. BORN IN THE USA and PINK HOUSES were both anti-Republican, but the Republicans wanted to use them for election.

That said, I still say the best choice is to see THE HANGOVER again.


(Reply to this)
ledawg1138
ledawg1138 writes:
on Jun 11 2009 09:30 PM

Eddie Murphy should be in "1 2 3", in dual roles! Relax, it's a joke.

(Reply to this)
halinwlf
halinwlf writes:
on Jun 11 2009 10:23 PM

It amazes me that people actually pay to watch Eddie Murphy any more,48 hours, Trading Places and Coming to America are the only decent films he has made in his entire career and that is ancient history.Surrounding himself with cute kids doesn`t make him cute or funny.

(Reply to this)
TheCaptain of TeamLoyalty
TheCaptain of TeamLoyalty writes:
on Jun 11 2009 10:59 PM

Born in the USA is not anti republican, it is anti war and anti greed.

(Reply to this)
wastelandrider
wastelandrider writes:
on Jun 11 2009 11:17 PM

In reply to this comment (#2512590)
Exactly.

(Reply to this)
wastelandrider
wastelandrider writes:
on Jun 11 2009 11:18 PM

In reply to this comment (#2512590)
Exactly.

(Reply to this)
NTROST
NTROST writes:
on Jun 12 2009 12:13 AM

In reply to this comment (#2512569)
@lamont j.
Denzel can fill anybody's shoes?

I mean don't get me wrong, I think Denzel Washington is a solid actor but to make a statement you just said is clearly overhasty & injudicious let alone untenable. I'm sorry to say Denzel Washington didn't out do Frank Sinatra in "The Manchurian Candidate" remake (So, he didn't fill those shoes even though the story had differences) & he isn't like the one-of-a-kind Walter Matthau. Denzel is a great actor but sorry to say Denzel can not fill just anybody's shoes. Denzel Washington is the modern day Sidney Poitier even though Sidney Poitier is overall superior. But again, Denzel Washington is great actor & usually consistant but your statement is a blinkered short-sighted & ill-judged comment.


(Reply to this)
Scott Love
Scott Love writes:
on Jun 12 2009 12:18 AM

Are you guys planning on doing any more of the video weekly review reviews? Those were great. I always laughed a lot at the subtle humor of which clips you would put before the "Rotten" or "Fresh" labels at the end of the reviews.

(Reply to this)
Scott Love
Scott Love writes:
on Jun 12 2009 12:20 AM

In reply to this comment (#2512580)
ha ha ha%u2026careful, man - they might do it.

(Reply to this)
NTROST
NTROST writes:
on Jun 12 2009 12:21 AM

On another note, the Tony Scott's remake of "The Taking Of Pelham 1 2 3" just doesn't out do the 1974 Joseph Sargent's original "The Taking Of Pelham One Two Three".

This is one of those remakes that just doesn't out do the original by any margin.


(Reply to this)
Read More Comments
Page | 1 2
Post Your Comment
You must be registered to post comments. Login or Register.

Related Links

The Taking of Pelham 1 2 3
  • Pictures
  • Posters
  • News
  • Forum

Related Articles

  • 10 Hair-raising Moments With John Travolta (3)
  • Submit to the RT Show and Earn a Cool $100 (5)
  • Watch RT on Current TV (3)
  • Comparing the Takings of Pelham 1 2 3 Opens in new window (6)
  • Critics Consensus: Pelham 1 2 3 Doesn't Quite Take (30)
  • Box Office Guru Preview: Travolta Faces Off With Denzel in 1 2 3 (11)
  • A Hundred Years of Heist Films (46)
  • Brian Helgeland Talks Robin Hood, The Taking of Pelham 123, More Opens in new window (1)
  • RT Interview: Tony Scott on The Taking of Pelham 1 2 3 (10)
  • Exclusive: Tony Scott talks Warriors (38)

Most Discussed

  • Box Office Guru Wrapup: New Moon Shatters Records (175)
  • Critics Consensus: New Moon Wanes (129)
  • Tomatometer Watch: Will Twilight's New Moon Dazzle? (97)
  • Total Recall: Star-Crossed Lovers (75)
  • Total Recall: John Travolta's Best Movies (71)
  • Weekly Ketchup: Idris Elba cast in Thor, more Spider-Man 4 rumors (58)
  • Friday Harvest: New Moon, Avatar, and more! (32)
  • Critics Consensus: Flee From Ninja Assassin (21)
  • RT on DVD & Blu-Ray: Angels & Demons, Funny People, and Superman (18)
  • WB offers DVD to Blu-ray Trade-In Program (16)

Latest News

  • Five Favorite Films With Zombieland Director Ruben Fleischer (5)
  • WB offers DVD to Blu-ray Trade-In Program (16)
  • RT's Blu-ray Picks from WB (4)
  • Critics Consensus: Flee From Ninja Assassin (21)
  • RT's Disney Animation Celebration --- A Walk Through The Magic Kingdom! (0)
  • "I Don't Hate Women": Lars von Trier on Antichrist (12)
  • Total Recall: John Travolta's Best Movies (71)
  • RT on DVD & Blu-Ray: Angels & Demons, Funny People, and Superman (18)
  • Box Office Guru Wrapup: New Moon Shatters Records (175)
  • Weekly Ketchup: Idris Elba cast in Thor, more Spider-Man 4 rumors (58)

Latest Interviews

  • "I Don't Hate Women": Lars von Trier on Antichrist (12)
  • Eric Bana talks Love the Beast - RT Interview (9)
  • Fight Club Sound Designer Reflects on Film's 10th Anniversary (19)
  • James Schamus talks Taking Woodstock - RT Interview (6)
  • John Hurt Talks Harry Potter, Quentin Crisp and Alien - The RT Interview (15)
  • Terry Gilliam Talks Doctor Parnassus (20)
  • Wes Anderson Talks Fantastic Mr. Fox - RT Interview (8)
  • Wolverine Creator Len Wein Talks About the Film (28)
  • Gavin Hood Talks Wolverine; Possible Sequel (28)
  • Duncan Jones talks Moon, Sam Rockwell, and Mute (14)

Latest Features

  • Five Favorite Films With Zombieland Director Ruben Fleischer (5)
  • "I Don't Hate Women": Lars von Trier on Antichrist (12)
  • Fight Club Sound Designer Reflects on Film's 10th Anniversary (19)
  • Five Favourite Films with Ang Lee (34)
  • 10 Movies That Changed The (End Of The) World (32)
  • Ho-ho-horror! 10 Scary Christmas Movies (39)
  • 12 Facts About 2012 (135)
  • Terry Gilliam Talks Doctor Parnassus (20)
  • Five Favourite Films with 24's Carlos Bernard (33)
  • Six Horrible Part Sixes (32)

Sponsored Links

 
 
About| Site Map| Help| RT To Go| Contact Us| Critics Submission| Linking to RT| Licensing| Movie List| Games| Celebs List| Newsletter
IGN Logo

IGN.com | GameSpy | Comrade | Arena | FilePlanet | GameSpy Technology
TeamXbox | Planets | Vaults | VE3D | CheatsCodesGuides | GameStats | GamerMetrics
AskMen.com | Rotten Tomatoes | Direct2Drive | Green Pixels


By continuing past this page, and by the continued use of this site, you agree to be bound by and abide by the User Agreement.
Copyright 1998-2009, IGN Entertainment, Inc. About IGN | Support | Advertise | Privacy Policy | User Agreement | Subscribe to RT's XML feed! IGN RSS Feeds
IGN's enterprise databases running Oracle, SQL and MySQL are professionally monitored and managed by Pythian Remote DBA
Certain product data ©1995-present Muze, Inc. For personal use only. All rights reserved.