What don't you guys get? These critics are reviewing the movie, not the book! It's not the critic's job to read the book first. That would make him a bad critic. He should be judging the movie based on the movie itself, not how it compares to the book. Who's fault is it when a movie doesn't do a book justice? The director, producer, film crew and actors. These critics watched the movie and gave their reviews and impressions of George from how RPattz played him and what they saw in the movie.
I'm sorry, but it sounds like you're just a bitter old RPattz fan who can't stand to see him get yet ANOTHER bad review. When you're a horrible actor, that's what you get.
Gabriele Cookstown
George isn't a likeable character...can you guys not do a tiny winy bit of research before you write a critic...I wish I could earn my money like that
Mar 9 - 07:05 AM
Kris Mayle
What don't you guys get? These critics are reviewing the movie, not the book! It's not the critic's job to read the book first. That would make him a bad critic. He should be judging the movie based on the movie itself, not how it compares to the book. Who's fault is it when a movie doesn't do a book justice? The director, producer, film crew and actors. These critics watched the movie and gave their reviews and impressions of George from how RPattz played him and what they saw in the movie.
I'm sorry, but it sounds like you're just a bitter old RPattz fan who can't stand to see him get yet ANOTHER bad review. When you're a horrible actor, that's what you get.
Apr 1 - 12:16 PM
Gabriele Cookstown
may you eat your filthy words after he'll receive praise for Cosmopolis..and who do you think gives you the right to judge me...
Apr 4 - 05:51 AM