Black Butterflies (2012)

TOMATOMETER

AUDIENCE SCORE

Critic Consensus: No consensus yet.


Movie Info

Poetry, politics, madness, and desire collide in the true story of the woman hailed as South Africa's Sylvia Plath. In 1960s Cape Town, as Apartheid steals the expressive rights of blacks and whites alike, young Ingrid Jonker (Carice van Houten) finds her freedom scrawling verse while frittering through a series of stormy affairs. Amid escalating quarrels with her lovers and her rigid father, a parliament censorship minister (Rutger Hauer), the poet witnesses an unconscionable event that will … More

Rating: Unrated
Genre: Drama
Directed By:
Written By: Greg Latter
In Theaters:
On DVD: Jul 17, 2012
Runtime:
Tribeca Films - Official Site

Cast


as Ingrid Jonker

as Jack Cope

as Uys Krige

as Eugene Maritz

as Anna Jonker

as Abraham Jonker

as Ettiene le Roux

as Mike Loots

as Pieter Venter

as Lucille (Lulu)
Show More Cast

Friend Ratings

No Friends? Inconceivable! Log in to see what your friends have to say.

Login

Critic Reviews for Black Butterflies

All Critics (12) | Top Critics (8)

Van Houten ... gives a strong performance as Jonker, and the cinematography is pleasing, but the script is cliché-ridden and ends on an overly sentimental note.

Full Review… | March 2, 2012
New York Post
Top Critic

The movie reminds you of the extent to which poetry has been marginalized as a cultural force since the early 1960s.

Full Review… | March 1, 2012
New York Times
Top Critic

Black Butterflies scarcely tries to illuminate the substance of Jonker's writing.

Full Review… | March 1, 2012
AV Club
Top Critic

Black Butterflies is a dark, moving depiction of the life and death of a brave rebellious, idiosyncratic woman who made significant strides toward changing the world around her and paid a heavy toll for her passion.

Full Review… | February 29, 2012
New York Observer
Top Critic

Always feels like a life schematically condensed rather than intimately explored.

Full Review… | February 29, 2012
Time Out
Top Critic

Art, politics, and craziness conspire to form a rather mechanical melodrama in Black Butterflies...

Full Review… | February 28, 2012
Village Voice
Top Critic

Audience Reviews for Black Butterflies

Nice movie, albeit very slow, and depressing.

itsjustme2004
Cynthia S.

Super Reviewer

½

In 1960 South Africa, Jack Cope(Liam Cunningham) saves Ingrid Jonker(Carice van Houten) from drowning. They bond over the fact that they are both writers; his prose and her poetry. In short time, they fall in love as she moves into his house. But since somebody forgot to get their divorce finalized, marriage is off the table. Which might be for the best as Jack suspects Ingrid of being interested in anything in pants.

"Black Butterflies" has all the elements of a good movie like history, literature, excellent cinematography, lots of period detail and Liam Cunningham who can simply do no wrong. What it does not have is any idea where to start, eventually getting to its point. In fact the movie should have spent more time in Ingrid's childhood, which is what formed who she would become, for better and worse, instead of reductively going for daddy issues.(Well, daddy(Rutger Hauer) was a government censor...)

While Carice van Houten has a go for broke attitude, she does not have an equal level of talent that would allow her to breathe life into such a complicated person. In being a movie about an unconventionial and mentally unstable woman, the movie takes the most conventional approach possible by focusing on the relationship between Jack and Ingrid. In any case, these people's melodramatic issues cannot compare to those suffering under the heel of Apartheid at the same time.

Harlequin68
Walter M.

Super Reviewer

Black Butterflies Quotes

– Submitted by Chris P (3 years ago)

Discussion Forum

Discuss Black Butterflies on our Movie forum!