Average Rating: 5.3/10
Reviews Counted: 8
Fresh: 2 | Rotten: 6
No consensus yet.
Average Rating: N/A
Critic Reviews: 2
Fresh: 1 | Rotten: 1
liked it
Average Rating: 3.9/5
User Ratings: 314
Greer Garson is dignity and integrity personified in the role of the real-life Edna Gladney. After several life experiences which rival daytime drama for unrelenting misery and melodrama, Edna marries flour-mill owner Sam Gladney (Walter Pidgeon). They have a baby, who dies shortly after Edna discovers that she can never have any other children. To give her life some meaning, Edna sets up the Texas Children's Home and Aid Society, which specializes in caring for illegitimate children and
Jul 25, 1941 Wide
All Critics (8) | Top Critics (2) | Fresh (2) | Rotten (6) | DVD (1)
Result is a sentimentally sugary flavor which also extends over the romantic portions of the film. There is no comedy relief.
With lovely Greer Garson playing the leading role, the spirit of the story is maintained on a level generally above its frequent insipid spots.
It was a noble deed and a noble effort to make a biography about a woman who was virtually unknown outside Texas, but the picture was long, overly teary, and didn't excite too many people at the box office, although it did make money.
Littered with stilted melodrama, wooden dialogue, and over-the-top courtroom showdowns.
One of the weakest films to be nominated for the Best Picture Oscar, this biopic of Edna Gladney is uncharacteristically poorly scripted by Anita Loos and poorly helmed by Mervyn LeRoy.
So intent on packing as many events as possible into a relatively slim 100 minutes that it can't devote enough time to developing any of them.
Pretty Technicolor, but the tearjerking is shameless.
This successful weepy revealed Garson's red hair in Technicolor for the first time, but was more significant for being the first of eight films she made with Pidgeon.
Greer Garson is one of the best actresses I have ever seen on film. I have only seen three of her films the two above mentioned and "Pride and Prejudice". It might be astonishing to think that I used to call Greer Garson, Greta Garbo. Strange, because they're acting if so different even if their names sound alike. My
September 4, 2005
HAS ALL THE MAKINGS OF A CLASSIC MGM FILM - OUTSTANDING PRODUCTION VALUES, A GREAT CAST, GOOD WRITING AND EXPERT DIRECTION. GREER GARSON IS SUPERB AND HER FREQUENT CO-STAR, WALTER PIDGEON GIVES A FINE, LOW KEY PERFORMANCE. ITS A TEARJERKER DONE WITH GREAT STYLE. FOTSY CLASS ALL THE WAY.
April 10, 2005
| —— | Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance | Feb 17 |
| 45% | This Means War | Feb 14 |
| 94% | The Secret World of Arrietty | Feb 17 |
| 28% | The Vow | $41.2M |
| 52% | Safe House | $40.2M |
| 42% | Journey 2: The Mysterious Island | $27.3M |
| 57% | Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace (in 3D) | $22.5M |
| 86% | Chronicle | $12.1M |
| 64% | The Woman in Black | $10.1M |
| 77% | The Grey | $5.0M |
| 73% | Big Miracle | $3.9M |
| 90% | The Descendants | $3.4M |
| 29% | Underworld Awakening | $2.5M |
| 99% | A Separation | Dec 30 |
| 97% | The Artist | Nov 25 |
| 96% | The Muppets | Nov 23 |
| 96% | Pariah | Dec 28 |
| 96% | Tomboy | Nov 16 |
The Rum Diary, Take Shelter
What are his 10 best movies ever?
See the all-new action-packed trailer!
The Vow leads record-breaking...