Critic Review - Cinema Crazed

The fact that this movie is animated entirely with clay ruined the enjoyment for me while watching this.

April 29, 2009 Full Review Source: Cinema Crazed | Comments (15)
Cinema Crazed

Comments

Wiggins

Wig gins

Wait wait wait! Isn't this admitting to being ignorant? Not liking the movie simply because how it was made or its visuals and not giving it any kind of chance.

Even if this read "I'm not a fan of the style" or "I didn't like the character designs" or something like that it would be one thing. But to out right not give the film a chance just because it is a plastecine stop-motion? That's just ignorant.

Feb 23 - 09:44 PM

Max the Movie Kid

Max Chittock

Way to ruin the 98%. -_- And not liking the movie just because it contains talented claymation? Isn't that racist to its kind of animation? And why didn't he mind The Curse of the Were-Rabbit? 0_o

Apr 8 - 07:28 AM

Sean G.

Sean Gnau

What kind of professional video critic judges with so much weight on style? What happened to the story, character development, plot, all that stuff? Did that matter? Obviously not, I read the entire thing and this film is rated rotten on the sole fact of clay-mation.

Apr 8 - 08:06 PM

THGhost

THGhost .

DICK FARMER!

Mar 29 - 07:07 AM

Jon J.

Jon Johannesson

So... claymation automatically ruins a film for you? How is that in any way a professional decision?

Apr 5 - 03:59 PM

Andrew L.

Andrew Lim

Do you honestly know how hard it is to create claymation? No, I don't think so. Frankly, it is quite stupid of you to not like a movie just because of how it's made. I guess that trumps plot, characters, setting, score, and everything else, eh?

Jun 7 - 12:23 AM

SagaciousFrank

Frank Hodson

I do not understand. To make a movie in that way is no mean feat.

Furthermore, I do not see how it detracts from the enjoyment of the film.

I mean, it's not like you're actually having to watch the film makers meritoriously remodel each frame step by step with the clay.

Jun 22 - 07:14 PM

James Collins

James Collins

Why?

Aug 10 - 02:40 AM

Jesse D.

Jesse Dawson

Actually,if you follow the link and read the review,you'll see that he called the claymation the only drawback and gave it a nine out of ten.

Nov 9 - 06:40 PM

Alicia Lapekas

Alicia Lapekas

So you only dislike the movie's medium? Especially since it is by Peter Lord, Nick Park and their claymation animators known for Wallace and Gromit. Quite a dumb thing to write about, taking the filmography of Lord and Park to begin with and their relationship to clay.

Feb 29 - 09:47 AM

James Marlow

James Marlow

"Unfortunately what ruined this cartoon for me was that I'm not a big fan of
clay-mation. I never have been, which is what prevented this from getting a solid ten and dropped it to a nine."

Why wasn't this fresh?

Mar 25 - 05:45 AM

Zachary Palumbo

Zachary Palumbo

Wait... What? How is this review considered valid?

Apr 6 - 08:38 PM

Nick Schubert

Nick Schubert

How did it ruin the enjoyment for you?
It just made me like it better!

May 20 - 11:14 AM

Sage Benner

Sage Benner

That's completely ridiculous! The animation is what makes this movie great! I feel sorry for you...

Aug 22 - 03:04 PM

JuanYamanda Rangel

JuanYamanda Rangel

A movie can be made out of stick figures and I would give it a shot and still wouldn't judge it by how it's made. Really? and you're a critic?

Oct 12 - 07:22 AM

Help | About | Jobs | Critics Submission | API | Licensing | Mobile