Conviction (2010) - Rotten Tomatoes

Conviction (2010)



Critic Consensus: Less compelling -- and more manipulative -- than it should be, Conviction benefits from its compelling true story and a pair of solid performances from Swank and Rockwell.

Movie Info

CONVICTION is the inspirational true story of a sister's unwavering devotion to her brother. When Betty Anne Waters' (two-time Academy Award winner Hilary Swank) older brother Kenny (Sam Rockwell) is arrested for murder and sentenced to life in 1983, Betty Anne, a Massachusetts wife and mother of two, dedicates her life to overturning the murder conviction. Convinced that her brother is innocent, Betty Anne puts herself through high school, college and, finally, law school in an 18 year quest to free Kenny. With the help of best friend Abra Rice (Academy Award nominee Minnie Driver), Betty Anne pores through suspicious evidence mounted by small town cop Nancy Taylor (Academy Award nominee Melissa Leo), meticulously retracing the steps that led to Kenny's arrest. Belief in her brother - and her quest for the truth - pushes Betty Anne and her team to uncover the facts and utilize DNA evidence with the hope of exonerating Kenny. -- (C) Fox Searchlightmore
Rating: R (for language and some violent images)
Genre: Drama
Directed By:
Written By: Pamela Gray
In Theaters:
On DVD: Feb 1, 2011
Box Office: $6.8M
Fox Searchlight - Official Site


Hilary Swank
as Betty Anne Waters
Sam Rockwell
as Kenny Waters
Minnie Driver
as Abra Rice
Melissa Leo
as Nancy Taylor
Peter Gallagher
as Barry Scheck
Ari Graynor
as Mandy Marsh
Tobias Campbell
as Young Kenny
Bailee Madison
as Young Betty Anne
Clea DuVall
as Brenda Marsh
Karen Young
as Elizabeth Waters
Talia Balsam
as Prosecuting Attorney
Juliette Lewis
as Roseanna Perry
Thomas Mahard
as Law Professor
Laurie Brown
as Law Professor 2
Rusty Mewha
as Desk Sergeant
York Griffith
as Desk Sergeant 2
Marc Macaulay
as Officer Boisseau
Frank Zieger
as Boyfriend
Iris Ingram
as Guy's Girlfriend
John Lepard
as Minister
Jake Andolina
as State Trooper
Wallace Bridges
as Global Van Lines Wit...
Marty Bufalini
as Defense Attorney
Doug Hamilton
as Medical Examiner
Sarab Kamoo
as Blood Expert
Hugh McGuire
as Trial Judge
Michele Messmer
as Mrs. Brow
Annabel Armour
as Social Service Woman
Toya Brazell
as Court Clerk
Heather Kozlakowski
as Jury Foreman
Matthew Hollerbach
as Law Student
Zack Fealk
as Law Student 2
Linda Hurd
as Bar Exam Woman
Paul Burt
as Prison Guard "Stash"
Gary Davis
as Prison Guard 2
Rick LeFevour
as Prison Guard 3
Gordon Michaels
as Lt. Daniels
Ethan Cutkowsky
as Neighborhood Boy
Alana Jo Beckman
as Neighborhood Girl
Ethan Cutkosky
as Neighborhood Boy
Eddie Hurch
as Courthouse Clerk
Jane Alderman
as Mrs. Halloran
Janet Ulrich Brooks
as Dr. McGilvray
Jennifer Roberts
as Martha Coakley
Linda Boston
as Release Judge
Kam Carman
as Reporter
Julio Ho
as Reporter 2
Peter Carey
as Reporter 3
Melissa Bickerton
as Admissions Counselor
Show More Cast

News & Interviews for Conviction

Critic Reviews for Conviction

All Critics (180) | Top Critics (38)

Blandly inspirational, with a minimum of you-go-girl montages and even less suspense.

Full Review… | April 28, 2015
Philadelphia Weekly

Conviction is way too routine, not fleshed out enough and rather uninspired. I'd recommend it for a watch just for the performances alone but that's it.

Full Review… | November 9, 2013
We Got This Covered

It has pretty much every cliche for Oscar season you're likely to see.

Full Review… | November 5, 2013
7M Pictures

'Conviction' seldom fails to win on appeal.

Full Review… | May 26, 2013
The Patriot Ledger

Hilary Swank won her two Oscars for other films, but this may be her best performance yet.

Full Review… | February 1, 2013
Movie Nation

Hilary Swank delivers in this compelling tale of a woman who attends law school to prove her brother's innocence in court.

Full Review… | January 6, 2013
Big Hollywood

Audience Reviews for Conviction

Conviction could have been a compelling, extremely moving, and heat-warming story, but the way Tony Goldwyn and the cast of Conviction tell it, it's not so gripping (boring even at parts) and compelling, but it tries to manipulate the audience to care, to cry, to cheer. But to tell the truth, it got about half-way. There is almost no history to these characters, and there are a lot of people to remember the names of, and we are supposed to hate, or love these people, but we don't know much about them, nor have we seen much of them either. The performances by Hilary Swank, Sam Rockwell, Melissa Leo, Minnie Driver, Juliette Lewis, Baliee Madison, and Tobias Campbell are what keep this film above water. See this film for the extraordinary performances, if for nothing else.

Raymond Wieser
Raymond Wieser

Super Reviewer

Sometimes you swear that you've seen a film before - Conviction is like that... where have you seen this type of plot boiler before? The kind of film that preaches rather than educates and tries to get by on the "true story" aspect instead of giving us something riveting and original to chew on. Not that the story itself isn't compelling, but the whole "woman forsakes all (including her family) to attempt to free her brother" (umm, isn't he family... ok, so she forsakes her husband and neglects her kids (who still love and cherish her as portrayed in several Hallmark moments) in favor of her brother (who is ying to her yang as shown in several childhood flashbacks) is simply so unbelievable and trite that it makes your teeth hurt.

Did I mention that this film also tries to rely on star power? Hillary Swank takes the lead as the sister of a convicted murderer. Sadly she doesn't do a lot of heavy lifting here, but I suppose she is sincere enough, though hemmed in by the aforementioned plodding and overripe plot. She does well at setting her jaw and showing the dogged, against all odds determination that the role requires. However, Sam Rockwell is the real deal in the film, demanding your attention in every scene he's in, as he plays the "bad boy" who gets tabbed for the in home robbery and murder of an elderly neighbor.

The film attempts to heighten the drama by playing cat and mouse with the "did he do it?" question, but later fall flat as it glosses over some of the police procedural aspects, while dwelling too long on others. The courtroom scenes in which the prosecution parades a series of damning testimonies is almost laughable - I was just waiting for his attorney to object or drill holes into the flimsy narratives, but it never came - yet another example of how the film tries to manipulate and ram "the facts" down your throat, with no regard to how the hole thing plays.

The wonderful Mellissa Leo is miscast and underused as the female cop (another faux pas as she is somehow the lead investigator and isn't even a detective... oops), and Minnie Driver as the "buddy" of the film is also underused - what a waste of two fine acting talents.

The film seemed as if it couldn't decide whether it was a police procedural mystery, or a human character study - and as is usually the case when a film can't decide - it failed at both.

Still, there is enough to chew on here to give this a marginal passing grade. I was nodding in agreement at the inferred bit of human nature as the prosecuting attorney, now a high powered political wheeler dealer, tries to block the investigation - not wanting to admit that perhaps they convicted the wrong man, she'd rather defy the basic tenants of her profession "let justice be served".

The film adds a final tag that tells us that over 700 convictions have been overturned due to the reopening of cases to allow for DNA evidence. That's just swell, unless you're aware that there is a backlog of over 100,000 cases waiting DNA testing.

paul sandberg

Super Reviewer


Based on fact, this is the true story of one Betty Anne Waters who decides to get her GED, then complete college and law school in an effort to exonerate her brother who has been condemned to life in prison. Kenny Waters was convicted and sentenced in 1983 for the 1980 murder of Katharina Brow in Ayer, Massachusetts.

What ultimately raises Conviction beyond your conventional "triumph over adversity" account, is the acting. Hilary Swank and Sam Rockwell are Betty Anne and Kenny, respectively. As siblings they convey a deep bond as family who have grown up together and remained close into adulthood. We see them as kids and then as adults, willingly supporting each other at various points throughout. Their portrayals are genuine and engaging. Betty Anne's devotion to her brother is the emotional connection that causes the viewer to be invested in this material.

Director Tony Goldwyn will always be best remembered as playing the villain, Carl Bruner, in Ghost. But he has also directed a significant number of TV shows including The L Word, Grey's Anatomy and Dexter. He's a workmanlike director and his comfortableness with TV often pushes the proceedings here into Lifetime movie territory . At times the plot can appear a bit simplistic in the way it unfolds. Great performances are what elevates the melodramatic script to something much more powerful. Impressive depictions from a talented cast make Conviction a film to believe in.

Mark Hobin

Super Reviewer

Conviction Quotes

There are no approved quotes yet for this movie.

Discussion Forum

Discuss Conviction on our Movie forum!