Dead Again Reviews
Super Reviewer
The Problem here is that it get sillier and sillier as further it the takes us into the mystery. And when the climax comes it goes totally over the top with its opera-like approach and bombastic score by Patrick Doyle.
Screenplay by Scott Frank does have many interesting ideas but not many of them truly works. You still have to give credit for Mr. Branagh and Scott Frank for trying something different than following just old cliches. Dead Again reminded me at times like a more sillier version of Hitchcock's fantastic Rebecca, which also had same kind of mystery in the core of it.
Branagh and his lenser Matthew F. Leonetti does wonders when it comes to black and white cinematography. Those moments truly feel like they are lifted from vintage 40's noir. If this film would focus on it's central mystery rather than those many pointless sideplots and karma mumbo-jumbo, it could actually be something very good, maybe even spectacular. Now it feels more like an potentially good film with some nice visual touches and ideas.
Branagh hasa made much better films in his career as a director but this film is not entirely completely bankrupt as a film and does have its merits.
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
The film is well made. Kudos to Andy Garcia's make-up technician. He is as convincing a dying old man as I've seen, complete with a cigarette-smoking tracheotomy! I think I'll give up smoking. Robin Williams also has a meaty, though small role. Its a great ride; the supernatural aspects could have been hokey but instead are gripping and mysterious, especially in the climax.
Whatever happened to Wayne (Hello,Newman) Knight?
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
Dead Again balances its entire storyline on an implausible view of reincarnation, one so much so that it makes the film literally impossible to accept. Having just seen (and enjoyed) Deja Vu, it seems a little unfair of me to pan the film on the basis of a supernatural/larger-than-humanity premise, but at least Deja Vu explored possibilities for its mechanics. Sure, they were tenuous, but they were there. Dead Again creates a shallow philosophical tenet and asking us to weigh our entire suspension of disbelief on it. It is completely risible. Speaking of risible, the climax is almost impossible to take seriously, with a lot of villainous mugging and hilariously uncool one-liners. What a horrible antagonist. Oh, and how gratuitous was the Robin Williams character, really? Veeeeehicle.
Dead Again is a weak mess. Kenneth Branagh's direction, as with his acting, is hit and miss, and the merits that this film is spotted with are far outweighed by the flaws. Skip this one.
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
To be sure, I love good film noir, and Dead Again has its moments. This is especially notable at the start of the film, having a good atmospheric set up, and a certain stylistic touch to the dialogue that I appreciated. As the film progressed, however, it got increasingly melodramatic to the point of almost being self parody. The existence of supernatural 'themes' is not an excuse for a profoundly dumb third act, with motifs about as subtle as the film's climax (an apartment decorated with pictures of scissors, for example).
An overall misguided and disappointing entry by Branagh.
2/5 Stars
Super Reviewer
Dead Again is Kenneth Branagh?s nod to film noir classics with murder, mystery and private detectives, and with a slightly supernatural twist. The film is notable because it?s a superb group of actos from the British stage having fun working together. It?s pretty humorous to see Branagh trying to hold an American accent, as well as Emma Thompson, but watching that old team work together made it almost believable anyway. There?s also a very interesting cameo by Robin Williams, and Wayne Knight (Newman!) in his first significant film role. The performances are what you?d expect from this group: They carry their characters well, and this helps engage the viewer, and the witty script keeps you interested on where this story is going.
The story itself is about the murder of a famous composers? wife, and his subsequent execution. You?d think the story would end there, but in a cleverly scripted set of twists, Branagh?s PI named Mike Church (appropriate) meets an amnesia victim with strange knowledge of the old murder. You might guess the ending long before it comes, but it?s a rather enjoyable journey to get there. It?s not a heavyweight film with a big aspirations, but it?s entertaining, and has a regular doses of ironic humor throughout.
If you like detective drama, you might like Dead Again. There?s no shootouts or memorable chases, as it?s more Agatha Christie than Bourne Supremacy, but it?s solid entertainment for an evening in with some popcorn, and someone you like.
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
"Dead Again" almost feels like a TV picture but suceeds on every level going back to true storytelling that involves more on the characters rather then on the plot.
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
