lee brandt

You obviously would make a terrible filmmaker, and we should be thankful you're not.

Oct 30 - 10:12 AM

James Reed

I guess I appreciate another opinion, but that screenplay is terrific!

Jan 30 - 01:19 PM

rodney olson

Suspension of disbelief is a must when it comes to movie viewing, but DiCaprio as a tough guy? Impossible. Dreadfull movie.

Feb 10 - 03:53 PM

Ed Casey

It reads more like a review of the filmmaker than the film itself.

Mar 23 - 11:32 AM

Unknown Unknown

Jan 15 - 08:55 AM

Ben Brodmann Morales

I feel bad for you. If you couldn't enjoy this movie, than what movie can you enjoy?
It's sad you're just trying to be controversial, you're just starving for attention..

Feb 5 - 12:03 AM

mike barkley

Kauffman your pathetic, ive read your reviews on 3 classic movies, raging bull, goodfellas and now the departed and all of them have the scent of a terrible movie critic whos does more hating on scorsesse than doing his job, whoever hired you is a retard, im sure if scorsesse ever made a movie about a gay pedophile it would be right up your alley, you freak

Nov 26 - 09:43 AM

joe adams

That script was so bad they gave an oscar. Brilliant review numnuts.

Oct 12 - 04:49 PM

anthony bucco

The marketplace and the Academy have voted....

Nov 26 - 10:46 PM

Susan Talbot

I usually love Scorsese films (exc. for the terrible "Gangs of New York"), but this is no "Casino" and certainly no "Goodfellas". "Scraping for material" it is, but that's okay, as long as you know what you're doing. Scorsese is clearly out of his depth in Boston's underworld!

Jun 10 - 05:13 PM

zig fronczak

!@#$%^&*

Jul 14 - 07:57 PM

Ernesto Tobias

hey guys im not gay

Aug 9 - 08:44 PM

Laurence Marzilli

No, scorsese isn't desperate. He made a great realistic film. maybe you should look at the outside world around you and do something write for a change.

Oct 5 - 04:38 PM

William Costigan Jr.

Its funny how you rated all scorses films similarly. You a f u c king desperate, is that how you got that undeserving Top critic star next to your name, by just going against good movies so you are the only one without a tomateo next to their name.

Nov 15 - 11:26 AM

Bo Lotti

It's funny because it won Best Picture and Screenplay.

Nov 23 - 09:42 AM

Vince Rodriguez

You know, one of my dream jobs growing up was being a film critic. You get to pre-view new & anticipated films in private screenings and get submersed in the film world. Sounds great to me. The only thing holding me back was that I thought it would be hard to become a top film critic (as it supposedly is). However, you give me hope Stanley, because you are an INCREDIBLE idiot and your reviews are WAY off base and out of touch. I mean, seriously, you get paid to write the nonsense you do? Amazing, truely amazing. If the film is not a wholesome G or PG flick its crap right? What a warped,1950's era, cheesy brain you have man.

Dec 20 - 10:06 AM

Prats Majmudar

This is "Departed" and you are "retarded"

Dec 26 - 08:14 PM

Michael Bevilacqua

Can you do any better? You're only making fun of him because he's got a couple of years on you you fuck. There's certainly a reason that it was the best film of the year by EVERY OTHER CRITIC.

Mar 16 - 09:53 PM

Austin Pilkington

DiCaprio is amazing again!
Great movie stop being a contrarian!!!

May 26 - 06:18 PM

Bo Lotti

Shawd up, Cwak Sucka.

Jul 1 - 01:13 AM