The Drummer (Jin. gwu) Reviews
April 19, 2013
The power of music is revealed yet again through writer/director Kenneth Bi's imaginative tale of a gangster-in-training ... whose escape from crime-laden Hong Kong to the serenity of rural Taiwan is predicated by his ever-inquisitive hands.
February 20, 2013
Finding a Rhythm
Music can have a profound impact on how we see and experience our world, whether we learn to play it or learn to listen to it. This effect is hard to describe, it is like explaining how an epiphany feels. It is better to witness this effect first hand, of course if that can't be done, it can be shown through story telling. This is what the movie The Drummer does, it shows you how music effected a young man.
The main character, Sid, is the son of a Hong Kong gangster, Kwan, whose hot tempered disposition ruined his marriage driving away Sid's mother. This left him and his sister Sina to grow up with their father's extreme moods. To cope with the loss of his mother Sid turns to drumming. However, Sid also acts out, much like his father and eventually gets his father into trouble with a more powerful member of the Hong Kong underworld. To protect his son Kwan sends Sid away to hide in Taiwan, not Taipei, the metropolis capital of the island, but out in the countryside. While staying there under the watchful eye of an older member of his father's gang, Ah Chiu, Sid discovers in the hills behind his house a group of drummers who practice Zen drumming. While it is Sids' love of drumming that motivates him to join the group, the presence of a firery young woman, Hong Dou, in the troupe doesn't hurt.
Like Zen, the style of drumming portrayed in the film originally comes from China, but both were adopted by Japan. Many in the west are familiar with the large drums beaten upon with thick wooden sticks popularized by troupes such as Kodo, from Japan. To play such instruments takes a different kind of training, it is a full body work out, not counting on the mental training. To be apart of such a group, in the traditional sense, means a high level of commitment and discipline, things that Sid lacks.
Sid is able to join these drummers and goes through a maturation process that helps him cross over into adulthood. This process is not without setbacks as Sid adjusts to the different lifestyle practiced by these monk like performers. He also has difficultly communicating to Hong Dou who he is as a person, which makes for some tension. He has to leave behind his Hong Kong ego and love of wealth and freedom and become a drummer.
The performances in this movie are wonderful and real. Sid is played by Jaycee Chan who clearly shows his character go from cocky brat to intensely focused young man. Tony Leung Ka Fai plays Kwan and brilliantly shows the aggressive gangster who hides away a much softer side and deeper understanding of his faults and how they have effected his children. The actresses in this movie do a top job of being fierce fighters for their place in the world and defenders of the weak. It is the women who fill the strongest roles. Sids' sister, Sina, played by Josie Ho, is a veterinarian and stands up to her fathers wild anger to protect her brother and her choice of husband, never backing down. Hong Dou, played by Angelica Lee, is a disciplined young women with no fear, proven when she attacks Sid in a market area for being a bully. While the troupe is lead by a master drummer, it's run by a woman named Lan Jie, played by Liu Ruo-yu, who is pure example of Zen clam and determination. She is motherly to young Sid, but willing to put him in his place if needed.
The movie is filled with memorable scenes and beautiful camera work. One of the most touching scenes is when Sid, who wants to perform for his father, plays his drums outside the walls of the prison his father is locked away in. There are picturesque shots of the Taiwanese countryside were the drummers practice. These scenes are shot in a way to suggest a protected area, not just the environment, but the art that is practiced there. Kenneth Bi seems to be saying there must be room in our lives for scared places and scared arts. Having always possessed a love for this style of drumming, because of its' highly meditative and intense nature, I was immediately interested in watching this movie. I was pleased to be given more than just a drum-line performance with some cheesy 'boy gets girl after learning to drum' story. I was pleased to see that Kenneth Bi's love of drumming and Zen go much deeper.
January 6, 2013
Beautiful HK/Taiwan Zen drama about the son of a mob boss.
November 30, 2012
The Drummer missed out on a few key elements that stopped it from reaching its unstated goal, which was to make a philosophical statement. Unfortunately, the last gangster part of the movie is very weak. It's not a bad ending per say, it's just badly played out. It's difficult to tell is it's simply the acting that is sub-par, or if it's the scenario, the editing, or even the directing.
When you see the end, you put into question the rest of the movie, and the light it casts just makes it look like low budget movie. It doesn't look that way until the end. What happened? Hard to say.
Exclude the end and you get great visual with an interesting movie, but I can't recommend it because it leaves you with an undesirable aftertaste.
January 22, 2012
A terrific movie. Highly recommend this.
|Christine Joann C||
January 19, 2012
Like a rhythmic Karate Kid flick, with heart-pounding drumming that speaks both to the frustrations and the violence the lead character goes through. And yet the drumming that was once his escape, becomes a new path of transcendence. The cinematic drum performances are poetic and beautiful.
February 15, 2010
A really cool movie with some bizarre dark moments but overall great visually and kinda sweet.
January 11, 2010
-The Drummer-(Jaycee Chan plays Sid, son of the legendary Jackie Chan) Join Sid, a young wreckless teen deprived of a loving father, as he fights to find a reasonable excuse to live the life he desires. He is sent away, after being caught in a secret romance, to the mountains of Taiwan. Struggle with him as he encounters a group of Zen drummers, wanting to join their ranks and desperately trying to learn how to "be one" with himself. Watching this movie makes you realize how meaningful the "growing up" process can be. You can find yourself in the most remote places of this world, but you're never far enough to forget the strongest of emotions, which is love, and you see that only when someone leaves this world, that you have a million questions left unanswered.
December 7, 2009
this movie is wonderful, you have to see it.
June 11, 2009
a film that could easily be misunderstood. cartainly not a jackie chan type movie. the zen/drum community machinations were pretty intrigueing
December 7, 2008
no thanks not my thing
November 20, 2007
This is suspiciously pretentious but the drummin was damned good to watch. A poor summary at best, but can be commended for allowin us a glimpse into the spartan disciplined lives of the mountain drummers. Angelica Lee retains them dagger eyes and we get a bit of Josie Ho too.
October 18, 2007
I like the cast involved. A good mixture of the new and veterans. A very inspiring film.