Critic Review - Combustible Celluloid

A vile, irresponsible film whose massive success says some very frightening things about America.

March 2, 2007 | Comments (73)
Combustible Celluloid

Comments

CoUcH ToMaToE DoUgIe

Shawn Amoroso

you frighten me, you jack ***!

Mar 31 - 09:25 PM

kitty45105

Abbie Borcyk

forest gump is one of the best movies made not to mention it won 6 oscars, you just dont have taste.

Jun 16 - 12:33 PM

djwes55

Dave James

As a viewer, if you have eyes and ears and even the slightest semblance of a brain, you will understand that Forrest Gump isn%u2019t to be taken seriously at all. The film is having fun with history %u2013 it%u2019s not trying to make any political or historical points. Whether you find the film%u2019s running historical gags funny %u2013 and personally some aren%u2019t nearly as funny as they think they are %u2013 could be a valid criticism, but calling it vile and irresponsible is hilarious.

There is plenty in Forrest Gump to criticize: over-sentimentality, the rigidity of its plot and dialogue that is sometimes underwhelming. But vile? %u201CA Clockwork Orange%u201D would be a film that could be called vile and irresponsible %u2013 if you happened to disagree with Kubrick%u2019s dystopian vision. Personally, I think %u201COrange%u201D is great as well but for someone who didn%u2019t like the film, I%u2019ll at least listen to someone who calls it vile.

But %u201CForrest Gump%u201D is a harmless film. It%u2019s not a detriment to society; there%u2019s no hatred or anything else that could be construed as harmful. This film is light, innocuous and ultimately isn%u2019t meant to be taken seriously anyway %u2013 calling it irresponsible is nothing short of, well, irresponsible. By the way, thanks for giving me something to do for the last ten minutes of work.

Jul 3 - 09:23 AM

Brian P.

Brian Peek

who the hell talks in percent signs?

Mar 3 - 12:44 PM

djwes55

Dave James

Sorry, apparently you are not allowed to have apostrophes.

Jul 3 - 09:27 AM

djwes55

Dave James

As a viewer, if you have eyes and ears and even the slightest semblance of a brain, you will understand that Forrest Gump isnt to be taken seriously at all. The film is having fun with history, its not trying to make any political or historical points. Whether you find the films running historical gags funny, and personally some aren%u2019t nearly as funny as they think they are, could be a valid criticism, but calling it vile and irresponsible is hilarious.

There is plenty in Forrest Gump to criticize: over-sentimentality, the rigidity of its plot and dialogue that is sometimes underwhelming. But vile? A Clockwork Orange would be a film that could be called vile and irresponsible, if you happened to disagree with Kubricks dystopian vision. Personally, I think Orange is great as well but for someone who didnt like the film, Ill at least listen to someone who calls it vile.

But Forrest Gump is a harmless film. Its not a detriment to society; theres no hatred or anything else that could be construed as harmful. This film is light, innocuous and ultimately isnt meant to be taken seriously anyway. Calling it irresponsible is nothing short of, well, irresponsible. By the way, thanks for giving me something to do for the last ten minutes of work.

Jul 3 - 09:30 AM

x9lonewolf

Tyler Dotson

That you actually get paid for your opinion and call Forrest Gump a bad film is outrageous. What is America coming too?

Jul 21 - 06:57 PM

Colonelcool

Luke Buckheit

You dont make decent money for these ****ty reviews, right? You're one of those losers who thinks his dumbass opinion matters, right?

Aug 16 - 10:15 PM

checkstumper

Molly Wolf

Please, everybody, do not take this fool seriously. Anything that smacks of a point of view different than his angry take on America is something to be scorned. He is a little sick, and his use of hyperbole of this nature illustrates this so completely. I've seen his type around quite a bit these days, and frankly, they are ripping at the fabric of this country, a fabric of decency, restraint, and basic human kindness, expressed with polite discourse. Bitter and mean, they will slink off to their lives of quiet desperation as they watch the world pass them by.

Oct 17 - 01:48 PM

alexis20

alexis dubé

Oh sure Forrest Gump is a such a vile movie..

Dec 3 - 01:53 PM

nick d.

nick dick

i agree. Forrest Gump was VILE. i three up three times watching it, i was so disgusted.

and what is the world coming to when hollywood thinks it has the right to create such an IRRESPONSIBLE portrayal of american history?? Forrest Gump was NOT the mind behind the "s*** happens" bumper sticker. and in real life, NOBODY moons the president and gets away with it!

VILE and IRRESPONSIBLE.

America, you SUCK!

Dec 14 - 10:13 PM

First L.

First Last

this is to nick d. and jeffrey.

this is a comedey.
and to the quote "VILE and IRRESPONSIBLE AMERICA YOU SUCK"........... GET THE F@#% OUT OF MY COUNTRY THEN!
I'd suggest France.

May 29 - 01:04 AM

MOVIEGOD

Dylan Sigaty-Hawkes

Lol go to bed kidlet.

Mar 20 - 11:18 PM

Nicholas Whewont

Nicholas Whewont

Do you know what sarcasm is?

Oct 26 - 10:40 AM

dbruman

Cosmo Nims

So many idiots went ahead and decided to post on this one critic's review...

"That you actually get paid for your opinion and call Forrest Gump a bad film is outrageous. What is America coming too?"

I lol'd. Oh noes! Someone else is gonna have a different opinion!

Jan 9 - 02:41 AM

Matt H.

Matt Holder

A vile, irresponsible film critic whose success and dislike of the great movies says some very frighening and disappointing things, and makes me lose the faith in America that things like this movie instilled in me.

Feb 1 - 07:37 AM

Greg Dennis

Greg Dennis

don't let such small foolish words make you lose heart for America. It's just a movie commented by a critic with obviously no eye's or taste.

Feb 1 - 08:57 PM

Michael W.

Michael Wilson

"Vile and Irresponsible?" I believe you're one sick puppy.

May 14 - 10:47 PM

Chelsea M.

Chelsea Michaels

are you out of your damn mind? forrest gump is one of the most beloved, heartwarming, magical films ever made. it won 6 oscars and is undoubtedly one of the best films out there. it touches every emotion, and takes you on a journey not many films do these days. you must be crazy, sir.

Jun 7 - 08:39 PM

Michaela V.

Michaela V

"Vile?" "Irresponsible?" Those words are totally out of context, and you're totally out of your mind.

Jul 19 - 10:27 PM

noisemaker

atli sig

you suck! forrest gump is awesome!

Jul 26 - 02:28 PM

Jack IM

Jack Iggo Milne

I completely disagree with "vile, irresponsible film", but we have to let this guy have his opinion. We'd all expect to be allowed to have ours.

This guy sounds like he has the wrong idea, but thats his problem.

Aug 1 - 11:24 PM

andyb79

Andy B

where can i read the full review?

Aug 18 - 05:59 PM

James Reynolds

James Reynolds

There isn't one. Thats all this ***** wrote.

Mar 17 - 07:47 AM

Andrew M.

Andrew Michel

You do realize how much of an idiot you sound like right? I mean, i cannot imagine anyone saying anything as pathetically stupid as that. You really do raise the bar for callous and capricious comments.

Sep 5 - 08:53 PM

dustin d.

dustin dziuk

obviously, everyone agrees to disagree with Mr. Anderson.

Sep 18 - 02:23 PM

Help | About | Jobs | Critics Submission | API | Licensing | Mobile