Four Daughters (1938) - Rotten Tomatoes

Four Daughters (1938)




Critic Consensus: No consensus yet.

Movie Info

Fannie Hurst's Sister Act was the source for this money-making Warners weeper. The four daughters of the title are played by the Lane Sisters--Priscilla, Rosemary and Lola--and by Gale Page. All are musical prodigies, and all are daughters of master-musician Claude Rains. To help make ends meet, Rains rents several rooms of his home to boarders--most of whom, thanks to the dictates of the plot, seem to be marriageable men. We're supposed to care the most about the mutual attraction the daughters feel towards handsome Jeffrey Lynn, but the film really belongs to John Garfield, making his movie debut (no, he wasn't in 1933's Footlight Parade) as an embittered piano genius. Garfield has us in the palm of his scruffy hand the moment he begins philosophizing about "the fates:" "So they flipped a coin...heads he's poor, tails he's rich....they flipped a coin--with two heads." Aware that he can bring only unhappiness to Priscilla Lane, the daughter who cares most for him, Garfield obligingly drives into a heavy snowstorm and is killed in an auto accident (but it's not staged as a suicide, lest the Hays Office spank). John Garfield made so powerful an impression in Four Daughters that Warners was compelled to write him into the sequel Four Wives, first as a flashback and then as (implicitly) a ghost. Another film, Daughters Courageous, was hastily constructed using the same cast, but with different character names so as to accommodate a happier denouement for Garfield and Lane. Four Daughters was remade in 1954 as Young at Heart, with Frank Sinatra and Doris Day in the John Garfield and Priscilla Lane roles.more
Rating: Unrated
Genre: Drama, Romance, Musical & Performing Arts, Classics
Directed By:
Written By: Fannie Hurst, Lawrence Kimble, Thyra Samter Winslow, Lenore Coffee, Julius J. Epstein
In Theaters:
On DVD: Mar 25, 1992
Warner Brothers


Claude Rains
as Adam Lemp
John Garfield
as Mickey Borden
Rosemary Lane
as Kay Lemp
May Robson
as Aunt Etta
Lola Lane
as Thea Lemp
Gale Page
as Emma Lemp
Dick Foran
as Ernest
Jeffrey Lynn
as Felix Deitz
Frank McHugh
as Ben Crowley
Vera Lewis
as Mrs. Ridgefield
Show More Cast

News & Interviews for Four Daughters

Critic Reviews for Four Daughters

All Critics (10) | Top Critics (2)

Full Review… | January 10, 2004
Chicago Reader
Top Critic

Full Review… | May 21, 2003
New York Times
Top Critic

A typical, sentimental small-town family melodrama of the 1930s, with one exception: John Garfield in a stunning screen debut as a brooding outsider.

Full Review… | March 9, 2011

Exemplary Warners hokum about sisters' romances

May 12, 2005
Film Journal International

Rains carries this Warner tugger

October 23, 2004
Kansas City Kansan

Superior, slickly made soaper with great stars.

May 23, 2004
Mountain Xpress (Asheville, NC)

Audience Reviews for Four Daughters

For the most part, this movie has a good story, but it has some predictable elements and boring scenes. Overall, an okay movie.

Aj V

Super Reviewer

Quaint is as good a word as any to describe this film, that's not always a bad thing though especially with a cast as good as this. Claude Rains and May Robson keep the schmaltz to a minimum, Priscilla is very pretty and best of all is John Garfield, wonderfully contemporary even in this slice of Americana.

jay nixon

Super Reviewer

Good for its time period, Four Daughters is entertaining despite being overly sentimental.

John Ballantine
John Ballantine

Super Reviewer

Four Daughters Quotes

There are no approved quotes yet for this movie.

Discussion Forum

Discuss Four Daughters on our Movie forum!