Has too many plot threads to follow in its willy-nilly efforts to set the stage for the real ending.
Well, it seems like someone has no sense of multitasking
Nov 24 - 09:46 PM
im starting to wonder if you even read the book
Nov 24 - 11:10 PM
He's a FILM critic!! He's reviewing movies, not books. I'm so tired of having HP fans respond to any form of criticisim with "Have you read the book?" We're not talking about the books (Which are great, btw) We're talking about the MOVIE!!!!!!!!!arrrrghhhhh...
Nov 25 - 06:57 AM
Nov 25 - 08:15 AM
yeah but is they never read the book harry potter would never become popular so mreading the book to watch a film is quite crucial. They can be film critics if they want to talk about montage and the whole look of the film not the plot characters etc.
Nov 25 - 11:45 AM
He's not here to review the book, he's here to review the movie!
Nov 27 - 01:15 AM
So its too hard to understand? Are you stupid? I'm shocked at that statement. It seems these 'critics' are purposely giving the movie a bad score just cause its Potter. Which honestly makes no sense.
Nov 25 - 09:34 AM
I thought the review was a fair one, even if I don't necessarily agree with his opinion. No need to call the reviewer stupid for his assessment.
Nov 26 - 08:48 AM
i totally agree with you.
Nov 25 - 09:45 AM
I think its funny how you don't even say WHY you hated the movie. I do agree with the people who say the scenes were two short. I though the movie was dazzling, but you could have your opinion even though some people don't agree with it.
Dec 8 - 06:15 PM
Unlike other negative reviews, at least you admitted that it might just be you - which raised your credibility, and I finished reading your review.You mention several confusions you had that are explicitly answered in the movie (i.e., the one who died in the beginning). Based on your immediate disinterest, I think you precluded yourself from following the movie accurately, plot-holes withstanding. Most movies can be nit-picked excessively, but it's not about that. I will concede that the last 3 movies have become increasingly esoteric (as did the books), but I think such depth and submersion in the Potter world is what makes the entire franchise succeed. Ultimately, you made some valid points that were exagerrated by the bitter taste still in your mouth, and I'd expect a better review if you were to sit through this (and the last several movies) with a more open mind to the greater appeal - although I can't force you to go along with the story.
Nov 26 - 06:55 AM
Ximena de la Puente
plot holes? well, maybe it's because this is the PART 1!! Now, my mom hasn't read the bood and she understood the movie. C'mon, there are already 6 films, at least watche them carefully if you are gonna watch the 7th... and I feel bad for your poor IQ "too many plot threads"... jesus... (sorry for my english...i speak spanish)
Nov 26 - 07:40 AM
plot holes? well, maybe it's because this is the PART 1!! Now, my mom hasn't read the book and she understood the movie. C'mon, there are already 6 films, at least watche them carefully if you are gonna watch the 7th... and I feel bad for your poor IQ "too many plot threads"... jesus... (sorry for my english...i speak spanish)
Nov 26 - 07:41 AM
Dear customers, thank you for your support of our company.Here, there's good news to tell you: The company recentlylaunched a number of new fashion items! ! Fashionableand welcome everyone to come buy. If necessary, pleaseplut:==== http://www.clothes2.us ========== http://www.clothes2.us ========== http://www.clothes2.us ========== http://www.clothes2.us ========== http://www.clothes2.us ========== http://www.clothes2.us ========== http://www.clothes2.us ======1) More pictures available on our website (===== http://www.clothes2.us ====)2) Many colors available .3) Perfect quality, 4) 100% safe door to door delivery, Best reputation , Best servicesWe need your support and trust!
Nov 26 - 05:36 PM
Having seen all the Potters thus far, I can agree that all good things must come to an end. In this case, all mediocre things. Aside from The Prisoner of Alzcaban (Sp? Probably but I'm not all that interested in looking it up), these films were bloated and increasingly boring. Yes I do realize the target audience are fans of the book series, yet I don't believe it makes the films any better by adding non-essential materials to inflate a movies run time.As the reviewer mentioned, not a huge fan of characters remarkably showing up just to suit the story without good reason. Don't get me wrong, there's alot of worse stuff to see out there - particularly in this years worth of stinkers, but as a whole the Potter movies are undeserving of their relatively high RT ratings.
Nov 26 - 07:40 PM
I don't think any one should read a book before going to see a movie. A Movie should stand alone as one complete whole from beginning to end. Even if it is open ended you should come out of it with a complete understanding of the story, if you don't then the director was simply unsuccessful to deliver it correctly.
Nov 29 - 05:26 AM
I totally agree with you. A movie should stand by itself without the need for reading the book it was based on. A person should be able to walk in off the street, and never having read the book, should be able to understand the movie.
Dec 5 - 09:39 AM
You make some points, but complaining about how the plot is confusing is pointless. My 10 year old sister understood it, not having read any book. Yet you still have some points, most of which I disagree with though.
Nov 30 - 01:48 PM
So it looks like Potter fans are resorting to ad-hominem attacks to try and prove their point. How pitiful.
Dec 1 - 10:41 PM
do you want to have some different things? Whether you want to give your relatives and friends, take a few different exotic gifts? Whether you want to buy some cheap benefits of thing? So please, let us begin now!===== http://www.clothes2.us ========= http://www.clothes2.us ========= http://www.clothes2.us ========= http://www.clothes2.us ====Click on our website===== http://www.clothes2.us ========= http://www.clothes2.us ========= http://www.clothes2.us ========= http://www.clothes2.us ====Believe you will love it.You can try Oh, give you satisfaction guarantee.===== http://www.clothes2.us ========= http://www.clothes2.us ========= http://www.clothes2.us ========= http://www.clothes2.us ====
Dec 5 - 04:49 PM
is this a sample of the IQ of Potter fans? "Have you read the book?" When the critic clearly says he has not. Have you read his review? Obviously not. Plus the one that has to post his comments 3-4 times. Get over it, as a movie this was sub par. Not on the level of the other films (on average). Nothing of consequence happened and without reading the book it lacked explainations. And what about that last scene??? I could have used a crow bar and taken that wand.
Dec 7 - 06:43 PM
Hello, everybody, the good shoping place, the new season approaching, click in. Letā??s Facelift bar!====accept credit card and so mang payment= = = = = www.flyingstyle.org ===Air Jordan (1-24) shoes $35UGG BOOT $50Nike shox (R4, NZ, OZ, TL1, TL2, TL3) $35Han bags ( Coach Lv fendi D&G) $35T-shirts (polo, ed hardy, lacoste) $16Jean (True Religion, ed hardy, coogi)$34Sunglasses ( Oakey, coach, Gucci, Armaini)$15New era cap $16Bikini (Ed hardy, polo) $18FREE SHIPPING= = =www.flyingstyle.org =
Dec 9 - 11:50 PM
you have too many plot threads, and are willy-nilly
Dec 15 - 09:31 AM