Erick Hecksher

Man your review sucks, this movie was awesome and it was funny, I don't know what you expect nowadays, but this is a very unfair review for an amazing work.

Sep 29 - 01:09 PM

Jerry Hatfield

Just seen it as well. Amazing! Did this reviewer watch the same movie? His dog must of died before going to the theater.

Sep 29 - 02:16 PM

Daniel Davis

This review is uglier than the movie.

Sep 29 - 06:16 PM

Stephen Wood

I hope the rest of the reporting in the Star-Ledger is more accurate than this review.

Sep 29 - 07:58 PM

Luce Kernizan

what a stupid review.. maybe you were watching something else because this movie was great and sooo funny.

Sep 29 - 08:06 PM

Deborah Psalm De Perio

I agree to all past replies of your review

Sep 30 - 06:30 AM

Emma Milligen

yeah, the reviewer should get his head out of his ass.

Sep 30 - 09:49 AM

Nanette Chertudi

I've seen a lot of animated movies with my children over the years and I have to stay this is in the top five. I think writers these days have their work cut out for them by entertaining both children and the parents that take them - my children loved it and so did I. Do you have any children Mr. Reviewer? Just because it didn't entertain you, did it entertain your children? Did you critic it with the same level that you do pur films for grown ups? I'd like to know why you dismissed it and what animated films you like and why? I go to movies to be entertained and it achieved all marks in good story line, funny jokes, great animation, great music, etc.

Sep 30 - 10:45 AM

Chris Burge

the movie was great fun

Sep 30 - 04:10 PM

Michael Conley

Stop talking shit about mah nigga Genndy Tartakovsky

Sep 30 - 11:16 PM

Dave Roberts

Well, you know what they say about people who can't make movies, they review them.

Oct 1 - 09:38 AM

Ronaldo Souza

What are you talking about? It's called stylization!

Oct 2 - 12:49 PM

Keith Manka

Read your article and think you got your critic license out of a Cracker Jack box. My two children who are young critic of 11 and 13 think that you are wrong wrong wrong. They enjoyed it so much that one of them has managed to see it twice already.

You look at this movie and try to pan it out as a Nemo want a be. In my opinion this is a story told again and again by many other movies and Nemo wasnâ??t the first to show it. Overall it isnâ??t the most terrible movie that has ever come out like you want people to believe. I like the way that it has been told. Ask my kids if they were thinking of a fish when they saw this and they would think your crazy.

As for the animation, where are you living, under a rock? The animation is great. Beats some of the trash the TV stations are putting out there theses days. Over the past 40 years of my life I have seen cartoons and have acquitted myself with them out of my childhood and now even more because of kids. This animation is not Pixar but it ranks up there in the top four animations studios.

I have seen most of the critic reviews at rotten tomato and canâ??t agree with them. The only reason I see that it did so terrible with the critics is that Adam Sandler was in it. This can even be seen in your review with the distaste you have of him and how he sucks the humor out of Robert Smigel. Donâ??t get me wrong I hated â??Little Nickyâ?? and barely tolerated â??Donâ??t mess with the Zohanâ?? without walking out. I am not an Adam Sandler fan, but I am man enough to give credit to movies that are done well even if it has someone Iâ??m not a fan of.

Bottom line is why movies canâ??t be for kids and kids only without people trying to take the fun out of it. When this movie comes out on Blueray, it will be added to the collection.

Oct 3 - 10:36 AM

Chilis Chilimunda

"Whoa, dude!" your review is blander than ice scraped from the wall for a refrigerator! You can just say if you really haven't seen the movie. I'd take a bullet for you just so you see it. Right through my brain (pointing at my elbow). Or I'd jump in from t of a train just so you can see another day, and, maybe fix your statement. Yeah, a bullet train.
So I saw the movie and it was priceless!! In your face...

Oct 5 - 04:08 AM

Robert Ward

You are really blind! This was a great movie and my children really liked it, alot! I almost refused to take them based on your insight...you were so wrong!

Oct 5 - 08:57 AM

Andre Garon

you are a FUCKTARD

Oct 6 - 08:59 PM

Cory Jeremiah

Is that it? Couldn't you have said anything better.How was the plot, was it creative, does it fulfill? I came for a review, not a one-sided attempt at a review

Oct 6 - 09:45 PM

Carlos Hernández

The single most retarded, stupid and dumb, argument lacking critic ever.

Oct 7 - 12:33 AM

Becca Elliott

Looks like Whitty isn't very witty.

Oct 7 - 07:11 PM