Quentin Tarantino made his directorial debut in 1992 with Reservoir Dogs, but it was 1994's Pulp Fiction, with its snappy dialogue and brutally dark humor, that made him a household name. Ever since then, Tarantino has inspired a cult following, and by all counts, he has consistently delivered; of the six feature-length films to his credit, only 2007's Death Proof (61%) has failed to earn Certified Fresh status. This week, Tarantino fans have a new treat to look foward to: Inglourious Basterds, the director's much anticipated seventh film, about a team of Jewish-American WWII soldiers on a Nazi-hunting mission.
The film received some early reviews from Cannes when it screened there in May of this year, and after some minor changes, it was screened again more recently. Quite a few critics have chimed in on it already, and so far, the buzz has been that it's a winner. If things continue to stay positive, we could be looking at a return to Certified Fresh status for Tarantino's filmography. Here's a look at how his past films have done on the Tomatometer:
Reservoir Dogs (1992), 95%
Pulp Fiction (1994), 96%
Jackie Brown (1997), 85%
Kill Bill, Vol. 1 (2003), 85%
Kill Bill, Vol. 2 (2004), 85%
Death Proof (2007), 61%
What are the critics saying right now about Inglourious Basterds? Check back often for updates on its Tomatometer score, and read on for a glimpse at the reviews collected thus far:
Some noted the abundance of dialogue in place of wall-to-wall action:
"It's certainly very talky, and there's no doubt that Tarantino is in love with the sound of his characters' voices, but QT dialogue is so much better than most other screenwriters that it's hard to quibble." -- Chris Hewitt, Empire Magazine
"Not enough scalps. While it's good and there are fun elements it's rather dialogue led than jam-packed with action." -- Baz Bamigboye, Daily Mail
Some enjoyed its revisionist history:
"In an age when everyone rushes to remake old movies and old TV shows and comic books and toys and whatever, Quentin [Tarantino] decided to remake World War II. And this time? It ends right." -- Drew McWeeny, HitFix
"Call it Pulp War Fiction--likely to divide critics, Tarantino's WWII fable interweaves little fact with much fiction, serving as a vessel for his playful, self-reflexive, postmodern commentary on a genre he knows and admires." -- Emanuel Levy, EmanuelLevy.com
"Tarantino seems to be scrutinizing his obsession with the cinema by cleverly placing it into an apt historical context." -- Ed Gonzalez, Slant Magazine
Some mentioned the graphic violence and dark themes:
"A bold, gory and glorious cinematic fest liberally doused with humour, satire and entertainment value." -- Louise Keller, Urban Cinefile
"Rarely have I ever been as satisfied with a film as I was with this one...[but] you should know what you're going to see... Heads are bashed in with baseball bats and people are brutally murdered. If that's not your thing..." -- Jenna Busch, Huffington Post
"Basterds isn't a deep film -- honestly, what Tarantino flick is? -- but it has moments as sharp as a bayonet and as perverse as war itself." -- Amy Nicholson, I.E. Weekly
Some loved it...
"Hysterically fun and gloriously excessive, Quentin Tarantino's latest is right up there with Pulp Fiction and Kill Bill." - Kevin N. Laforest, Montreal Film Journal
"By turns surprising, nutty, windy, audacious and a bit caught up in its own cleverness, the picture is a completely distinctive piece of American pop art with a strong Euro flavor that's new for the director." -- Todd McCarthy, Variety
"A glourious rude mix 'n match of subtitles, Nazi scalps, guerrilla cinema and testicle blood-soaked subterranean French cellar saloon shootouts, the film is a vintage QT Western European western. In other words, Tarantino's WWII heartfelt warsploit rocks." -- Prairie Miller, NewsBlaze
And some didn't...
"Inglourious Basterds is not boring, but it's ridiculous and appallingly insensitive-a Louisville Slugger applied to the head of anyone who has ever taken the Nazis, the war, or the Resistance seriously." -- David Denby, The New Yorker
"There are some nice-ish performances but everything is just so boring. He should perhaps go back to making cheerfully inventive outrageous films like Kill Bill. Because Kill Adolf hasn't worked out." -- Peter Bradshaw, The Guardian [UK]
Read more early reviews of Inglourious Basterds, which opens in wide release this week on Friday, August 21st. Also, be sure to check out our interview with director Quentin Tarantino, in which he talks about the film, war movie cliches, and what it was like to work with Brad Pitt.
|
sunsaz writes: on Aug 17 2009 05:21 PM It won't come close to touching RD or PF. I'll be happy if it manages to land in the low-80s on the TM. Just as long as it fares better than Death Proof. Regardless of the rating, it should still be a fun movie. (Reply to this) |
|
fargo_viper writes: on Aug 17 2009 05:21 PM Dumbledore sucks wand. (Reply to this) |
|
Scarborough Fair writes: on Aug 17 2009 05:39 PM For the record, Death Proof is great. There, I said it. (Reply to this) |
|
Logan A. writes: on Aug 17 2009 06:58 PM I'm gonna guess around 75-85. I'm pulling for ya, ya Basterds! (Reply to this) |
|
Boxman writes: on Aug 17 2009 07:11 PM Well I have no interest in seeing this movie in theaters. I'll wait til it comes on cable but, im sure it will get good reviews 70-80 percent i'm guessing. I'm not really into Tarantinos movies not saying he's a bad director just not into them much. (Reply to this) |
|
Gerant K. writes: on Aug 17 2009 07:59 PM Inglourious Basterds is hilarious. Lot's of little nods to himself throughout the film which I thought was fun. Death Proof totally deserves to be fresh, I believe that film holds some of his best dialogue to date... thanks for the feet Quintin! (Reply to this) |
|
Account writes: on Aug 17 2009 08:10 PM Might see this. Not into history movies at all though. If i do see it, its because of the director. (Reply to this) |
|
ferran275 writes: on Aug 17 2009 08:37 PM From someone who has seen it, I'd say, don't go in there expecting action all the way around, but go in expecting great build-ups that really pay off for the wait, and I think that's why people love Tarantino so much, the reason movie's like this one have staying power is because things happen so fast that you might have, and probably did, miss something and you WANT to go back in and see it again, I've always loved that about QT. (Reply to this) |
|
thereign writes: on Aug 17 2009 08:47 PM Saw it late last month, I thoroughly enjoyed it. GreenFox, it's not a "history movie" by any stretch...just go in, sit back, enjoy.(I can't believe one of those idiot critics almost gave away the ending, though...sheesh!) (Reply to this) |
|
King Kubrick writes: on Aug 17 2009 09:32 PM My most anticipated film of the year thus far, followed by the Road. I believe critics who had long waited for a chink to appear in Tarantino's armor unfairly maligned death proof (which was spectacular)just because it paled next to his previous achievements. The film was by no means a failure. (Reply to this) |
|
BCENS writes: on Aug 17 2009 09:43 PM Speaking of Grindhouse, I heard that filming has started on Machete! That was the second best fake trailer in Grindhouse (next to Thanksgiving). Props go to Werewolf Women of the SS, too. (Reply to this) |
|
eastern2western writes: on Aug 17 2009 10:39 PM be honest I think this movie will not save the weinsteins at all because tarantino has never trully really been a commercial director, his movies have certain level of anti main stream and never trully are megablock busters, they make money but they are not super successful (Reply to this) |
|
GFP Sr writes: on Aug 18 2009 01:08 AM I would argue that Kill Bill and Pulp Fiction were incredibly lucrative after DVD sales, TV showings, etc. (Reply to this) |
|
martinscorsese25 writes: on Aug 18 2009 02:21 AM RESERVOIR DOGS is overrated by the public. just because the characters look badass, they think RESERVOIR DOGS is QT's second best film... WRONG!!!!... Gene Siskel and Roger Ebert was right on the money with RESERVOIR DOGS. i remember seeing it for the first time, i already saw Pulp Fiction, but i always here people rave about DOGS and PULP so i thought they are equally great, but as it turns out, they are not. i love the start of the movie, but after the opening track, the movie slowly goes downward. not that DOGS isnt a good film, actually, it is quite good, just overrated by the public. people bash the Kill Bill movies so much, when in fact, it is QTs second best film. he is so in command there, so confident with his filmaking that when the two movies are combined, it is easily his second best. RESERVOIR DOGS has its moments(really great moments), but the movie lacked consistency and that's why it's no KILL BILL.. ps. all the negative reviews for Basterds came at Cannes, so far, after QT reedited the movie, there hasnt been a negative review yet. i think Basterds might reach to 95% status (Reply to this) |
|
martinscorsese25 writes: on Aug 18 2009 02:24 AM ooopsss, my mistake, the New Yorker is taking the "armond white" root for Basterds. i hope he's happy. (Reply to this) |
|
fullmetalnek writes: on Aug 18 2009 06:22 AM How much is needed to be certified fresh? well, I think Death Proof is a really good movie, even if it pales next to his other work. The only scene I kind of really dislike is when they're talking about the "Dick Department" after they've picked up Zoe. Is not because of what they're saying, buy it just sounds awkward coming out of their mouths. Only Dawson makes her way comfortably in that scene. Other than that, it's a blast. (Reply to this) |
|
Not L. writes: on Aug 18 2009 10:05 AM Overrated is such a stupid term that I wish people would stop using In YOUR OPINION it wasn't as good, but fact of the matter remains that the majority liked it more that Pulp (Reply to this) |
|
BowieSwimmer writes: on Aug 18 2009 11:23 AM In reply to this comment (#2538263) Have you seen the "Machete!" cast? INSANE - Cr Also, "Death Proof" is sorely underrated. As was "Grindhouse" as a giant cinematic experience (I saw it three times in theaters). Certainly the weakest film of his as a whole (it was overly self-indulgent at points), but a "weak" QT film is still something absolutely wonderful. I think its even better than "Planet Terror"; there's just some beyond killer dialogue. (Reply to this) |
|
mr gritty writes: on Aug 18 2009 12:29 PM I haven't seen Death Proof in its standalone form as of yet, but I saw Grindhouse at the theatres and thought it was a blast. The whole 'grindhouse' experience, what with the fake trailers and everything, made for something that was more than the sum of its parts. I don't think either movie, Death Proof or Planet Terror, would work particularly well as standalone moviess, but I think they complemented each other well in the double-feature format. I personally thought it should have been kept that way. What this means is that Tarantino hasn't made a single movie I felt to be truly bad. I've thoroughly enjoyed them all. Even if Basterds were only to reach the (relative) lows of Grindhouse, it will still mean a fine time at the movies. I'm also glad to see that the tomatometer has risen considerably since the Cannes debut -- now I don't know if that's due to the post-Cannes edit being that much improved, or simply a difference in tastes as compared ot the Cannes crowd, but in any case it is a good sign nonetheless. The 21st will also be the day the 16-minute preview footage of Avatar will be shown, so it will be a good day for movies in any case. (Reply to this) |
|
opTIMus Nerd writes: on Aug 18 2009 01:23 PM I have always thought 'Jackie Brown' to be QT's weakest flick..I was surprised to see Kill Bill 1 & 2 rated at 85%?!?! "Death Proof" wasn't the awesomest but it certainly had style and was intriguing. I don't believe Res. Dogs to be over-rated in the slightest; that flick kicked open the door on the 1990's and having been in a stage adaption of it, I can say it is as GREAT as the proverbial "they" have always said it was. (Reply to this) |
| You must be registered to post comments. Login or Register. |




















