RottenTomatoes.com
Log In | Register | What is RT?
RT's Blu-ray HQ
  • Home
  • Movies
  • DVD
  • Celebrities
  • News
  • Critics
  • Trailers & Pictures
  • CommunityBeta
  • Features
  • | Columns
  • | Guides
RT Search Powered by Google
help icon Enhanced RT
searches on Google
Click here to turn on enhanced search results from RT on your Google searches.
 
News
Controversial Rape Scene in Kite Runner Could be Cut
Family of child actor requests edit -- or relocation -- to preserve dignity.
by Sara Schieron | September 26, 2007
Discuss Article
Twelve-year-old Ahmad Khan Mahmidzada portrays the young Hassan in the upcoming film adaptation of Khaled Hosseini's novel The Kite Runner. A story about the friendship of two Afghan boys, the film's pivotal conflict concerns a rape that the actor's family has now asked the studio to cut from the film.

The controversial child rape scene in The Kite Runner is perpetrated by a Pashtun bully upon Mahmidzada's character, a lower class Hazara boy. While this rape points to ethnic stereotypes some fear could revive hostilities in the Afghanistan, it also draws attention to the surprising number of child rape scenes that have been sprouting up in recent films. Controversy has followed recent films such as Hounddog and the upcoming Nothing Is Private, which both feature scenes of child sexual abuse.

It's unknown if the family of Mahmidzada was aware of this trend when he told the AP, "They didn't give me the script. They didn't give me the story of The Kite Runner. If I knew about the story, I wouldn't have participated as an actor in this film." Mahmidzada also had concerns Afghans would confuse the actors in The Kite Runner for real people, thus fearing his family would lose dignity as a result of his appearance in the rape scene.

This rape constitutes the primary conflict between the two friends in the film, Amir and Hassan. Amir witnesses the abuse and does nothing to intervene.

Mahmidzada said that during the shooting of the scene, director Marc Forster (Finding Neverland) told him, "The film will be a mess without this part." However Mahmidzada, his family and other Afghans on the set in China backed Mahmidzada in his protest. "We are Afghan and this is not acceptable to us," he explained.



Forster directing his young actors on the set of The Kite Runner


The family is concerned that the inclusion of the rape scene will result in torment for Mahmidzada by his schoolmates and other Afghans. Mahmidzada's father explained, "There are ethnic problems in Afghanistan -- between Hazara, Pashtun, Tajik and other ethnic groups...We don't want any problem between any ethnic group in Afghanistan. We want unity among all ethnic groups in Afghanistan."

After Afghanistan suffered the post-Soviet era Civil War, the predominantly Pashtun Taliban killed thousands of Hazara before dissolving in 2001. Afterwards, the Afghan public became concerned about the possibility of further conflict between the many divergent factions in the region. Perhaps this diversity of citizens is who Mahmidzada was referring to when he lamented to the AP, "It's not one or two people that I have to explain to, it's all of Afghanistan. How do I make them understand?"

The Hollywood Reporter notes Mahmidzada's compensation for his role in the film was $10,000. To put this into an economic context: Afghan teachers earn $70 per month.

Though this conflict is yet unresolved, Mahmidzada did suggest a resolution to the AP when he said of the film company, "They should take us out of Afghanistan."

The Kite Runner will be released stateside by Paramount Vantage in limited release December 14. **UPDATE Studio reps have confirmed that The Kite Runner will be distributed on its original release date of November 2.

Sources: Hollywood Reporter

Related Items
Celeb: Marc Forster
Bookmark and Share
Comments (1-20 of 38 posts) | Reply
EmmG389
EmmG389 writes:
on Sep 26 2007 07:03 PM

They shouldn't have even made this movie. That scene was the central scene in the book.

(Reply to this)
h-town24
h-town24 writes:
on Sep 26 2007 07:07 PM

They are not going to cut a scene in a film because an actors family wants it!

(Reply to this)
Bloody Mathias
Bloody Mathias writes:
on Sep 26 2007 07:56 PM

"Mahmidzada also had concerns Afghans would confuse the actors in The Kite Runner for real people, thus fearing his family would lose dignity as a result of his appearance in the rape scene."

Wow.

Anyway, i'm not watching a movie where a young boy gets analy raped by the village bully no matter how compelling the ensuing drama is.
I know i'd feel horrible for a few days afterwards. There's just 3 rules i have:

1) No child rape movies. I broke this rule for Mysterious Skin only for JGL though. Great movie but again, a few scenes haunted me for days. I know this is the exception though.

2) No Uwe Boll movies.

3) No Rob Schiender flicks.

Ugh.


(Reply to this)
Mr. Right
Mr. Right writes:
on Sep 26 2007 08:04 PM

The whole book builds on and revolves around this scene, and now they want to cut it? What crap.

(Reply to this)
Metafact
Metafact writes:
on Sep 26 2007 08:55 PM

Wait a minute, Bloody Mathias, are you telling me that you equate Rob Schnieder and Uwe Boll to child rape?

Wow.

Anyway, I never read the book, but if that rape was a key moment in it, then I'm not sure how the studios are going to cut it out of the film and still have it make sense. It would be like cutting Sonny Corleone's death from The Godfather.


(Reply to this)
sharpless
sharpless writes:
on Sep 26 2007 09:02 PM

I like the cut of your jib, Bloody Mathias.

(Reply to this)
harrismonkey
harrismonkey writes:
on Sep 26 2007 09:20 PM

I can't quite figure out if the studio and director really screwed these innocent people over that badly, or if these people are just trying to make a stink and trying to blackmail Paramount.

Usually talent sees a script before signing on unless it's some big secret (like starwars, etc.). Since the book is published, there's no secret there.

And I think it's almost unheard of for people to cast a child for a child rape scene and just offhandly mention it that day when the actors get to set. Oh by the way, I know we didn't mention it, but today your going to get annally raped, you don't mind do you?

So what I'm saying is I'm very surprised this wouldn't have been addessed early enough in the process for them to make an informed decision.

On the other hand, if all they want is to be relocated to the states- that probably costs a lot less than the marketing budget of the film.

This whole thing is weird.

BTW, yes that is one of the most central scenes of the entire book, and the childhood scenes are the best part of the book to begin with. Also- the trailer looks awful. I'll probably see it because it's a great book and a good director, but my expectations are pretty low.


(Reply to this)
pmazun
pmazun writes:
on Sep 26 2007 09:46 PM

they CANNOT cut that scene . if they cut the scene the movie will be crap. i can see if that part was long and stuff but i think they have enough sence about this type of thing. priests do the same damn thing and NOW there is a problem . ITS BULL****!!

(Reply to this)
antarianzan
antarianzan writes:
on Sep 26 2007 10:00 PM

They shouldn't even release the movie if they have to cut the scene. It would completely destroy the story and therefore the legacy the book has built for itself.

I loved the book and the director is promising, but I have to agree that the trailer was disappointing. The cinematography looked very bland.


(Reply to this)
MMacKK
MMacKK writes:
on Sep 26 2007 11:47 PM

They should have dressed Dakota Fanning up as young Arab child. I tell ya, prosthetics these days...

Anyway, yeah, she would have been keen to do it. Her and her parents.


(Reply to this)
thereign
thereign writes:
on Sep 27 2007 12:44 AM

It's absolute bull that the kid and his family are saying they were never shown a script. There's no way a studio would do that, especially with such a pivotal scene--they'd be opening themselves up to a lawsuit! Also, did the family never read the book? I'm sure there must have been at least ONE copy floating around the set, probably in the hands of the continuity director or the script coordinator! It's absolute nonsense. If the kid and his family were so worried about what other Afghans would think, you know what--don't be an actor! And if teachers really make only $70 a month in Afghanistan, if I were Mahmidzada, or Mxyzptlk, or whatever the heck his name is--I'd be more concerned about an angry mob of teachers burning down my house!

(Reply to this)
Runawayrunaway!
Runawayrunaway! writes:
on Sep 27 2007 06:01 AM

YAAAAAAAY CHILD RAPE YAAAAAAAAAAY

(Reply to this)
Gimy
Gimy writes:
on Sep 27 2007 06:07 AM

1, why the h3ll are some of you SO intent on this scene being in the film? fbi is coming to check your computer...better run!
2, is this the new fad? heeey lets put a rape scene in it. "been done, lets go one better...a teen rape! yaaaaaaaay for growing short n' curlies". im with some of the others in the fact that i would not watch a rape scene with a kid in it, what the h3ll is up with that? you can get a message across without actuallying showing whats happening. case in point, show a close up of the victims face and the agony...or shoot the feet and the struggle for the victim to keep his/her balance, that pain. i'm sorry but a BOOK illustrating it...and a movie SHOWING it...is two completely different things. there are certain things that shouldn't be shown on a movie and this, to me, is one of em. less is more, achieve the same effect by putting more into the EMOTIONAL aspect instead of the physical. if its THAT big of a deal of the actual ACT and effects won't work, use a body double and make it well known to the arabic public that its NOT him. h3ll, if natalie portman can do it in all her movies(cept the new one!) why can't some kid? the kid, the family...both save face, you get the shot, it won't be THAT detrimental to the movie. the only people it effects are chesters saying "wait, thats not fresh meat...thats a 25 year old midget! d3mmit".


(Reply to this)
skletonkee
skletonkee writes:
on Sep 27 2007 06:59 AM

In reply to this comment (#1151739)
Totally agree...This family is either having second thoughts or are trying to renegotiate something...in fact, in one of the interviews the young actor asked the film producers to move his family to America...

this is all strategy.


(Reply to this)
Baccus83
Baccus83 writes:
on Sep 27 2007 08:13 AM

You know, all they're talking about is cutting the actual scene. Like, not actually showing the rape. That doesn't mean they cut the element from the script. You can have an event happen in a movie - even an important one - without actually showing it. It's more difficult to do, but it's possible. You can show the events leading up to it, you can show the immediate aftermath. If the story hinges on this event, I'm sure they'll find a way to incorporate it.

(Reply to this)
Bane Of Anubis
Bane Of Anubis writes:
on Sep 27 2007 09:13 AM

In reply to this comment (#1152199)
I agree that they can intimate almost anything, but this is a scene that needs to be shown -- this sort of brutality is intended to haunt and without visuals, you will be far less affected. Agree with Mathias, though, probably wouldn't see it if it were on screen.

(Reply to this)
hugz4thugz
hugz4thugz writes:
on Sep 27 2007 10:09 AM

Hi, I'm Chris Hansen and I'm with Dateline NBC....

(Reply to this)
Pilgermann
Pilgermann writes:
on Sep 27 2007 10:16 AM

I seriosuly doubt that the rape scene would be graphic. It probably just shows enough for one to realize what's happening or what's about to happen.

(Reply to this)
Pilgermann
Pilgermann writes:
on Sep 27 2007 10:18 AM

In reply to this comment (#1152340)
And by seriosuly I meant seriously (damn Rotten Tomatoes for not allowing an 'edit' option).

(Reply to this)
synergyred
synergyred writes:
on Sep 27 2007 10:42 AM

Oh geeze. I don't know anything about Hounddog or any of these other movies with child rapes scenes, but I have read The Kite Runner. I agree with most everyone here that that scene, although horrifying to even read, is the most important scene in the book. I also can't help but wonder why the family did not protest when they first discovered that this scene was in the script. Why have they waited until now?

I wonder how this will effect the fate of this movie. Perhaps just the version that will air in Afghanistan will be edited. Either that or maybe they'll find a way to edit the scene to satisfy the family.

I still can't help wondering why this issue, if it was so damn important to the family, hadn't come up sooner?


(Reply to this)
Read More Comments
Page | 1 2
Post Your Comment
You must be registered to post comments. Login or Register.

Related Links

The Kite Runner
  • Pictures
  • Posters
  • News
  • Forum

Related Articles

  • UK Tomatometer Preview: Quantum Of Solace - Is the New Bond Shaken or Stirred? (38)
  • RT on DVD: Kite Runner, Stephen King's The Mist Enter Your Homes! (21)
  • Down but Not Out, HD DVD Soldiers On (49)
  • Critical Consensus: Bucket Gets Kicked, The Orphanage is Certified Fresh, In the Name of the King Not Screened (40)
  • No Country for Old Men, Juno, There Will Be Blood Lead Critics' Choice Winners (8)
  • David Benioff Promises Fun Wolverine (33)
  • Critical Consensus: I Am Legend All Over the Map, Chipmunks Hits Sour Note (23)
  • Box Office Guru Preview: I Am Legend Set For Explosive Opening (15)
  • David Benioff on The Kite Runner: The RT Interview (1)
  • Atonement Leads Golden Globe Nominations (61)

Most Discussed

  • Box Office Guru Wrapup: New Moon Shatters Records (181)
  • Total Recall: John Travolta's Best Movies (92)
  • Ban Them All! 10 Infamously Controversial Movies (80)
  • Friday Harvest: The Road, Avatar, and more! (80)
  • 5 Facts About The Twilight Saga: Eclipse (70)
  • Critics Consensus: Flee From Ninja Assassin (45)
  • WB offers DVD to Blu-ray Trade-In Program (33)
  • RT's Blu-ray Picks from WB (22)
  • Five Favorite Films With Zombieland Director Ruben Fleischer (22)
  • RT on DVD & Blu-Ray: Angels & Demons, Funny People, and Superman (19)

Latest News

  • Weekly Ketchup: Zombieland 2 in 3D? (18)
  • Duncan Jones Reteams With Kevin Spacey (2)
  • Friday Harvest: The Road, Avatar, and more! (80)
  • Ban Them All! 10 Infamously Controversial Movies (80)
  • 5 Facts About The Twilight Saga: Eclipse (70)
  • Five Favorite Films With Zombieland Director Ruben Fleischer (22)
  • WB offers DVD to Blu-ray Trade-In Program (33)
  • RT's Blu-ray Picks from WB (22)
  • Critics Consensus: Flee From Ninja Assassin (45)
  • RT's Disney Animation Celebration --- A Walk Through The Magic Kingdom! (0)

Latest Interviews

  • "I Don't Hate Women": Lars von Trier on Antichrist (16)
  • Eric Bana talks Love the Beast - RT Interview (11)
  • Fight Club Sound Designer Reflects on Film's 10th Anniversary (21)
  • James Schamus talks Taking Woodstock - RT Interview (8)
  • John Hurt Talks Harry Potter, Quentin Crisp and Alien - The RT Interview (15)
  • Terry Gilliam Talks Doctor Parnassus (21)
  • Wes Anderson Talks Fantastic Mr. Fox - RT Interview (8)
  • Wolverine Creator Len Wein Talks About the Film (28)
  • Gavin Hood Talks Wolverine; Possible Sequel (28)
  • Duncan Jones talks Moon, Sam Rockwell, and Mute (14)

Latest Features

  • Ban Them All! 10 Infamously Controversial Movies (80)
  • 5 Facts About The Twilight Saga: Eclipse (70)
  • Five Favorite Films With Zombieland Director Ruben Fleischer (22)
  • "I Don't Hate Women": Lars von Trier on Antichrist (16)
  • Fight Club Sound Designer Reflects on Film's 10th Anniversary (21)
  • Five Favourite Films with Ang Lee (34)
  • 10 Movies That Changed The (End Of The) World (36)
  • Ho-ho-horror! 10 Scary Christmas Movies (39)
  • 12 Facts About 2012 (135)
  • Terry Gilliam Talks Doctor Parnassus (21)

Sponsored Links

 
 
About| Site Map| Help| RT To Go| Contact Us| Critics Submission| Linking to RT| Licensing| Movie List| Games| Celebs List| Newsletter
IGN Logo

IGN.com | GameSpy | Comrade | Arena | FilePlanet | GameSpy Technology
TeamXbox | Planets | Vaults | VE3D | CheatsCodesGuides | GameStats | GamerMetrics
AskMen.com | Rotten Tomatoes | Direct2Drive | Green Pixels


By continuing past this page, and by the continued use of this site, you agree to be bound by and abide by the User Agreement.
Copyright 1998-2009, IGN Entertainment, Inc. About IGN | Support | Advertise | Privacy Policy | User Agreement | Subscribe to RT's XML feed! IGN RSS Feeds
IGN's enterprise databases running Oracle, SQL and MySQL are professionally monitored and managed by Pythian Remote DBA
Certain product data ©1995-present Muze, Inc. For personal use only. All rights reserved.