Lady in the Water (2006) - Rotten Tomatoes

Lady in the Water (2006)



Critic Consensus: A far-fetched story with little suspense and unconvincing scenarios, Lady In The Water feels contrived, pretentious, and rather silly.

Movie Info

A modest building manager named Cleveland Heep rescues a mysterious young woman from danger and discovers she is actually a narf, a character from a bedtime story who is trying to make the treacherous journey from our world back to hers. Cleveland and his fellow tenants start to realize that they are also characters in this bedtime story. As Cleveland falls deeper and deeper in love with the woman, he works together with the tenants to protect his new fragile friend from the deadly creatures that reside in this fable and are determined to prevent her from returning home.more
Rating: PG-13 (for some frightening sequences)
Genre: Drama, Mystery & Suspense, Science Fiction & Fantasy
Directed By:
Written By: M. Night Shyamalan
In Theaters:
On DVD: Dec 19, 2006
Box Office: $42.2M
Warner Bros. Pictures - Official Site


Paul Giamatti
as Cleveland Heep
Bob Balaban
as Harry Farber
Cindy Cheung
as Young-Soon Choi
Bill Irwin
as Mr. Leeds
Mary Beth Hurt
as Mrs. Bell
Noah Gray-Cabey
as Joey Dury
Jared Harris
as Goatee Smoker
Joseph D. Reitman
as Long Haired Smoker
Grant Monohon
as Emaciated Smoker
John Boyd
as One-Eyebrow Smoker
Ethan Cohn
as Glasses Smoker
June Kyoko Lu
as Mrs. Choi
Tovah Feldshuh
as Mrs. Bubchik
Tom Mardirosian
as Mr. Bubchik
June Kyoto Lu
as Mrs. Choi
Maricruz Hernandez
as Perez de la Torre Si...
Carla Jimenez
as Perez de la Torre Si...
Natasha Perez
as Perez de la Torre Si...
Monique Curnen
as Perez de la Torre Si...
Marilyn Torres
as Perez de la Torre Si...
George Bass
as Mr. Perez de la Torr...
Joel Garland
as Pool Guy
Nell Johnson
as Phone Message
Walter Lafty
as Silvertide Band Memb...
Mark Melchiorre Jr.
as Silvertide Band Memb...
Kevin Frank
as Silvertide Band Memb...
Brian Weaver
as Silvertide Band Memb...
Nick Perri
as Silvertide Band Memb...
Jeremy Howard
as Tartutic No. 1
Brian Steele
as Tartutic No. 2
Kurt Carley
as Tartutic No. 3
Doug Jones
as Tartutic No. 4
Show More Cast

News & Interviews for Lady in the Water

Critic Reviews for Lady in the Water

All Critics (221) | Top Critics (47)

[Perhaps it's] improvised and protracted, nonsensically and unnecessarily, just for the sake of stringing us along. And, maybe, putting us to sleep.

Full Review… | September 13, 2006
Top Critic

Once again Shyamalan is a maddening storyteller, by turns inspired and insipid, and he still manages to conjure some odd, unnerving moments.

Full Review… | November 7, 2012
Empire Magazine Australasia

Peevishly defensive, intransigently personal and serenely indifferent to critical (and audience) reaction

Full Review… | August 30, 2009

While the film's performances are intriguing and the direction tight, Shyamalan's fairytale ends up being more interesting than the actual film.

Full Review… | April 29, 2009
Cinema Crazed

... to put it bluntly, badly paced and completely trivial, not to mention utterly juvenile.

Full Review… | July 4, 2008

This could have made a decent movie but the mythology comes so thick and fast that it mixes to a slurry as you watch.

Full Review… | June 13, 2008
Eye for Film

Audience Reviews for Lady in the Water

Talk about a director losing his touch! "Lady in the Water" is a very simple story about a mythical woman who rises from the water. Discovered by an apartment owner and his peers, they begin to uncover the secrets of why she is there and how to send her home to release the terror surrounding the tenants at the apartment building. Sound dumb? That is because it undoubtedly is. Sure, I left out quite a few details there, but this film does not warrant a full commentary. Paul Giamatti gives his all in his performance, but I just did not buy any of the dialogue that anyone was saying, so that took me out of every scene. Bryce Dallas Howard is laughable as the title character and the mystical thematic elements surrounding her are incredibly comical (unintentionally so). There are some undeniably well-shot moments, but that is seen throughout all of Shyamalan's work. It all comes down to the story here, which is one of the most ludicrous (albeit original) ideas I have viewed in a very long time. "Lady in the Water" is a train wreck of a fantasy film. I hated every second of it.

KJ Proulx
KJ Proulx

Super Reviewer


Offensive for the critics, the director put himself in a role, where he is a future hero for the world that write beautiful things and Bob Balaban's role is a intelligent, but rude critic that have a violent end. Lady in the Water present a charming cast and a interesting script, but become sort of a magic cliche movie.

Lucas Martins
Lucas Martins

Super Reviewer

Okay, so this isn't quite the complete and utter failure that I had been led to believe that it was...but still, it is pretty bad. The film is basically a fairy tale bedtime story concerning Cleveland Heep- the superintendent of an apartment complex who discovers a sea nymph who entered into our world through the pool at the apartment cocmplex. She tries to get back to her world, but she's threatened by menacing creatures, and requires help from Cleveland and the various colorful tenants of the building.

Just looking at the broad concept (a supernatural thriller/fairy tale sort of bedtiem story thing) this isn't too bad. It's kinda unique, though the execution of it all is where there's trouble. The specific story itself is a little hokey, the script is atrocious, the cast, while notable, give some really dry, wooden, and downright awful performances, and to top it all off, the jokes suck, the film is unintentionally funny, there's tons of cliches, the bits where the 4th wall is broken really fall flat and induce facepalms, and it's all a bit of a bore and I didn't care too much. Also, Shyamalan really shows his narcissism here, but I won't spoil it by detailing specifics.

But, since I did give it a barely passing grade, that means it's not all bad. LIke I said, good cast, terrible work. The cinematography is quite wonderful (as should be expected), the direction is decent (I've always felt that Shyamalan was a far better director than a writer) but he's been far better, and I do think Howard is pretty, even if she often gets miscast or misdirected.

So yeah, bottom line, this film does mostly live up to its reputation. I liked some aspects of it, but it is essentially a really poor misguided piece of work.

Chris Weber

Super Reviewer

Lady in the Water Quotes

There are no approved quotes yet for this movie.

Discussion Forum

Discuss Lady in the Water on our Movie forum!