More comical than compelling, but what do you expect of a chopsocky revolving around a head case of a hero begging to be buried alive in order to channel his psychic powers?
Comment
07/21/08
Mad Detective (2008)
80 %
Reviews Counted: 15 Fresh: 12 Rotten:3 Average Rating: 6.4/10
Runtime: 89 mins
Theatrical Release: Jul 18, 2008 Limited
Genre: Action/Adventure
Starring: Ka Tung Lam, Lau Ching-Wan, Jay Lau, Kelly Lin, Andy On
Reviews
1 - 15 (sorted by date)
Mad Detective doesn't always make sense, and you cannot always tell what is real and what is imaginary, but viewers will be having too much zonked-out fun to care.
07/18/08
Top Critic
If the insanely inventive and entertaining Mad Detective weren’t so weird -- and in Cantonese -- hordes of action geeks would be lining the block to see it.
07/18/08
Top Critic
A freewheeling narrative that twists around its central themes with manic intensity.
07/18/08
Fleeting confusion and bizarre literalization aside, Mad Detective is an effective mystery story, with an oddball hero -- like TV's Monk, but far crazier -- and some moments of visceral violence that raise the stakes.
07/17/08
It may make no sense to throw logic out the window, but that’s exactly what makes Detective such an unhinged blast.
07/16/08
Every moment in Mad Detective seems engineered for maximum oddity; it almost becomes overwhelming...Yet the movie feels adventuresome, too, a new bridge to Asia’s soulful ghost canon. It’s a metaphysical mystery masquerading as a doodle.
07/16/08
Even if you lose track of who's shooting whom and why during the abstract climactic face-off, the clever last shot shows you're not alone.
07/16/08
Top Critic
Director Johnny To’s previous flicks are slicker affairs, but there’s still plenty here to please the fans.
07/15/08
To and Ka-fai's widescreen lensing is both elegant and sharp, its distorted angles and flaring white lights generating a sense of unease that complements Bun's instability and Chi-Wai's fractured self.
07/15/08
The prolific Johnny To and his occasional collaborator Wai Ka Fai here put a new twist on the standard police yarn.
09/29/07
Direction lacks the strong hand of To's solo efforts, and pic shows some signs of rush, with abrupt transitions and lack of flow in the editing.
09/10/07
Top Critic1 - 15 (sorted by date)
Related Forums
(2008 USA release)-Johnnie To's MAD DETECTIVE actuates the comic genius of Wai Ka Fai
by: REEL_REVIEWER 6/22
by: REEL_REVIEWER 6/22
(2008 USA release)-Johnnie To's MAD DETECTIVE actuates the comic genius of Wai Ka Fai
by: REEL_REVIEWER 6/22
by: REEL_REVIEWER 6/22
(2008 USA release)-Johnnie To's MAD DETECTIVE actuates the comic genius of Wai Ka Fai
by: REEL_REVIEWER 6/22
by: REEL_REVIEWER 6/22
(2008 USA release)-Johnnie To's MAD DETECTIVE actuates the comic genius of Wai Ka Fai
by: REEL_REVIEWER 6/22
by: REEL_REVIEWER 6/22
News
Critics Consensus: The Dark Knight Is One Of The Year's Best-Reviewed
posted by Tim Ryan July 17, 2008
This week, we've got the Caped Crusader (The Dark Knight, starring Christian Bale and Heath Ledger), ABBA aficionados...
posted by Tim Ryan July 17, 2008
This week, we've got the Caped Crusader (The Dark Knight, starring Christian Bale and Heath Ledger), ABBA aficionados...
Around the Network
• Mad Detective at Rotten Tomatoes
IGN RSS Feeds