Rob Young

One occasionally hears opinions about art of the type "the Mona Lisa is inferior to a decent photograph" or "Beethoven produced a lot of noise that my child can improve upon". Seldom are the opinions of a qualified critic of this caliber. However, the comments of mr. Smithey in this odd review are of similar quality.

Oct 15 - 08:57 PM

Susan Sams

Rob, I think you're the one who needs to re-think the quality of your opinion and not be so closed-minded.. Other people are allowed to have opinions. Oh, and notice I said "I think" not "you aren't qualified enough because you think differently." Personally, I think Miranda July tries too hard. The whole indie thing is hard to accomplish.. and I personally think she failed. This film is so contrived it's hard to stay interested. Love her books, but this was sad. And so are closed-minded people like Rob.

Nov 20 - 03:37 AM

Colm Doran

i agree with this comment

Nov 2 - 05:34 PM

Faith Workman

I agree fully with this review!

Rob Y., are you really trying to compare this movie to priceless works created by two of history's greatest artistic geniuses?

May 23 - 03:28 PM