No "Oldboy" Remake?
If you've been holding your breath for director Justin Lin's long-rumored American remake of his Korean action hit "Oldboy," it sounds as though you may as well exhale: Dark Horizons reports that Lin, at the Sundance Festival this week, told Bloody Disgusting that it doesn't look like it's going to happen.
Lin's specific reason for this was the old "a lot of other projects in the works" excuse, but he's long maintained that his satisfaction with the original "Oldboy" would preclude him from doing a remake unless it was absolutely perfect.

Choi Min-Sik in the Korean version of "Oldboy."
Lin's specific reason for this was the old "a lot of other projects in the works" excuse, but he's long maintained that his satisfaction with the original "Oldboy" would preclude him from doing a remake unless it was absolutely perfect.

Choi Min-Sik in the Korean version of "Oldboy."
Related Items
| Movie: | Oldboy |
| Celeb: | Justin Lin |
|
Steve Perry writes: on Jan 25 2007 12:31 PM [b]Hallelujah[/b] Thank God! This movie was great and a remake would kill what made this film so special just like many american adaptations of asian films. Old Boy was great! Thanks for not destroying it Lin. (Reply to this) |
|
nogard64 writes: on Jan 25 2007 12:43 PM I wish they would re release it again, I would love to see the now infamous hallway scene on the big screen (Reply to this) |
|
digitalsoul68 writes: on Jan 25 2007 12:48 PM [b]I second that AMEN[/b] An Oldboy remake would just be stuck in the mire of Hollywood remakes and just not be as effective IMO. Someone mentioned Gary Oldman playing Oh Dae-su's part would have been good and if they had David Fincher directing it MAY HAVE worked, but best leave a masterpiece alone. (Reply to this) |
|
A Lapse In Reason writes: on Jan 25 2007 02:01 PM [b]Wait what?[/b] Justin Lin didn't have anything to do with Oldboy. Chan-wook Park directed and wrote it. How does Justin Lin have anything to do with Oldboy? (Reply to this) |
|
Matthew Good... Band? writes: on Jan 25 2007 02:13 PM In reply to this comment (#853982) Justin Lin would be the guy re-making it. The mistake is that the article says he made it in the first place. (Reply to this) |
|
nogard64 writes: on Jan 25 2007 02:13 PM In reply to this comment (#853982) are you serious? (Reply to this) |
|
henwance writes: on Jan 25 2007 03:00 PM THANK YOU GOD! (Reply to this) |
|
Broken Sword writes: on Jan 25 2007 03:23 PM Get Scorsese to do the remake. That is if he isn't busy remaking gems-Infernal Affairs 2 and 3. (Reply to this) |
|
iheartbrucecampbell writes: on Jan 25 2007 06:38 PM there is a god, and he loves korean film. (Reply to this) |
|
Bob* writes: on Jan 25 2007 06:41 PM now those are AWESOME news!! (Reply to this) |
|
lavatory love machine writes: on Jan 25 2007 07:43 PM In reply to this comment (#853986) infernal affairs 2 is a indeed a gem, but IA3 is average (Reply to this) |
|
Squaregeiz writes: on Jan 25 2007 11:55 PM [b]Thank goodness.[/b] This film did not need to be remade. In fact, it barely even needed to be made. I cant stand how many people act as if this is the greatest film ever made, and just completely ignore the plot holes that are as bad as anything in Snakes on a Plane. It was an okay movie, and that's it. And that hallway scene is ridiculously stupid. That's probably one of the worst fight scenes (OMG obviously CG knife in a guy's back!) ever set to film that didn't involve Charlie's Angels in some way. (Reply to this) |
|
TheBomb69 writes: on Jan 26 2007 06:34 AM Squaregeiz is wrong. (Reply to this) |
|
Sadistik writes: on Jan 26 2007 08:25 AM This news makes me happy. Fuck Hollywood. (Reply to this) |
|
Q & T writes: on Jan 26 2007 11:11 AM THANK YOU ZOMBIE JESUS (Reply to this) |
|
Now it's dark writes: on Jan 27 2007 10:58 AM *Does the Happy Dance* (Reply to this) |
|
arcadefire325 writes: on Jan 28 2007 03:47 PM YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 1 remake down.........15 billion to go :) (Reply to this) |
|
Maven writes: on Jan 28 2007 11:03 PM [b]It's a scuzzbag convention![/b] The real reason this piece of trash won't be remade is obvious- the market for Incest Porn is fairly limited in this country, being mainly restricted to the majority of people who posted in this thread about how much they 'loved' the original. (Reply to this) |
|
digitalsoul68 writes: on Jan 29 2007 11:58 AM In reply to this comment (#853996) Awww, c'mon, Maven. Is that any way to dis your brother here, who LOVES you so much? Why won't you return my phone calls? Don't you remember summer camp? (Reply to this) |
|
fuzzibunny writes: on Nov 04 2007 03:40 PM Just what we need. Another remake of a brilliant film. Had Hollywood run out of imagination already? (Reply to this) |
| You must be registered to post comments. Login or Register. |











