News » 10 Horrifically Profitable Films

10 Horrifically Profitable Films

As Paranormal Activity scares up $100 million from a budget of loose change, we look at history's lowest budget horror hits



Oren Peli's debut feature Paranormal Activity -- an ingenious horror movie set in a house as a young couple attempt to capture a spectre on camera -- was made on video for a tiny budget of just $15,000. But with a smart marketing campaign and viral word-of-mouth from audiences that propelled it from limited release into wide theatrical distribution, the shoestring fright flick has now taken more than $107 million in the US alone. What's more, it marks an all-time record return on initial investment. As the film finally arrives (on a wave of hype) in the rest of the world, we decided to take a look at 10 other profitable horror films throughout history. After all, it's the genre to be in if you really want to make a low-budget killing.




Cat People (1942)

Not to be confused with Paul Schrader's '82 skin-flick remake with Natassja Kinski, this wartime classic from producer Val Lewton and Jacques Tourneur is a masterpiece of horror-noir mood and suspense scares. The story of a feline fatale cost just $141,659 -- a small budget even then -- but grossed $4m over the next two years and saved the studio, RKO Radio Pictures, from the financial ruin incurred by releasing box-office flops like Orson Welles' Citizen Kane and his follow-up, The Magnificent Ambersons.




The Blob (1958)

Independently produced by a savvy operator named Jack Harris, who coughed up the $300,000 budget himself, this perennial favourite B-flick has alien jelly invading a small town, with the most memorable scene having The Blob ooze its way into a movie theatre packed with teens. No doubt the kids of the day thought it was a blast, daddy-o. A young jobbing actor named Steve McQueen was tapped for the lead and offered a choice: he could take a $3,000 fee upfront or get 10 percent of the gross box-office. Figuring The Blob would be just another creature feature, he opted for the former. Bummer. The movie grossed an astounding $12m, which would've earned McQueen $1.2m and set him up for life.




Night of the Living Dead (1968)

Long before sophisticated marketing campaigns and the Internet, George A. Romero started the whole zombies-feast-on-the-flesh-of-the-living genre with this incredibly tense horror flick. Shot on B&W with an amateur cast in and around Pittsburgh for $114,000, it nevertheless found wide independent release thanks to word of mouth and took $12m at the box-office and another $18m internationally.




Eraserhead (1976)

David Lynch's debut feature remains a stark surrealist nightmare that defies explanation. What we can agree on, though, is that with its high contrast black-and-white industrial hellscapes, affectless hero, oozing chickens, splattering sperm-like creatures and radiator ingénues, it's quite terrifying. The movie beguiled audiences on release, too, clocking up $7m in ticket sales -- many from midnight screenings -- which was pretty good for a $100,000 budget eked out of Lynch's own pocket.




Halloween (1978)

John Carpenter's movie about a knife-wielding psycho stalking Haddonfield on October 31 was an immediate fright-flick sensation due to its emphasis on suspense over gore. It was produced for a mere $325,000 but took $47m -- and inspired literally hundreds of sillier and gorier imitators, including 1980's Friday The 13th, which, made for $700,000, earned an also-impressive $37m in ticket sales.

The Inner Circle

The Inner Circle on 12-2-2009 09:44 PM

Halloween still is one of my fav films

Escapefromalcatraz

Escapefromalcatraz on 12-2-2009 09:55 PM

Ha. The Blob is actually a pretty decent B movie and has some GREAT hot rods in it!

sayurkangkung

sayurkangkung on 12-2-2009 09:58 PM

Yes for the existence of Eraserhead

bondfreak

bondfreak on 12-2-2009 10:37 PM

that colin movie sounds like hes going to make a lot of dough :) not a fan of horror myself but cool list

Grizzle

Grizzle on 12-2-2009 10:51 PM

Can go past some B-grades. Damn, they are awesome just for being lame.

NTROST

NTROST on 12-2-2009 11:32 PM

@GrizzleGreedigut

You do know that "B Movies" doesn't mean they are graded with a "B" grade. The "B" movie terminology was known for being filler films which were films that were made with low-budgets & at one time were films that would start before the "A" movies began which were the films that were made by the big studios. "B" movies also used to be played in seperate theatres from the big studio chains back in the day. The "B" Movie terminology is just a term for low-budget. It doesn't mean they earned a "B" grade or something.

I probably could have explained this better & with more entailment but I'm a little lazy to get into such information.

King Thor

King Thor on 12-2-2009 11:32 PM

I liked the first Saw. Actually mostly just the third act. In fact, I think the third act saved the whole movie.

Great picture which shows the moment when Doctor Gordan could have just used the saw to drag the phone to himself instead of sawing off his own foot.

Good thinkin' doc.

Mehone T.

Mehone T. on 12-3-2009 12:07 AM

You mean the Doc Gordon from the movie, or the one that's always puttin up obscure, and frankly outlandish comments on RT?

cinemascribe

cinemascribe on 12-3-2009 12:08 AM


King Thor wrote: "I liked the first Saw. Actually mostly just the third act. In fact, I think the third act saved the whole movie.

Great picture which shows the moment when Doctor Gordan could have just used the saw to drag the phone to himself instead of sawing off his own foot."

In the film, that particular phone doesn't dial out ..it was placed there specifically so that at a certain time during Gordon's game, Zepp could call him. And he doesn't cut his foot off to get to the phone, he cuts it off to get out of the bathroom.

I have no issue with anyone criticizing these movies. either you like 'em or you don't..but can we at least strive for some accuracy ?

King Thor

King Thor on 12-3-2009 08:53 AM

Cinemascribe,

I know that the phone didn't dial out, and that he cut his foot off to get out of the bathroom. But he had to do that because since he couldn't reach his phone while it was ringing because his wife was calling him. If he had been able to reach his phone he probably could have told his wife the situation he was in, she could have gone to the police, and they probably could have just traced his phone call and saved him.

That is, unless, Jigsaw didn't decide to electrocute him because 'those were the rules' and he wasn't allowed to do that or something.

BatsInTheBelfry

BatsInTheBelfry on 12-3-2009 01:44 AM

Very interested to see Colin. Awesome for including Eraserhead, that film is one of the most unsettling film experiences I've ever had, and I mean that in the best way.

Pseudonym

Pseudonym on 12-3-2009 03:48 AM

Glad to see Saw ONE in this list. It's the only one that matters.

Bed Head

Bed Head on 12-3-2009 04:07 AM

IMO, this list merely reflects how relatively simple it is to scare people. It doesn't necessarily take much money (or, in some cases, even any skill) ... seeing as fear is such a primal response, and all.

Of course, you'd never guess that based on the current state of the horror genre.

Gordon Franklin Terry Sr

Gordon Franklin Terry Sr on 12-3-2009 04:27 AM

Anything that is new and different makes money.

Major Motion Picture Studios avoid "new and different" like The Plague because there's too much risk.

"New and Different" films, therefore, don't get a lot of financing because of the risk. Thus a higher profit is earned by the owners because the film is "New and Different."

Hollywood only deals with people and films who/that are Already successful--nothing "new and different" comes from Major Studios.

Michael M.

Michael M. on 12-3-2009 05:09 AM

Halloween is the greatest horror movie of all-time. I'm not biased or anything. :)

BUCK69

BUCK69 on 12-3-2009 05:25 AM

It's been more than twenty-five years since I saw it, but Eraserhead still freaks me out. It's like some of the things that I did in the Army. A hell of an experience, but once is enough.

Wayne C.

Wayne C. on 12-3-2009 05:51 AM

"John Carpenter's movie about a knife-wielding psycho stalking Haddonfield on October 31 was an immediate fright-flick sensation due to its emphasis on suspense over gore."

Hate to be a stickler, but Halloween wasn't an immediate sensation. It started off with bad reviews and poor box office until it was out for a few months. Then it started to take off.

MAdams

MAdams on 12-3-2009 02:24 PM

Thanks for the comment, Wayne.

From what I've read, most of the reviews were positive at the time, although some, like Pauline Kael, weren't impressed. The great thing with google news archive search is you can see how people reacted back in the day, such as here:

http://news.google.com.au/newspapers?id=v1QQAAAAIBAJ&sjid=SowDAAAAIBAJ&pg=2780,4564626&dq=halloween movie carpenter&hl=en

And here:

http://news.google.com.au/newspapers?id=xVQQAAAAIBAJ&sjid=SowDAAAAIBAJ&pg=2982,9011027&dq=halloween movie carpenter&hl=en

As for the box office, you're right - it started slow but picked up. By October the next year the NYT reported it had grossed $50m (I'm assuming that included some int'l figures).

So, yes, I could've phrased it better!

BrianMN

BrianMN on 12-3-2009 06:25 AM

Open Water seems to be the one movie everyone seems to hate.
I loved it.
I'd put Halloween in the top spot and Open Water is my second.
Blair Witch, hated it.
Back to Open Water, the ending really seemed to make or break this movie with a lot of people.
I remember the first time I watched it and during the ending my mouth just sort of hit the floor. It took a few seconds for it to register that they actually ended it in such a way, not what I was expecting.
Not only that but the ocean and sharks scare the hell out of me. :(
The acting was crap but man, they had balls to swim right with the real thing instead of relying on CG.

The O-Critic

The O-Critic on 12-3-2009 06:41 AM

What? No Texas Chainsaw Massacre?

frothy

frothy on 12-3-2009 07:28 AM

To me, there's little more boring than seeing two people whine and snipe at each other about their various marital flaws. Yuck, Open Water, yuck.

Launy The Schwartz

Launy The Schwartz on 12-3-2009 07:39 AM

Trivia for all of you. Halloween was the highest grossing independent film of all time until this movie broke it's record...Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Oh Halloween. You were great for part 1,2, n H20. The rest (including the Hillbilly reboots) can all burn in an epic fail fire.

Cutler to the rescue

Cutler to the rescue on 12-3-2009 08:15 AM

Halloween is the greatest Horror movie of all time.

Glenn W.

Glenn W. on 12-3-2009 09:14 AM

Halloween is the movie that made me want to become a film student.

What's Hot On RT

Critics Consensus
Critics Consensus

Journey 2 Not Worth the Trip

Luis Guzman
Luis Guzman

What are his 10 best movies ever?

<em>Amazing Spider-Man</em>
Amazing Spider-Man

See the all-new action-packed trailer!

The Avengers!
The Avengers!

Five new Marvelous pictures

Help | About | Jobs | Newsletter | Critics Submission | API | Licensing | Blog | Developers | Mobile