It isn't the most highly anticipated sequel of the year, but The Pink Panther 2 opens this weekend, and in honor of Steve Martin's second turn as the successful-in-spite-of-himself Inspector Clouseau, we decided this would be a great time to look back at the best-reviewed movies of his career.
Over the last three decades, Martin has done it all: starred in classic comedies (The Jerk), critically lauded dramas (The Spanish Prisoner), and even a musical (Pennies from Heaven). He's written books, plays, and is currently promoting his first album of original banjo music alongside Pink Panther 2; clearly, even in the collection of larger-than-life personalities known as Hollywood, Steve Martin is in a class of his own. So let's spin the dials on the Tomatometer and relive the 10 freshest films in the Martin filmography -- and when we're done, have a look at the rest of his releases, including all your favorites that missed the cut!
10. Pennies from Heaven (83 percent)
Worried about being typecast as a buffoon, Martin used the career capital he'd earned with The Jerk to make his dramatic debut in the American remake of the 1978 BBC series Pennies from Heaven. Having loved the source material -- he publicly proclaimed it "the greatest thing I've ever seen" -- Martin went all out for the role of Depression-era sheet-music salesman Arthur Parker, taking six months of tap-dancing lessons in preparation for what ended up being one of the more critically well-received flops of the first half of the decade. Although audiences ignored Pennies, bringing in a paltry $9 million return on its $22 million budget -- and Fred Astaire bitterly bemoaned the use of his old footage in a film he derided as "cheap and vulgar...froth" -- many critics appreciated the script's cynical update on the classic musicals of the 1930s; Roger Ebert captured the mood of many of his peers when he termed it "dazzling and disappointing in equal measure."
9. The Jerk (83 percent)
Martin's first role in a feature film came in 1978's Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, but the less said about that, the better; for all intents and purposes, his movie career kicked off with his appearance as the simpleminded Navin R. Johnson in the rags-to-riches-and-back-again story The Jerk. While it certainly isn't for everyone -- if you require your comedies to have brains to go along with their hearts, or even to make complete sense from start to finish, then you may not find it all that funny -- but it's full of classic bits, and Martin's willingness to get dumb helped blaze a trail for everyone from Adam Sandler to Jim Carrey. (Don't thank him all at once.) Not all critics appreciated The Jerk when it was released, but it's aged well, moving into the pop-culture consciousness and inspiring fond memories in scribes like Channel 4 Film's Richard Luck, who wistfully remarked, "if only he could have satisfied himself with this area of expertise, people would still talk of Steve Martin as one of the kings of comic cinema."
|
vitajex writes: on Feb 05 2009 09:03 AM Pennies from Heaven has got to be one of the weirdest musicals ever! That's the only reason I could get through it, as I generally don't like musicals.(I have compulsive homicidal reactions to "Jazz Hands") The Jerk is, without a doubt, one of the funniest films ever. I could watch it 100 times and still laugh. And if you don't like "Planes, Trains and Automobiles", you probably like to kick puppies too. (Reply to this) |
|
JAKEofMIDWORLD writes: on Feb 05 2009 09:18 AM I think Steve Martin is one of the greats. He's made some bad pictures, but so has all the other great comedians. (Reply to this) |
|
arendr writes: on Feb 05 2009 09:24 AM Good lord, he's made some fantastic movies over the years. (Reply to this) |
|
He's a Cockapoopoo writes: on Feb 05 2009 09:34 AM Why does the "best" of everything have to depend on the Tomato Meter? Just because critics take themselves too seriously to give Three Amigos or My Blue Heaven a Fresh Rating... I should decide. (Reply to this) |
|
opTIMus Nerd writes: on Feb 05 2009 09:41 AM I love Martin in many things but he has not made a film worth seeing in YEARS! These Pink Panther things are depressing and I really don't understand the reason for another one...Uck. People saw the first one? L.A. Story, I thought, was a turning point for him and I remember being quite excited back then to think that most of his movies, from then on, would be of that quality or better. Instead Sgt. Bilko, Pink Panther and other garbage. Booooo. (Reply to this) |
|
tgibfo writes: on Feb 05 2009 09:49 AM Some good stuff.... obviously I completely agree with THREE AMIGOS and MY BLUE HEAVEN being above PENNIES FROM HEAVEN... (Reply to this) |
|
spoo writes: on Feb 05 2009 10:01 AM In reply to this comment (#2302537) Ugghh I hate My Blue Heaven but I do agree that The Three Amigos is great. (Reply to this) |
|
Hari Seldon writes: on Feb 05 2009 10:06 AM Best Steve Martin movies huh? Well let's see, there's The Jerk and .... Ummm ... I guess that's about it. (Reply to this) |
|
SuperJuice writes: on Feb 05 2009 10:19 AM As an "old" Martin fan, he needs to see this and strive for this type a' gold again. His last 10 years of movie-dome output is abyssmal. Bowfinger was his last good comedy. Is there any hope he'll somehow come back to us? I know he's about growing and shedding some of that old image, but his mojo is long gone. He could go back to his roots - maybe even going back to his *gasp* stand-up act (which is tried a number of years ago and putzed out). (Reply to this) |
|
IBelieveInHarveyDent writes: on Feb 05 2009 10:34 AM i used to have hope that steve martin would someday be funny again and then i heard his new banjo song on snl... (Reply to this) |
|
Nate A. writes: on Feb 05 2009 10:43 AM Martin has been in a rut for a while now, checked out his IMDB and his last good comedy was Bowfinger and it's ten years old already! Agree with Planes as the #1 film. Always thought The Man With Two Brains was pretty funny also. (Reply to this) |
|
Elixor writes: on Feb 05 2009 11:29 AM Planes as #1 is dead on, but I agree with others that Three Amigos would be on my top ten. But it's obvious how easy a list like this is if you can just rank them by something like Tamato meter scores too :) (Reply to this) |
|
kodie131 writes: on Feb 05 2009 11:32 AM The Jerk should be #1! Planes is great, but come on, nothing beats juggling cats. (Reply to this) |
|
arendr writes: on Feb 05 2009 11:55 AM Yeah, I like Three Amigos too. It's silly, but fun. Snobby critics really tore that movie apart. (Reply to this) |
|
Shatter24 writes: on Feb 05 2009 11:56 AM I do like the Tomato-meter makes an objective an impartial list, since it is a compilation of many critics reviews and therefore stands above individual preference. I do also agree that critics have a tendency to take themselves too seriously and this list is heavy on Martin films that are not what he's good at and known for (comedy) but are instead against type which critics like but audiences rarely do. Three Amigoes should definitly be on this list and My Blue Heaven should be considered. I too mourn the Steve Martin of old, who mixed zaniness with a straight man routine, rarely seen today. I don't think we'll ever seen that from Martin again, b/c his mediocre family-oriented comedies are too safe a bet for studios. (Reply to this) |
|
nathanpoitras writes: on Feb 05 2009 11:58 AM Don't forget BOWFINGER! (Reply to this) |
|
jokerboy1991 writes: on Feb 05 2009 12:02 PM In reply to this comment (#2302588) AH! My Blue Heaven is awesome... this list makes me sad, WHERE IS THOU AWESOME STEVE MARTIN?!? (Reply to this) |
|
Vito G. writes: on Feb 05 2009 12:10 PM In reply to this comment (#2302520) Steve martin is a great! My Blue heaven is by far one of the funniest movies ever he nails that roll. The Jerk should be number 1 and where art thou old steve martin all this new stuff is pretty bad except he has a small roll in Baby Mama which is classic Steve Martin. That right there lets me know that he does still have it he just chooses all this family comedy stuff. (Reply to this) |
|
tomwaitsjr writes: on Feb 05 2009 01:32 PM Wow! Looking at the opening for Pennies from Heaven, it's dead on for Hopper's "Nighthawks," one of the best American paintings ever. That said, the more I looked at the films, the sadder and more nostalgic I felt. All these God-Awful films Martin keeps doing makes it like he's more than dead, but being tortured and dying slowly. . . And Planes, et al. kind of makes me feel bittersweet, since we lost John Candy so early, and he was phenomenol in that film. I hope Pink Panther dies, but I predict it'll make over 50 million domestic overall. . . Paul Blart surprised me by making so much opening day, but I attribute that to that film being PG, as is this one. (Reply to this) |
|
jokerboy1991 writes: on Feb 05 2009 01:47 PM I would actually say Dead Men Don't Wear Plaid is my favorite of his, I am a butler not a catcher. (Reply to this) |
| You must be registered to post comments. Login or Register. |














