ROTTEN TOMATOES: Early Plans for a "Pirates 4"? Comments

Early Plans for a "Pirates 4"?

by Scott Weinberg | April 04, 2007

Summary

Whenever a new sequel hits the horizon and everyone gets all excited ... we get hungry for (yes) extra sequels! Now it seems there's some early rumblings about a fourth chapter in the "Pirates of the Caribbean" series -- although I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for it to happen. Back to Article

(1-24 of 24 posts) | Reply

rockstarfrank writes:
on Apr 04 2007 02:19 AM

[b]second thoughts on 4[/b]
At first I was pretty excited at news of part 4 or even more movies. I definitely love the Pirates movies, but 4 movies may be just a bit overkill...that's a lot of Jack Sparrows mumbling and with Richards in part 3 I think it may be best if the mumbling ends at 3.

Then again I would pay to see the 4th if they do it and I am sure it would be #1, however Disney is much to classy to milk a franchise...

(Reply to this)

GreenBastard writes:
on Apr 04 2007 02:56 AM

If they can keep the new idea's and excitment coming why stop!
As long as they still have Depp it's all good, who needs anyone else?

(Reply to this)

Aftermath_1551 writes:
on Apr 04 2007 03:00 AM

early on there were rumblings for a second trilogy and Depp has as much agreed to the idea. But they have to come up with some good ideas, otherwise it would be total crap. If they are going to approach a second set of movies then they should approach it as a second trilogy and not as one after one after one if you get my drift.

(Reply to this)

okito writes:
on Apr 04 2007 03:14 AM

I'm all for it, who doesn't like POTC. as long as They keeps DEPP and come up with great concepts of pirates with super powers, not like the sea monsters in the second movie, I don't care I could turn into a franchise for all I care, but please guys at Disney work WORK. they don't call you genius for nothing, plus the sequel reached a billion, and I'm guessin the third could do even better. just dont screw it up and keep 'em comin.

(Reply to this)

WiseGuy writes:
on Apr 04 2007 03:54 AM

Disney is too classy to milk a franchise? Where have you been? ...ever heard of Bambi II? Cinderella II? Cinderella III? Tarzan and Jane? The Little Mermaid II? The Little Mermaid III? Mulan II? Hercules: From Zero to Hero? The Lion King 1 1/2? The Lion King II: Simba's Pride? Pocahontas II? I hope that you were being sarcastic when you said that.

(Reply to this)

greatwhitetomato writes:
on Apr 04 2007 04:55 AM

[b]sarcasm[/b]
yes, sarcasm. (...) usually indicates sarcasm.

(Reply to this)

randal1013 writes:
on Apr 04 2007 06:08 AM

i think depp is a fantastic actor and all, but he can't carry a pirates movie by himself. besides, just how many sequels are they going to make? they already have a trilogy, that's enough!

(Reply to this)

S0BeURself writes:
on Apr 04 2007 07:27 AM

i love the pirates movies, but i think as a trilogy they'll have more resonance. and im glad wiseguy didnt catch the sarcasm, that list of sequels is pretty funny. whatever happened to early nineties disney?

(Reply to this)

lrm8 writes:
on Apr 04 2007 07:40 AM

although i have to say to wait until we see how the third one ends to judge whether or not to make the 4th (and 5th and 6th??), my first impression is just let it go disney.

(Reply to this)

DarthWonka writes:
on Apr 04 2007 08:00 AM

Just a start a friggin' series called The Adventures of Jack Sparrow or something. He's the only character besides maybe Barbossa that anyone gives a damn about anyway. Yeah, give Jack his own series, like an Indiana Jones or James Bond for pirates.

(Reply to this)

COME ON! writes:
on Apr 04 2007 08:51 AM

[b]Meh[/b]
Pirates of the Caribbean is sooo 2006.

(Reply to this)

photosuperstar writes:
on Apr 04 2007 08:57 AM

the second POTC film was the worst movie I've ever seen. It's so bad, I'm still angry at having spent money to see it. I have lower hopes for the third film and negative hopes for a forth one.

(Reply to this)

skasforfags writes:
on Apr 04 2007 09:29 AM

In reply to this comment (#860090)
You haven't seen many movies I take it.

It can't just be Johnny Depp, that's why the first one was better. He played second fiddle to the rest of the story, as opposed to the second where he, at times, was the entire focus.

(Reply to this)

Merlin235 writes:
on Apr 04 2007 10:19 AM

I just hope the third one is better than the second. I'll reserve my thoughts of a fourth on until I know that they can even make a good third one. Now, if the second one was better....I might think different.

(Reply to this)

Mattmovies writes:
on Apr 04 2007 10:43 AM

Everyone likes the pirate flicks?

Alll things considered, I'd rather them milk this franchise film than chance a bad Spiderman film.
Spiderman 3, if it is good, will beat the superhero movie curse (part 3s suck).
Why risk a lousy part 4?
Milk a movie made to make cash over milking a movie that has some real film making inspiration, that's how I see it. 10 Bad Transformers films that make Trillions can only support finer made work.

(Reply to this)

red_wine writes:
on Apr 04 2007 11:59 AM

Overkill! Overkill! Overkill!

(Reply to this)

phoenixphire24 writes:
on Apr 04 2007 12:52 PM

Depending on how 3 ends, I don't know that I'm interested in seeing more of this story line. I'd be much more interested in seeing how Jack became a pirate and his deal with Davy Jones...

(Reply to this)

Wallcloud writes:
on Apr 04 2007 01:38 PM

In reply to this comment (#860095)
i think the more ambiguous Sparrow's past is the better, prequels just undermine the first movie, and we'll know how it ends.

i'm soooooo excited for the 3rd pirates... but Disney should leave it on a high-note (unlikely).

(Reply to this)

ck100 writes:
on Apr 04 2007 02:51 PM

These movies are entertaining, but if you have too many then the series will wear out its welcome. As much as I enjoy Jack Sparrow, I'm worried we may get tired of the character if Depp continues to play him again and again and again and again..............

(Reply to this)

TheAnswerMVP2001 writes:
on Apr 04 2007 06:21 PM

If Depp wants to keep making them, then Disney would be fools to stop, doesn't mean they're going to be good, but they'd still be fools.

(Reply to this)

aknddon3 writes:
on Apr 04 2007 07:28 PM

In reply to this comment (#860083)
They made those movies for the kids which LOVE them, so do ot open your mouth again.

(Reply to this)

WeaponAndy writes:
on Apr 06 2007 11:34 AM

If the third movie is as sweet as it looks, I wouldn't mind a 4th. If they do a 4th, maybe they could just blot out Depps Sparrow and just focus on Barbosa. The dude is a bad ass and his crazy ass ship fight in a whirlpool with cannons blazing looks awesome.

(Reply to this)

ipisking writes:
on Apr 07 2007 06:27 AM

Did someone just say Moooo!!!!

(Reply to this)

johnnydepprocks writes:
on May 14 2007 02:45 PM

[b]pirates of the caribbean 3[/b]
hey
i think it would be cool to have more piorates of the caribbean movies. i know there is going to be a fourth, and that would be cool if they would make more. johnny depp would.

(Reply to this)

Related Links

Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl

Related Articles

Most Discussed

Latest News

Latest Interviews

Latest Features

Sponsored Links