Alas, we never buy the depth of Holly and Gerry's love because the chemistry between Swank and Butler is nonexistent.
1 Comment
12/24/07
Rate this Movie 
P.S. I Love You (2007)
22
%
Tomatometer
How does the Tomatometer work
Reviews Counted:95
Fresh:21
Rotten:74
Average Rating:4.4/10
Consensus: Hilary Swank is miscast as the romantic lead in this clichéd film about loss and love.
Rated: PG-13 [See Full Rating]
Runtime: 2 hrs 7 mins
Genre: Irish, Romance, Romantic Comedy, Based On A Novel, Theatrical Release
Theatrical Release:2008
Box Office: $53,535,019
Synopsis: Two-time Oscar winner Hillary Swank tries her hand at romantic comedy in this touching film based on the bestselling Irish novel. Holly Kennedy (Swank) and her charming Irish husband Gerry (Gerard... [More]
Starring: Hilary Swank, Gerard Butler, Gina Gershon, Lisa Kudrow
Director: Richard LaGravenese
Get This Movie
Reviews for P.S. I Love You
[Hilary] Swank's raw, genuine performance stands out -- like an emerald on a compost heap -- against the canned warmth...
12/22/07
It's Million Dollar Cry Baby. P.S. I Love You is the most potent tear jerker since The Notebook. It's not as profound or skillful, but there certainly hasn't been anything that makes you so happy to cry since then.
12/21/07
If you're looking for a great date movie so you can get laid over the holidays, this is the one.
12/21/07
This is the kind of movie that was made for the female audience and we thank you. PS, take Kleenex.
12/21/07
[T]his wonderful movie... is not relentlessly grim, but it is endlessly poignant even in its lightest moments...
12/21/07
The end dedication (to the producer's late sister) reminds us that even a disposable commercial film can be extremely personal and meaningful for the people involved in its creation.
12/21/07
Snippets of sharp, witty dialogue are lost in a sea of sappy clichés and too-cute-for-words plot twists.
12/21/07
Hillary Swank makes the best of her lonely heart role but never gets to take off the gloves in an entertaining romantic drama. Supporting she-wolf Lisa Kudrow steals the show.
12/21/07
Swank does her best, but she seems lost in the movie's identity crisis, taking the project seriously one moment and doing a pratfall off a karaoke stage the next.
12/21/07
The film does have its share of funny, winning, and heartwarming/emotional moments, but the rest feel artificial and contrived, from the basic conceit to the various smaller elements that are too familiar and/or forced to elicit any sort of favorable resp
12/21/07
The movie is so bent on conjuring big, sweeping emotions that it becomes a bit scattershot, starting down way too many tear-jerking roads but never going down any of them far enough to discover any real substance.
12/21/07
Doesn't add anything fresh or special or memorable to our understanding of the grief process.
12/21/07
The supporting roles are all handled well by experienced actors, and they have good material to work with.
12/21/07
P.S. I Love You isn't as pathetically sappy as the title might sound. OK, maybe it is a little...
12/21/07
Some actors are better suited to straight-ahead dramas. Swank appears to be one of them.
12/21/07
It's tough going relieved only by some lovely Irish scenery.
12/21/07
It's the sort of movie that no man will ever go to unless dragged by a woman. His sole reward will be the sight of Swank in sexy underwear.
12/21/07
The talented Swank is slumming a bit here, but she could -- and has -- done worse.
12/21/07
In its way, it's almost daringly radical in its old-fashioned sentimentality.
12/21/07
Latest News for P.S. I Love You
September 05, 2008:
Video Exclusive: Gerard Butler talks RocknRolla and 300 sequel with RT
RocknRolla is, critics are rumbling, Guy Ritchie's powerful return to form, a snappy ensemble crime caper featuring drug dealers, Russian billionaires, rock stars and a... More...
August 15, 2008:
OtherCool.com: Swank gets it just right with a fine-tuned subtle expression of confusion, despondency and rage. 
More...
April 03, 2008:
Stan Lee, Disney Commit to Three Films
Stan Lee might be 85 years old, but he's showing no signs of slowing down. More...
December 23, 2007:
Box Office Guru Wrapup: National Treasure Uncovers Holiday Gold at #1 Spot
Cage posted one of the best openings of his career with National Treasure: Book of Secrets which debuted on top with an estimated $45.5M from an aggressive launch in 3,832... More...
RT On Current TV
What’s Hot On RT
Fresh Links
Featured
Best Sci-Fi This Decade
Techland lists the best Sci-Fi films of this decade.
40 Worst Films of the 2000s
Moviefone takes a look back at the biggest stinkers of the past 10 years.
10 Questions For Zac Efron
The Me and Orson Welles star answers reader questions on TIME.com.
Best Decade Ever!
Hollywood.com's C. Robert Cargill offers his thoughts on what the best decade for film was.
Pee-Wee's Big Adventure
In the AV Club's "Scenic Routes," Mike D'Angelo reminisces about the Tim Burton film.
Promos
Follow RT on Twitter
Get the latest Tomatometer updates on upcoming movies!
IGN RSS Feeds