Shame

Shame

79%

Critic Review - ColeSmithey.com

Crossing the line into pornography never seemed so simultaneously safe and repressed.

November 13, 2011 Full Review Source: ColeSmithey.com | Comments (7)
ColeSmithey.com

Comments

Jason Osiason

Jason Osiason

Fuck you, you hack. :)

Nov 15 - 09:05 PM

Lenny Feder

creighton satterfield

You didn't like Toy Story 3...

Nov 17 - 12:30 PM

Anthony Ruggio

Anthony Ruggio

How do random douches like this get their own website, much less become counted as a legitimate critic on RT? If you don't have real journalistic credentials outside of the blogosphere you have no business being counted as a reputable critic.

Nov 21 - 02:24 AM

Alex Greenbean

Alex Greenbean

have you ever been to this guy's site? he has an auction on E-bay to go out with him. the starting bid is $250. I never saw a bid yet. this guy is a pretentious moron.

Nov 28 - 10:04 PM

Adam Roman

Adam Roman

what does his review of Toy Story 3 have to do with anything?


although I do think that me and this critic have nothing in common, i'm just saying saying "you didn't like toy story 3" is meaningless.

Nov 28 - 10:33 PM

Sean Wu

Sean Wu

Though I probably will not see SHAME until I'm older, I can say this: It's wrong to compare the film to pornography. Cole, did youexpect this film ot be all full forntal nudity, shaky cam, but no character? McQueen didn't make this to be about porn, it's about a man addicted to sex. Cole Smithey, you are a twisted pervert trying to egg the film about what it wasn't meant to be.

Dec 4 - 07:21 PM

Sam Walden

Sam Walden

Reviews like this are sad. This is an example of a person who has judged a masterpiece without even bothering to try and understand it. This isn't a safe movie and it wasn't supposed to be and comparing it to pornography only proves that the "critic" is a truly immature person.

Jan 10 - 02:53 AM

Find us on:                     
Help | About | Jobs | Critics Submission | Press | API | Licensing | Mobile