"DreamWorks Animation SKG" isn't the type of studio name that suggests the sort of mystery and wonder we expect from our cartoon features -- in fact, but for the "animation" part, it reads like something you might expect to see written on the wall of an especially groovy German chemical factory. Appearances can be deceiving, however; over the last 11 years, DreamWorks' animation division has provided filmgoers with some of the most offbeat, adventurous, and critically well-received family-friendly fare around -- a streak the studio hopes to continue with their latest release, this week's technologically groundbreaking 3-D feature Monsters vs. Aliens.
We knew just what to do to celebrate the occasion: Dedicate this week's Total Recall to revisiting the DreamWorks Animation filmography, from 1998's Antz straight through to last year's Kung Fu Panda. Like any studio, DreamWorks has had its ups and downs over the years, and not everything has found its way to a Fresh certification -- but more often than not, they've hit the critical bulls-eye (and made buckets of cash in the process). How do your favorites stack up with the critics'? Read on to find out! -- and then play our DreamWorks Cartoon Challenge!
17. Shark Tale
For the second time, DreamWorks found itself pushing a project with a lot of superficial similarities to a Pixar picture -- and once again, Pixar ended up on top. After the Antz vs. A Bug's Life throwdown, DreamWorks could at least console itself with some terrific reviews; Shark Tale, however, has the dubious distinction of being the studio's worst-reviewed release -- despite a star-studded voice cast that includes Will Smith, Jack Black, Robert De Niro, and Angelina Jolie. Though audiences clearly hadn't tired of CGI fish -- Shark Tale grossed $367 million worldwide -- critics weren't impressed with its endless string of pop culture gags and Godfather-inspired plot; Roger Ebert spoke for most of his peers when he wrote, "It's strange that a kid-oriented film would be based on parody of a 1972 gangster movie for adults."
16. Shrek the Third
The third time was definitely the charm for the big green animated ogre at the box office -- Shrek the Third racked up nearly $800 million in worldwide grosses -- but critically, the second sequel in the Shrek franchise suffered an ignominous fate, earning a 41 percent Tomatometer and scores of scornful reviews from the likes of Newsweek's David Ansen, who halfheartedly complimented it as "skillfully made corporate product" before saying "I wonder who, exactly, will be fully satisfied.
15. Sinbad: Legend of the Seven Seas
Though most of DreamWorks Animation's releases have turned a profit, every studio suffers the occasional commercial misfortune. Sinbad: Legend of the Seven Seas was a whopper, earning the lowest total for any film shown at more than 3,000 screens in all of 2003 and prompting DreamWorks honcho Jeffrey Katzenberg to proclaim the death of traditional animation in general. Not what you would have expected from a movie featuring the voices of Brad Pitt, Catherine Zeta-Jones, and Michelle Pfeiffer -- but then, you also wouldn't expect it to be, in the words of Mark Halverson of the Sacramento News & Review, "as routine as many live-action adventure films, right down to the competent but fairly undistinguished art and animation."
|
Rolento88 writes: on Mar 26 2009 09:17 AM maybe they should do one for pixar now... (Reply to this) |
|
dlo2012 writes: on Mar 26 2009 09:55 AM In reply to this comment (#2396678) i think they already did a pixar one (Reply to this) |
|
dlo2012 writes: on Mar 26 2009 09:59 AM chicken run was ok but i really think that shrek, kung fu panda, and antz were a lot better (Reply to this) |
|
the_clouds_are_bleeding writes: on Mar 26 2009 12:21 PM I loved Wallace & Gromit: Curse Of The Were-Rabbit! It is the only movie on the list which I have seen more than once and will go back for repeat viewings. (Reply to this) |
|
centaine writes: on Mar 26 2009 12:33 PM whatever...Madagascar is still my fav (Reply to this) |
|
alsanali writes: on Mar 26 2009 12:36 PM Flushed Away is by far Dreamworks' best CGI film. Though, unsurprisingly, the wit didn't work quite as well for American audiences as it should have. (Reply to this) |
|
Speaker for the Films writes: on Mar 26 2009 12:43 PM Right Now, Monsters would be #9, right before Flushed Away. (Reply to this) |
|
alsanali writes: on Mar 26 2009 12:43 PM I'm also hoping Monsters vs. Aliens turns out well. Any movie that combines House, Dwight, Jack Bauer and Stephen Colbert as president gets points in my book. (Reply to this) |
|
Speaker for the Films writes: on Mar 26 2009 12:53 PM Right Now, Monsters would be #9, right before Flushed Away. (Reply to this) |
|
ihatecarneys writes: on Mar 26 2009 01:14 PM i'm sure they'll do a pixar one when Up comes out. (Reply to this) |
|
vashfanatic writes: on Mar 26 2009 01:31 PM And yet, "Shark Tale" received an Oscar nomination. That's just sad. (Reply to this) |
|
Sputnik99 writes: on Mar 26 2009 02:06 PM I own Antz on VHS-tape. That's funny. Didn't realize it was that old. And Chicken Run is a masterpiece. Love it. Aardman is the only production company that I consider better than Pixar. (Reply to this) |
|
Travis C. writes: on Mar 26 2009 02:18 PM Dreamworks sucks (Reply to this) |
|
ledawg1138 writes: on Mar 26 2009 03:09 PM "Kung Fu Panda" is my favorite Dreamworks film. I love "Shrek" and "Shrek 2" and "Antz" and "Chicken Run", but "Kung Fu Panda" was a great animated movie. If you haven't seen it, do so. (Reply to this) |
|
Floor Man writes: on Mar 26 2009 03:31 PM I wonder...does anybody remember the BOOK called..."Shrek"? Not a bad film, of course, but the book holds a special place in my heart. (Reply to this) |
|
SuckitBaby writes: on Mar 26 2009 03:36 PM Sorry people, but Kung Fu Panda (while not a bad movie at all) is highly overrated! Wall-E is by far the best animated movie I've seen in a looong time! (Reply to this) |
|
ledawg1138 writes: on Mar 26 2009 04:37 PM In reply to this comment (#2397213) Yeah, "WALL-E" is better, but "Kung Fu Panda" is still a great animated film. (Reply to this) |
|
Tyrant writes: on Mar 26 2009 05:09 PM Wallace and Grommit rocks, my favorite animated movie :) It's also one of the few family movies i enjoy. (Reply to this) |
|
nathanpoitras writes: on Mar 26 2009 05:44 PM Kung Fu Panda is easily the best thing Dreamworks Animation has done to date. (Reply to this) |
|
knowingtoast85 writes: on Mar 26 2009 06:51 PM Call me a sucker for claymation, but nothing tops Nick Park's masterpieces. Even "Flushed Away," a victim to the rewrites and notes processes that befall CG productions far more streamlined than painstaking stop-motion, had some really bright, engaging moments. (Reply to this) |
| You must be registered to post comments. Login or Register. |












