Vincent Pieretti

You're obviously the stupid one

Oct 13 - 09:14 PM

Joe Slansky

c'mon that was one of the better horror flicks of all time!

Oct 13 - 10:40 PM

Lucinda Shale

I agree with Vincent and Joe. . . To have thought this film was silly means that you lack the intellectual depth to have understood what the movie was trying to achieve. There was significant character development without handing everything to us on a plate, plenty of jumps even when you knew they were coming, the movie was gripping, there were no unnecessary scenes to bulk it out - every scene had a purpose, there was fantastic imagery and thought behind it. It was clever, twisted, original and depraved - what exactly were you looking for when you went to see this film, because it fulfilled everything that a good horror movie should have and more. I have very few negatives about this film.

Oct 14 - 12:14 AM

Basti-John Norman Artiaga

It is kinda stupid sorry

Oct 14 - 12:58 AM

Sam Wiidge

I'm a big horror fan and I loved this film. It was anything but stupid - on the contrary, the story was deep, not superficial, and the acting and script were solid. The scares and jumpy moments were effectively combined with a sinister and dark feeling that leaves the audience disturbed and horrified. This is how horror films should be done; not the silly, cliche stuff that passes for 'horror' nowadays. I couldn't disagree more with those who say it was banal or stupid. My advice to them? Go see the movie, and actually watch it this time.

Oct 14 - 03:45 AM

Iain Dyce

This film was absolutely TERRORFYING unless you grew up with a father who looked like that demon no could sleep fine after seeing that freaky white face. you critics are stupid and always have been, ever since you called titanic good and star wars bad.

Oct 14 - 07:49 AM

Becky Mundy

I really enjoyed this movie and thought it was scary and fun. Of course it knew who the real demon is! The demon possessed the children. The children were too young to understand, so they call him Mr. Boogie, which also prevents giving it away too soon (unless you'd already figured it out...). Not too hard to understand.

Top critics should be above calling a movie "stupid". Sounds like a cop-out to me.

Oct 14 - 07:16 PM

Gaby Castro

I agree with vincent and joe and lucinda. Them showing Baghul in the begining would have ruined the suspense. And the story wasnt even about him killing people if you noticed. It was about the father and the video tapes trying to solve everything. not just about the deity.

Oct 15 - 07:43 AM

Anthony Felix

Hey, I watched this movie and I loved it. You are so stupid to think this movie was stupid, sorry. I felt like saying something :D

Oct 15 - 04:20 PM

Charlotte Lomax

Some people are just never happy. In comparison to most drivel that comes out nowadays this movie is an unpredictable gem in a sea of plastic jewellery...

Oct 17 - 01:34 AM

Julia Longoria

Thank you this movie was terrible!

Oct 17 - 09:06 PM

Raphaël Rivest

I am surprised to see the Tomatometer for this has gone so low when i actually thought it would get much better. I don't understand what can be so bad about this movie for a critic to actually hate it when i thought most of the things in it were done right. Oh well, can't agree with everyone!

Oct 18 - 09:09 AM

Karen Engels

You are out of your cotton pickin' mind!

Oct 18 - 10:48 AM

Mitch Andrews

you are stupid and your face is very scary

Oct 18 - 04:46 PM

Scott Mallon

it seems as if someone named peter howell didn't take the time to try and enjoy it. just immediately started trying to figure out how he would say it sucked. i figure you probably went into the movie thinking that.

Oct 18 - 10:14 PM

Chad Gibson

In your review you referred to Ethan Hawke's character as Ellison Osborne. I believe it's Oswalt. Also, google isn't as reliable of a source when compared to a police database. You should probably watch the movie again sir, and stop using google as a viable source.

Oct 20 - 07:29 AM

Dean Wirth

Peter you are so stupid, this movie is scary.

Oct 23 - 06:35 AM

Tom Martin

well, I don't always google about the places i moved into, I doubt there are coral snakes and scorpions in Pennsylvania so he must have known he was hallucinating, and glasses, depends what is lacking in his vision. not everyone does as much research as you do, most of us are lazy.

Oct 23 - 06:57 PM

Ryan Phillips

So it's a stupid movie because the character didn't use google? I'm sorry a 3 minute google search does not make an entertaining movie. I don't believe this guy has any reason to judge horror movies, in pretty much all good horror movies the protagonist does something stupid or irrational that usually results in their death, but if the only valid criticism you have is that the character went to classified police archives instead of "googling" the murders I'd say it's a pretty good movie.

Oct 28 - 12:17 PM