Declan Connor

their is a scene when an engineer tells the bridge that the warp core was knocked out

Sep 9 - 02:04 AM

Robbie Moore

Excuse me, you are off. Star Trek was a really good movie

May 29 - 01:39 PM

David Gee

George Kirk couldn't warp-kamikaze Nero's ship because it was so badly damaged. Remember when you were watching it and saw it all happen right there in front of you? And if you're still confused, just ask any random small child who saw the movie and they'll tell you that.

May 29 - 10:18 AM

Nick Fury

Says the idiot who thinks that Roger Ebert is still alive and thinks that Star Trek is called Space Trek.

Apr 25 - 12:27 PM

Leo Monteiro

Matthew Preston = fucktard

Apr 22 - 08:04 PM

Tylerambo: First John Part II

So you hate on Star Trek '09 but defend Movie 43. Pathetic.

Apr 6 - 06:37 PM

Diego Hard With an Anus

Oh my God... threads like this are why I go on Rotten Tomatoes. I don't know how I'd get through my day without checking up occasionally to see how the epic war between Matthew Preston/Movie 43/Geordie Newlands and Jake Preston/Alex Maverick/Dylan Jones. You guys make my day. Thank you.

Apr 3 - 06:50 PM

Pat S.

Don't feed the troll guys. This forum is about the upcoming film not the first one, the only reason why someone would come here to insult the first film is to bait fans into an emotional response. A.k.a., a troll.

Mar 25 - 05:20 PM

In Your Dreams

Oh look, it's Pretend Black Guy, back for more lazy trolling.

Mar 25 - 11:05 AM

Alex Aston

Why do people keep on answering this guy's posts if he pisses everybody off? Anyway I myself am a Trekkie and I actually loved the last one. Not only was it the best Star Trek movie yet for me, but I also thought it was the best adventure film since Raiders of the Lost Ark.

Mar 10 - 06:49 PM

Dylan Jones

What a fucktard.

Mar 8 - 01:40 PM

Jacklord Alan Keen

You suck...the movie was great...

Mar 8 - 05:52 AM

Ryan Gahris

I enjoyed this movie quite a bit. I also enjoy the deconstruction of logic, from time to time, with things beyond our comprehension. In conversing about the space-time continuum and what energies beyond our current understanding, like dark matter/anti-matter, are capable of.

So, while all the current theories remain merely hypothetical, their effects cannot be concretely argued one way or the other. More importantly, when these elements and ideas are experimented with in film, it is simply a catalyst to make you consider the possibilities. The entertainment of thought alongside amusement.

To get thee panties in a bunch over inconsistencies that you, yourself, believe to be a reality only highlights your failure to imagine the possibilities and limit yourself within the distracting nuisances of your own perception. Personally, I think your just trolling to get everyone riled up. You have found success in that regard, amidst your presumably dismal life. Thankfully though, I learned a long time ago that there is no use, point or way to successfully argue with a sociopath.

People like you who make me look forward to the day dolphins supplant the human race in intelligence and world-wide dominance. And by the look of this thread you engineered, that day might just come in my lifetime if we use you to set the bar. With that, I hope you move beyond your own demented sense of clarity and find a way to put into practice, a sense of empathy towards your fellow human beings in this life. So, when you move onto the next, you won't find yourself alone as you wander... Into Darkness! :P

Feb 24 - 11:52 PM

hollis mills

oh matthew, so stupid, gay, and retarded

Feb 17 - 01:48 PM

Jake Preston

Oh Matthew. That's not what you said last night when we watched it. Remember, you asked me to spoon you afterwards?

Feb 16 - 12:30 PM

Calvin Candie

So you want us to agree with you? Fuck that shit.

Feb 9 - 01:48 PM

Chum Chum

hmm yea.. ok. So, what is with the habitual trollin...why do you need attention from strangers? Do you need to feel important? Whats the vindication for acting like a child?
I'm expecting a bullshit responce but theres always time to kill

Feb 7 - 08:05 AM

Steve Oden

Matthew,

If I may attempt an assessment of the scenario you have brought to light. These are possibilities that counter your assessment of the scene.

1. Nero's ship had just appeared through a time dilation. In the past, this has knocked out shields (both defensive, and structural integrity) on any ship traveling through time.

2. The Federation ship was thousands of kilometers (albeit not well shown on screen, which would be the only flaw I could entertain. But this will be remedied by future points) from Nero's ship. This would allow for greater velocity of impact when the two collided.

3. Even at a short distance, in space there is no drag coefficient. This allows for an object to obtain greater speed in a shorter period of time.

4. Gauging the amount of time that Kirk had time to speak with his wife, this supports the ship was farther away than we see on screen.

5. The Federation ship flew inside the (for lack of better term) claws of Nero's ship, again allowing for it to gain greater speed.

6. If the structural and defensive shields were down, this accounts for explosions throughout Nero's vessel.


I hope this helps.

Feb 7 - 05:52 AM

Al Sousa

"Shit were spotted, jam their transmissions and knock out their warp drive" Doesnt take a vulcan to figure that one out people.

Feb 5 - 11:34 PM

Movie 43

Matthew, saying that Stra trek sucks and movie 43 is great means that your the best

Feb 5 - 05:39 PM

Trey Marksberry

I legitimately don't understand how people like you use this site. You have no knowledge of this movie obviously, whatsoever.

Feb 4 - 07:19 PM

Bob Saget

"Why the first one sucked poo". Just the name of the thread shows the brain development of the person who wrote it.

Feb 4 - 01:46 PM

hollis mills

oh bright boy, go eat sum poo

Feb 2 - 09:21 PM

Dylan Jones

That's a terrible argument.

Feb 2 - 12:26 PM

Bob Saget

That is your argument for why you didn't like the movie?

Feb 1 - 03:41 PM