Critic Review - ReelViews

The film is never boring. It is, however, completely preposterous.

January 28, 2009 Full Review Source: ReelViews | Comments (6)
Top Critic IconTop Critic


King Thor

Chris Kalmin

So if a movie is preposterous it gets a rotten rating? Taken (which is completely preposterous) is meant to be a fun movie not Oscar worthy. "The film is never boring," good, then it did its job.

The Dark Knight was a preposterous premise, does that warrant a rotten rating?

I'm not saying your opinion is wrong or anything like that, but if a movie is fun to watch and you enjoy it, doesn't that deserve a fresh rating?

I liked Taken a lot. Women trafficking in Europe does happen, that is not preposterous. Maybe the rest of the plot isn't too likely to happen, but it sure as hell is extremely entertaining.
The movie achieved its goal and is not a bad movie on any account. That should warrant a fresh rating.

Jan 28 - 08:32 PM

Ausautas V.

Ausautas V.

"The Dark Knight was a preposterous premise, does that warrant a rotten rating?"

Thank you. Every time I hear this "unrealistic, implausible, suspension of disbelief" stuff, several "Dark Knight" scenes pop into my head.

Not a classic, but a watchable action fantasy of efficient revenge.

Sep 26 - 12:18 AM


Futureman .

Like a Timex watch, this review keeps going and going and going....

Jan 29 - 09:31 AM


Frank Cisneros

You suck ****.

Jan 31 - 01:20 PM


Dano Jackson

I loved the movie.
I agree with King Thor's comment 100%
It felt like the movie was over in 15 minutes, that's how gripping it was.

Feb 6 - 05:35 AM


Rick Newsom

Funny, the Bourne movies were also completely preposterous, were they not?

Yet the reviewer seemed to enjoy THEM.

Although I usually tend to agree with more of Mr. Berardinelli's reviews than not, I fear that he, as many other professional reviewers, are handicapped by their familiarity with the folks who bring us these movies. I suspect that at least some of the negativity in the review is a previously acquired dislike for Mr. Besson's work.

Feb 16 - 07:47 PM

Find us on:                     
Help | About | Jobs | Critics Submission | Press | API | Licensing | Mobile