• PG-13, 2 hr.
  • Drama
  • Directed By:
    David Fincher
    In Theaters:
    Oct 1, 2010 Wide
    On DVD:
    Jan 11, 2011
  • Columbia Pictures

Critic Review - Eclipse Magazine

What happens when a director and writer hate their subject? A well made, but one dimensional hit piece.

October 2, 2010 Full Review Source: Eclipse Magazine | Comments (47)
Eclipse Magazine

Comments

Mr J.

Mr Jim

*waits for s-storm*

Oct 2 - 06:11 AM

Ithil

Ian Browne

What the hell? Your blurb is flat out insulting the people involved in making the film?

Oct 2 - 06:23 AM

Corey D.

Corey Dowd

ALSO, BLACK PEOPLE

Oct 2 - 06:26 AM

JokerJakub13

Jacob Gronowski

why are the people involved with making the film a bunch of douche bags? you stupid piece of shit cunt..go back to the kitchen and bake me some cookies

Oct 2 - 06:40 AM

cderry

Chris Derry

Erica Albright...is that you? I'm sorry you were compared to a farm animal in the movie. Wait...no I'm not.

Oct 2 - 06:43 AM

Zachary P.

Zachary P

Bahahaha, you win, sir.

Oct 2 - 09:27 PM

kargo

ivan kargovski

Stay in the kitchen bitch!

I'm only partially kidding but for someone like that it's the only suitable response.

She has a history of making incredibly dumb remarks so it's not really surprising...what's surprising is the kind of idiots that constitute what are known as film critics.

You can't do anything yourself?You have no talents?You're a frustrated individual?Become a critic.

Oct 2 - 06:54 AM

Brian B.

Brian Barreto

David Fincher..."douchebag"? Sorry lady, you are very, very slow in the head, aren't you?

Anyways, to those of you who haven't seen this film, go and see it now. It was amazing-the 2nd best film of 2010 after Inception, in my opinion.

Oct 2 - 07:28 AM

Zoubin I.

Zoubin Irani

Armond and his trolls are really trying to damage this movie.

Too bad their reviews are atrocious and vulgar.

Oct 2 - 07:37 AM

DoctorSubmarine

Josh Rosenfield

It seems as though the only negative reviews are from people who don't take film criticism seriously.

Oct 2 - 07:39 AM

The Stunner

Tiago Paulo

because film criticism is so serious nowadays?

Nov 24 - 11:19 AM

ftf353

Anthony Filaseta

Why the fuck are the people involved with making this movie douchebags?? Holy shit you are one stupid bitch.

Oct 2 - 07:55 AM

Sean Z.

Sean Zabik

If a writer and a director make a movie they obviously dont hate their subject there writting about they find an intrest in this person. If you've seen any interviews with the cast and crew they are all truly interestined in what David fincher and Aaron Sorkin have made.

Oct 2 - 08:19 AM

Sean Z.

Sean Zabik

If a writer and a director make a movie they obviously dont hate their subject there writting about they find an intrest in this person. If you've seen any interviews with the cast and crew they are all truly interestined in what David fincher and Aaron Sorkin have made.

Oct 2 - 08:19 AM

Gjorgi M.

Gjorgi Micalevski

People, people, people calm down, this is the guy that gave Eclipse a B+ and Inception a D.
hahahha what a fake ass

Oct 2 - 08:29 AM

Ali T.

Ali Tabaei

you do not know about this movie ranking !!??

Oct 2 - 08:36 AM

ftf353

Anthony Filaseta

Ahahahahaha!!! I love how she changed her asinine "douchebag" rant once she realized how fucking stupid it/she was.

Oct 2 - 09:57 AM

Rich M.

Rich M.

By Esenberg's reactions?

Please learn how to spell, Michelle

Oct 2 - 10:51 AM

Bob V.

Bob Villa

HAHAHHAA!!! This bitch again!!!

Oct 2 - 10:58 AM

Bob V.

Bob Villa

This dumb bitch gave Inception a rotten too...then she came here and got into arguments with people...hilarious!!!

Oct 2 - 11:00 AM

Jeremy D.

Jeremy Dewald

It's so funny when a critic is sooo wrong. They make their-self look so stupid because they make statements like this one, which are completely absurd and couldn't be farther from the truth. It must suck when you can't even notice that this is a good movie huh Michelle? Must be embarrassing to come on here and realize your in a small group that contains Armond White as the only critics in America who disliked this film.

Oct 2 - 11:00 AM

Sarah H.

Sarah H

I'm hoping your use of "their-self" was meant to be ironic...

Oct 3 - 08:41 PM

vik713

Vikas Gupta

This a$$hole of a "critic" is just as backwards as that douchetard armond.

She gave rotten ratings to the following:
Scott Pilgrim
Inception
Shutter Island
Avatar

and fresh ratings for:
Step Up 3D
X-Men Origins: Wolverine
GI Joe
Resident Evil: Afterlife

This stupid bitch has no credibility whatsoever.

Oct 2 - 12:22 PM

Vince Vaughn not really

Glenn Vaughn

well...some people have weird opinions

Oct 13 - 05:26 PM

Find us on:                     
Help | About | Jobs | Critics Submission | Press | API | Licensing | Mobile