Critic Review - Reel Film Reviews

...one of the worst comic-book adaptations to come around in ages...

July 28, 2012 Full Review Source: Reel Film Reviews | Comments (50)
Reel Film Reviews

Comments

John Dorian

John Dorian

.one of the worst comic-book adaptations to come around in ages...

What About Green Lantern?

Jul 28 - 03:36 PM

bob  j.

bob jones

he said one of, not the

Jul 28 - 06:35 PM

The Fox

What Does Da Foe Say?

Top 5 worst comic adaptations ever?
1: Daredevil
2: The Fantastic 4
3: Green Lantern
4: The Incredible Hulk
5: Spider-Man 3

Nov 7 - 07:35 PM

The Fox

What Does Da Foe Say?

Not to mention Catwoman, Elektra, Ghost Rider, Aeon Flux, Cowboys and Aliens, Spider-Man 1 & 2, Batman & Robin, etc.

Nov 7 - 07:38 PM

Himanshu Pant

Himanshu Pant

This movie is better than the dark knight rises.
The dark knight rises is a 3 hours of foolishness and crap.
The amazing spider-man is combination of adventure, action, mystery and fun.
Spider-man can beat batman easily and the lizard can kill bane with only one punch.

Jul 28 - 11:46 PM

Ricardo S.

Ricardo Santaella

agree watch my reviews :)

Jul 29 - 09:51 PM

bob  j.

bob jones

first off, tdkr is great, and better than this. second, spider-man can't beat batman. and thirdly, the lizard is a CREATURE. bane is a human. of course he could kill him, if he is bigger than him. and just because characters in one movie can beat characters in another one (which in this case they cannot) it doesn't make the movie better. is 'godzilla' better than 'alien' because godzilla can kill the alien? no. and stop commenting on every negative review. i think you like this movie a little too much

Jul 30 - 01:37 AM

Andrew Boyce

Andrew Boyce

spider man will defeat batman and dont compare lizard and bane two very diffrent villans

Jul 31 - 09:36 PM

bob  j.

bob jones

i didn't compare bane and lizard, i responded to someone who did

Jul 31 - 10:50 PM

Musa Giwa

Musa Giwa

Spider-man cannot beat batman, batman is too methodical to be defeated by spiderman's impulsive antics. love them both though :D

Aug 2 - 04:33 PM

Jon Martin

Jon Martin

I agree, Batman would get his ass handed to him on a platter by Spidey!!! Even if Spidey would have 1 one hand tied behind his back and wore a blindfold... lol

Aug 12 - 08:18 PM

Andrew Boyce

Andrew Boyce

dont compare them

Aug 1 - 08:12 PM

Aiden Jeynes

Aiden Jeynes

Spiderman fanboy detected

Aug 15 - 02:45 AM

Joshua Henderson

Joshua Henderson

An iconic character is bound to have fans.

Aug 23 - 02:05 PM

Karen Warwick

Karen Warwick

That's like saying Bucky Larson: Born to be a Star is the beast movie in history.The Amazing Spiderman was a well done movie.

Jul 29 - 09:18 AM

The Fox

What Does Da Foe Say?

Yes... it is the beast Spider-Man movie in history.

Nov 7 - 07:37 PM

Baurushan Jeyaseelan

Baurushan Jeyaseelan

not one of the worst...this is the worst!

Jul 29 - 10:16 AM

Ben S.

Ben Strasz

Really? Worse than Catwoman? Worse than both Ghost Rider movies? Worse than the Fantastic Four movies? Worse than Elektra? Worse than Jonah Hex? If you think that this movie, which was actually decent, is worse than those piles of trash, then you either have major taste issues, or haven't seen enough comic book movies to know any better.

Jul 29 - 11:01 AM

Himanshu Pant

Himanshu Pant

Spider-man can beat batman easily.
Batman is just a rich guy.
He does not have any superpowers.
Bane is looking like a masked joker.

Jul 30 - 08:58 AM

This comment has been removed.

Eric Pierson

Eric Pierson

HP, you really need a hug.

Aug 1 - 10:59 PM

bob  j.

bob jones

1. spider-man isn't better than batman just because he has 'super powers', which seems to be your only defense.
2. lizard is generic and not intimidating. bane is awesome and intimidating.
3. tdkr is only 30 minutes longer than tasm, and you barely feel it.
4. that doesn't make it better.
5. how does that make the movie better at all?
6. first off, why are you mentioning batman begins if you're trying to defend tasm against tdkr? second, batman begins wasn't a huge flop, it is the 118th highest grossing movie of all time in the U.S. third, in the U.S., the dark knight is the 4th highest grossing movie of all time, tdkr is the 6th highest, and tasm is the 59th highest.
btw i know i look stupid arguing on the internet, just had to get that out of my system

Sep 15 - 07:46 PM

Geórgia Cordeiro

Geórgia Cordeiro

Completely disagree. This is the best movie of this franchise to date. Garfield is Spidey and his chemistry with Stone is amazing. But I do want the next script to step it up to match the quality of the characters and the cast.

Jul 31 - 01:24 PM

Andrew Boyce

Andrew Boyce

i havnt seen tdkr but in my opinion the amazing spiderman is the best superhero reboot ever and to say its the worst comic book adapations is stupid
Fatastic four Ghost rider GREEN LANTERN etc

Jul 31 - 09:34 PM

bob  j.

bob jones

dont forget Hulk by ang lee. and ghost rider 2

Aug 2 - 03:53 AM

Andrew Boyce

Andrew Boyce

i forgot those thanks

Aug 10 - 07:42 PM

Musa Giwa

Musa Giwa

David Nusair you should stick to your day job. As a critic you suck. No sense what so ever in what you've written, it's one of the laziest pieces of writing I've ever had the displeasure of reading.

Aug 2 - 04:41 PM

Nekrobomb Jones

Nekrobomb Jones

Yeah, I just saw the film and he writes like I think not seeing it. Once you see it, you feel very different. I love Sam Raimi, but they kind of screwed up the plot putting characters in the wrong places. At the moment Gwen is where she should be. The Lizard was set up, but never used (like in Tim Burton's Batman with Harvey Dent). Here he is fully realized and finally we touch on Peter's parents. If anything, this film is more Batman than the new Batman. Martin Sheen was a perfect Uncle Ben, and didn't hit you over the head with a catchphrase. The Green Goblin is set up slightly and maybe Gwen will die. If so, they have me. 500 days of Summer is awesome as well, check it out. Lazy review? Absolutely. I wonder if this guy even saw the film. Only complain, Denis Leary's death scene. I wasn't sure if he was even dying (spoiler alert, ha ha ha)

Oct 31 - 10:57 AM

Find us on:                 
Help | About | Jobs | Critics Submission | Press | API | Licensing | Mobile