News » Columns » Weekly Ketchup » Weekly Ketchup: Oscar noms, and Tom & Jerry

Weekly Ketchup: Oscar noms, and Tom & Jerry

Plus casting news for Abigail Breslin and Keira Knightley

The Oscar nominations obviously dominated the news this week, but there's also a few new animated movies to report, lots of casting and the word on what the director of 1998's Godzilla might be doing next.


#1 OSCAR'S MAGIC TRICK: MAKING THE DARK KNIGHT'S BEST PICTURE NOMINATION DISAPPEAR

The Academy announced this year's Oscar nominations yesterday morning, and several excellent movies were honored, but this year, I felt like there were more missing nominees than the last few years, which this Variety piece does a nice job of summarizing. The most obvious snub is that The Dark Knight did not receive a Best Picture nomination, despite being nominated in eight other categories. I honestly thought the Academy would "get it", but I guess the presence of Batman in the movie was just a hurdle they couldn't get past. If Christian Bale's character had been, say, an ex-cop-turned-vigilante who didn't wear a mask and a cape, I think The Dark Knight would have just not have gotten a Best Picture nomination, but nominations for Director and Screenplay as well, as it is a "crime movie" on par with the best movies by the likes of Scorsese and Coppola. The other movie I felt the Academy didn't honor properly was The Wrestler, with had a beautiful song by Bruce Springsteen, artful direction by Darren Aronofsky, a great script, and was one of the five best movies of 2008. It seems to me that the Academy rewarded some movies this year for being "Oscar movies", rather than for being the best of the year, regardless of their subject matter. Ten years from now, will people remember and still be watching The Reader and Frost/Nixon, or will they remember The Wrestler and The Dark Knight?

Getting past that issue, here's a rundown of the nominees in a way that always interests me, by number of nominations. The top 10 nominated movies are: The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (13), Slumdog Millionaire (10), The Dark Knight (8), Milk (8), WALL-E (6), Doubt (5), Frost/Nixon (5), The Reader (5), Changeling (3) and Revolutionary Road (3). I always think it's interesting when Best Picture nominees aren't in the top 5 list of nominees, because you'd think that if a movie was so great as to be the Best Picture, it would come along with more than 4 other nominations in other categories. Of course, one can argue that the sum of a movie can be greater than the whole of its parts, and the only way non-Best-Picture nominees can be nominated in other categories is if those films don't "sweep" the other categories.


#2 TOM & JERRY: AN ITCHY & SCRATCHY MOVIE CAN'T BE FAR OFF

In the conversation about violence in movies, when people point out how violent many cartoons have always been, they are very often referring to Tom & Jerry, who started finding creative ways to kill, maim and disfigure each other nearly 70 years ago in 1940. Somehow, however, I think we can expect their next big project to be toned down just a bit, as Variety reports that Warner Bros is eyeing Tom & Jerry as a way to "create their own Alvin & the Chipmunks-like family franchise." As CGI characters in a live-action world, Tom & Jerry will star in an origin story of how they first meet before getting lost in Chicago, and the definitive cat and mouse rivals have to team up to find their way home. A new screenwriter, Eric Gravning, has been hired to work on Tom & Jerry, which is being produced by Warner Bros' Dan Lin (Terminator Salvation: The Future Begins, Sherlock Holmes), and will probably be destroying one of your cherished childhood memories by 2011 or so.


#3 TIM BURTON'S FIRST MOVIE TO FINALLY HIT THE BIG SCREEN

Screenwriter John August (Big Fish, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory) has been hired by Disney to adapt Tim Burton's first movie, Frankenweenie, as a full-length stop-motion animation feature. Like the original short, Frankenweenie will also be in black and white, and it will also be in 3-D. Tim Burton is producing, and much of the same crew that worked on Corpse Bride will work on Frankenweenie, but it is unclear who will be directing. Frankenweenie is the story of a man who tries to bring his dog back from the dead after it's hit by a car. Disney is planning to release Frankenweenie in 2011. John August has also found other new work as the new writer of the Preacher movie, which will be directed by Sam Mendes (American Beauty, Revolutionary Road), based upon the comic book series by Garth Ennis about a disillusioned reverend on a quest to find God to hold Him accountable for his actions, or lack thereof.


#4 ISAAC ASIMOV'S CLASSIC FOUNDATION TO BE DIRECTED BY THAT 10,000 B.C. GUY

Thursday night, Columbia Pictures won a heated auction for the rights to Isaac Asimov's revered Foundation Trilogy, a science fiction epic spread across hundreds of years, many short stories and novels, and a lot more books than just a trilogy. The other major suitors for Foundation were 20th Century Fox and Warner Bros, who are still cooling down after their Watchmen legal battles. Columbia bought Foundation as a likely project for director Roland Emmerich, whose history with "big" movies is spotty: he can claim success with Independence Day and The Day After Tomorrow, but he also directed the 1998 debacle that was Godzilla, and last year's anachronism-filled blockbuster wannabe, 10,000 B.C. Roland Emmerich is currently working on his latest apocalyptic epic, 2012, which is now scheduled for a release in November, 2009, bumped back four months from July. The Foundation series is a bit complicated to thumbnail in a short article, but basically, it involves the future of mankind in outer space, and various attempts to keep the Galactic Empire from collapsing into decline. The books are extremely brainy and obtuse, but as a Roland Emmerich movie, it will probably be mostly about pew-pew-pew outer space dogfights and very large, loud explosions (in the vacuum of space).


#5 ABIGAIL BRESLIN TO PLAY A PRETTY FLOWER

With Hollywood's love affair lately with remakes, I'm glad to be able to report that the upcoming movie called The Wild Bunch is not a remake of the groundbreaking 1969 Sam Peckinpah western. It is however, a CGI animated family movie about talking wildflowers and other plants being attacked by evil, genetically mutated cornstalks. Abigail Breslin (Little Miss Sunshine) will provide the lead voice, with other voice actors to include Willie Nelson, Willem Dafoe, Elizabeth Hurley and Chris Klein. Willie Nelson's a good choice for this movie, no doubt, because whoever came up with the premise was probably smoking something Willie is very familiar with. The Wild Bunch will be the directorial debut of Douglas Wood, who was a story editor for TV's Tiny Toon Adventures, and is the first feature film from a new Israeli company called Animation Lab. Abigail Breslin also signed on for two other projects recently: costarring with Johnny Depp in the CGI animated movie, Rango, and as a young con artist living in a post-zombie-apocalyptic world in Zombieland, opposite Woody Harrelson.


#6 WITNESS THE RESURRECTION OF... JIM BELUSHI

Roman Polanski's (Chinatown, The Pianist) next film, The Ghost, was originally supposed to start filming a few months ago, but didn't, and so some recasting has been done. Tilda Swinton and Nicolas Cage are out, and in for Cage's lead role is Ewan McGregor. Other new cast members are Tom Wilkinson, Kim Cattrall, Olivia Williams and Jim Belushi, with Pierce Brosnan being the only one left of the first three characters announced. The Ghost is based upon a 2007 political novel by Robert Harris (Enigma, Fatherland) about a ghostwriter (McGregor) hired to help a former British Prime Minister (not so loosely inspired by Tony Blair) write his memoirs after the previous writer dies from drowning. I made Jim Belushi the headline for this story because I think it's interesting that the According to Jim star is being included in a movie that is, well, not his usual fare. It's sort of like if Kevin James got cast in the next Mike Leigh movie. Filming starts on February 4th in Berlin.


#7 KEIRA KNIGHTLEY AND COLIN FARRELL PARKED ON LONDON BOULEVARD

Colin Farrell and Keira Knightley have signed on to star in London Boulevard, the directorial debut of screenwriter William Monahan (The Departed, Kingdom of Heaven). Based upon a 2001 novel by Irish writer Ken Bruen, London Boulevard is about a South London criminal who gets out of jail and tries to go straight by becoming a handyman working for a reclusive young actress who happens to fancy him. But then, things, of course, go horribly wrong. Filming starts this summer in and around London.




#8 ARE YOU TRYING TO SEDUCE ME, MRS... CHER?

37-year-old Johnny Knoxville and 62-year-old Cher are signed to star in The Drop Out, a college sex comedy about a professional student who gets involved with his much older neighbor. Finally getting kicked out of his parents' house, Knoxville's character moves in with Cher's neighbor character so he can keep living the lifestyle to which he is accustomed, but also in the mix is her son, who is looking for a father figure despite Knoxville being his same age. Family Guy writer Ricky Blitt will be making his directorial debut with The Drop Out, and also wrote 2005's The Ringer, which also starred Johnny Knoxville. Cher has already started doing press for the project, which starts filming this summer, recently talking it up on Ellen , refering to The Drop Out as "something you wait for your whole life" and "really crazy."


#9 SIX FEET UNDER AND WEST WING STARS GOING TO THE CABIN IN THE WOODS

Following the success of Cloverfield, that film's writer, Drew Goddard (TV's Lost and Buffy the Vampire Slayer) is making his debut with a horror film called The Cabin in the Woods, the details of which are being kept a tight secret. What's not a secret is that it was written by Buffy the Vampire Slayer creator Joss Whedon, and that the first two cast members to be announced are Bradley Whitford (The West Wing) and Richard Jenkins (the ghost dad from Six Feet Under), who will play "white collar coworkers." All that we know about The Cabin in the Woods, really, is that it is aiming to knock that particular sub-genre of horror, movies set in cabins in the woods (like The Evil Dead and Cabin Fever) out of the park, and that by having a more adult cast than just a bunch of good-looking 20-somethings pretending to be teenagers, a different tone from most of today's horror movies is suggested. Filming starts in the spring of 2009, with MGM already scheduling a release date of February 5th, 2010.


#10 SEAN PENN TO NOT FEAR THE REAPER?

Promoting his newest movie, Brooklyn's Finest, at Sundance this week, director Antoine Fuqua (Training Day) revealed to ComingSoon.net that he hopes his next movie will be a mob biopic, Scarpa, for which he is in talks with Sean Penn to star. Scarpa is based on the life of Gregory Scarpa, Sr., AKA The Grim Reaper, who was the chief enforcer for New York's Colombo crime family in the 1970s and 1980s. First off, if you take a look at the Wikipedia page for Scarpa, I think it's sort of obvious that Sean Penn looks absolutely nothing like the man, so I've got to think that maybe Penn's role would be an F.B.I. agent or something. But, Penn does like to challenge himself, so maybe he really put on a massive black mustache and try to sound Italian.

Playboy Slim

Playboy Slim on 01-24-2009 12:30 PM

"The Dark Knight" argumeny has been milked for everything it's worth. Yes, it will "The Dark Knight" and "The Wrestler" that will be remembered, not "The Reader". Saying it for the millionth time isn't going change it.

"Tom & Jerry"? Just shoot me in the ****ing face now. "London Blvd." sounds good. And that's all I got.

jokerboy1991

jokerboy1991 on 01-24-2009 01:42 PM

Yep, 20 years down the road The Wrestler will be looked at as a classic, and The Reader will be looked at as just another period piece. I still can't believe Wanted got as many nominations as The Wrestler. Its a little weird that Belushi is the new Polanski movie but I actually don't think he's that bad, hopefully Polanski delivers on the goods this time (Chinatown is my all time fav). "it is a "crime movie" on par with the best movies by the likes of Scorsese and Coppola", Greg, please tell me you are not comparing TDK to The Godfather and Goodfellas!?!?!

greg_dean_schmitz

greg_dean_schmitz on 01-24-2009 05:11 PM

Okay, perhaps I was dabbling a bit in hyperbole with that one line... The Dark Knight is no Godfather. Though I still feel pretty comfortable swapping out Coppola for Michael Mann. TDK had a very "Heat"-ish feel, yeah?

Playboy Slim

Playboy Slim on 01-24-2009 05:32 PM

What if he is comparing them? It might be better than many of the films they've done. It is better! HA! I said "The Dark Knight" is better than the best films ever. Because *narrowly dodges bullets* Joe Pesci , Marlon Brando, and Heath Ledger is what it comes down to and *doges shoe* Heath *doges gernade* Ledger is the best. All of them are gods *doges flaming arrows* among crime films for many reasons, but it's the big performance that I remember. I'm ready for the verbal beating.





jokerboy1991

jokerboy1991 on 01-24-2009 09:59 PM

LOL, Ledawg are you really trying to piss me off?!? Because if you want to play rough, I'll play rough! But I don't want to, so yep! TDK is an awesome movie but I do think its flawed, TDK will go down as a classic for a lot of people and will be in famous for a long time. Sure I think it was snubbed, and is better then Frost/Nixon, Milk, and The Reader. Those are very good movies but I still feel like they didn't bring any originality to the table like The Dark Knight and Wall-e. I still do think though that The Wrestler was a HUGE snub. Also Benincio Del Toro was fantastic in CHE which I think everyone should see despite its flaws.

Playboy Slim

Playboy Slim on 01-24-2009 12:32 PM

*argumeny is argument. Damn keyboard.

Random_Jake

Random_Jake on 01-24-2009 01:42 PM

The Dark Knight getting passed over was inevitable but Wall-E was definitely better than all their choices.

MuertoMalo

MuertoMalo on 01-24-2009 02:42 PM

Tom & Jerry? This is bad.

kodie131

kodie131 on 01-24-2009 02:50 PM

The Wrestler is the most underrated movie of the year. I saw it last night and was completely blown away, especially by the leading performances from Mickey Rourke, Marisa Tomei, and Evan Rachel Wood. RT is right, years from now people will remember The Wrestler as a classic. Very sad to see it isn't up for best picture.

Zaraki

Zaraki on 01-24-2009 03:14 PM

I enjoyed the tom and jerry cartoons when i was a little kid, but come on... Get some original ideas hollywood. T&J won't translate to the big screen, and it will flop.

tomwaitsjrHAPPYICONOCLAST

tomwaitsjrHAPPYICONOCLAST on 01-24-2009 03:24 PM

I am also sad Wrestler isn't in the best picture nom. I'm not surprised that the Academy screwed up best song for about the 20th time in a row. Bruce Springsteen's song is awesome.

Aronofsky's the Wrestler reminded me, at times, of video games such as CALL OF DUTY (which is even mentioned in the film) Whereas the camera is just behind the actor. It was marvelously done.



Erik

Erik on 01-24-2009 04:40 PM

Please, for the love of god, no Tom and Jerry CGI.

tomwaitsjrHAPPYICONOCLAST

tomwaitsjrHAPPYICONOCLAST on 01-24-2009 05:04 PM

Once Alvin and the Chipmunks made money, (I didn't see it, but heard it was awful) you knew it was just a matter of time for Tom and Jerry. Remember, they already did Rockeye and Bullwinkle. . . (Probably Robert Deniro's saddest moment of lechery).

I want to see a full film version of Woody Woodpecker vs. George W. Bush. It will be great. Woody destroying everything around the ex-President. . . the more Woody destroys, the more W. seeks solace in the bottle, and in a cocaine induced Frenzy, starts making Woody Woodpecker laugh noises and banging his head on random doors in the neighborhood until taken away in the comfy white room for which he'll stay his remaining years. . . laughing . . . laughing. . . and banging his head.

Playboy Slim

Playboy Slim on 01-24-2009 05:51 PM

Damn it Greg! You posted your comment at the exact same time I did! Well, I was speaking for myself anyway.

If "Tom & Jerry" could give a huge backstory, with them being former lovers, but an affair with Snagglepuss ruined their relationship, so now it's one against another. Or a gang war. Or something... this movies gonna hurt. Can't wait for Ronald Emmerich's next film, I'm surprised it's not "Tom & Jerry". Eeekk, "10,000 BC" is a huge snub. Seriously, Emmerich ain't no Peter Jackson, or even Micheal Bay.

vashfanatic

vashfanatic on 01-24-2009 05:56 PM

Didn't they already do an awful Tom and Jerry movie?
http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/tom_and_jerry_the_movie/
(and, for kicks, check out: http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/nostalgia-critic/1499-tom-and-jerry-the-movie)

Mr. Dufresne

Mr. Dufresne on 01-24-2009 06:03 PM

Please, please leave Tom and Jerry alone. Please don't tarnish the image of some of the greatest cartoon shorts of all time.

martinscorsese25

martinscorsese25 on 01-24-2009 06:30 PM

i think Milk is a little overrated. The only scenes i found moving there are when Sean Penn is talking to a gay boy on the phone. Other than that, well, I didn't really felt sad when Milk was killed. But Penn is really good in the film and he deserves the nod. not the win though, Rourke for me is the BEST of the year. Penn was more of an impersonation(which was very entertaining), but Rourke's performance hit me so hard.

also, for me Frost/Nixon was very entertaining but i think the performances are the only ones that should be nominated.

bottom line. my best picture nominees


The Dark Knight
(10 or 20 years from now. I want my kids to see on the cover of the anniversary eddition of the DVD "11 Oscar Nominations including Best Picture, Best Director and Best Adapted Screenplay, And Winner of 5 including Best Supporting Actor Heath Ledger")

Curious Case of Benjamin Button
(yeah i know the script was mediocre, but you got to acknowledge the technical achievements of the film, it elevates the movie. 20 years from now, people will still be amazed on how this film played a part to the evolution of digital effects)

The Wrestler
( This film had a huge flaw, *SPOILER* the ending wasnt quite right. i'm not saying i want a happy ending, but the ending was just... "cut". Still Rourke's performance, which deserves an oscar, and his ladies Tomei and Wood are an achievement themselves. also the way the director shot the movie was inspiring to struggling directors. Not as big as the other movies this year but it is on par with the Best Movies of the year)

WALL-E
(i want to put Gran Torino here. Saw it last night and i have to say i love the film, but i think the film will only be remembered as Clint's last acting gig. WALL-E on the other hand is great achievement not just for animation, but for a film in general. People will still watch this for many many years)

Slumdog Millionaire
(Still havent seen it because it hadnt yet opened to a theatre here in the Philippines. But seeing that it wins every award then it deserves to be in the best picture list)


ps. i havent yet watch 'The Reader'. based on what the people here at RT are saying. I think it is pretty much a "RENT IT" only movie.

~*Admiral Snowstorm*~

~*Admiral Snowstorm*~ on 01-24-2009 07:05 PM

Actually, pretty much everybody's already forgotten The Wrestler. Everybody remembers the song and Rourke, but the movie itself is already fading fast from the minds of the public. Especially now since The Dark Knight was robbed or whatever.

Jake007

Jake007 on 01-24-2009 08:29 PM

I would agree that The Wrestler will certainly not be remembered for decades to come, however, neither will The Reader.

Frost/Nixon fascinated me. Being someone who is very interested in politics, but was not in existence during the Nixon era, this was a film that I "ate up" as it were. Very educational, and very moving. I think this is going to make a great addition to the "Nixon portfolio" but I can not say that it will be remembered as a must see in twenty years.

I was sad that Wall-E was passed up. The academy once again shows that they can not respect an animated movie simply because it's animated. Then we have Milk which was clearly nominated purely due to it's "sensitive subject matter" (Brokeback Mountain anyone?).

I'm a little tired of the academy's politics.

Good to see that Hollywood will be tarnishing another classic in the form of Tom & Jerry soon. Oi..

mjprogue

mjprogue on 01-24-2009 09:23 PM

Are people still talking about Dark Knight? Come on...the movie was mediocre at best!

I'm actually surprised it isn't up for best picture simply because it is so rare to see any of the best movies of the year get nominated. I was certain the Ledger factor would get it the sympathy vote (you know...like it got it so much box office).

Honestly though...you guys think folks will still be talking about Dark Knight in ten years? The fanboys maybe...but most people will have forgotten all about it.

Iceman Cometh

Iceman Cometh on 01-24-2009 09:54 PM

The Wrestler was a movie with fantastic performances, but that's really it. The 2 acting noms it got are very deserving, but I'm not surprised to see it not nominated for best pic or director.

SlainOne

SlainOne on 01-24-2009 10:39 PM

If I hear someone say "fanboy" one more time, I'm going to puke. Anyone who praises TDK is immediately a fanboy, and is one that was sucked in by the hype, somehow looked down upon lately. I liked the movie. But, there are many other movies I like as well, and there are better movies.

The Dark Knight was a good movie. It was GOOD. Do I think it will be remembered 10 years from now? Yes. And this is because, many people went to see it, and many loved it. It's truly a classic of our time, with deep storytelling and a great story/visuals.

Overlook all of the people that are saying "THIS IS THE GREATEST MOVIE OF ALL TIME" and "IT'S BETTER THAN EVERYTHING THAT HAS EVER EXISTED." And look at it for what it is, a Good, fun experience.

pinkincide

pinkincide on 01-24-2009 11:24 PM

FANBOY

Random_Jake

Random_Jake on 01-24-2009 11:28 PM

and people wonder why the oscars are losing popularity. Instead of nominating glorified porn flicks for best picture why not nominate something interesting to the general public.......

Flap s.

Flap s. on 01-25-2009 04:48 AM

The Weinsteins did a good job in stealing another oscar spot. The Reader has 60% rating and it's up for Best Picture, are you ****ing kidding me?

The Dark Knight is number 2 as the most grossing movie ever, it has around 98% rating and it gets ignored by the oscars? That piece of crap titanic movie does the same thing and gets nominated for a million of oscars. That is just plain wrong.

It's all politics and bribs! Go Weinsteins.....

What's Hot On RT

Critics Consensus
Critics Consensus

Journey 2 Not Worth the Trip

Luis Guzman
Luis Guzman

What are his 10 best movies ever?

<em>Amazing Spider-Man</em>
Amazing Spider-Man

See the all-new action-packed trailer!

The Avengers!
The Avengers!

Five new Marvelous pictures

Help | About | Jobs | Newsletter | Critics Submission | API | Licensing | Blog | Developers | Mobile