This is the problem when you're an exceptional, visionary filmmaker. When you give people something extraordinary, they expect it every time. Anything short of that feels like a letdown.
she prefer battleship & snow white and gave them a fresh review...wtf????!!
Jul 16 - 02:41 PM
Ever heard of an opinion, personal preference, taste? Everyone's is different.
Me I love The Lord of The Rings Trilogy. The Return of The King is my all time favorite movie, followed by The Dark Knight. I thought Battleship was an okay movie, not good but okay. I liked Righteous Kill though most critics hated it, I liked all the Transformers movies. I liked the Fantastic Four movies. I didn't really care for Drive. I loved Leon The Professional. I liked Spider-man 3.
Everyone has their own personal opinion man get over it. List some movies you like and I bet you the other people in here who are defending The Dark Knight rises, who hated the movies she liked(even though you guys may not have seen all of them) will disagree with you on you. That's just how it is, we are individual beings, we are Human not some Freaking hive mind.
Jul 16 - 02:53 PM
A lot of people dont mind her giving an opinion its just the way she rated the film. Because it wasnt as good as the Dark knight she gave it a rotten review.
Jul 16 - 04:10 PM
Battleship is fresh along with huger games?
Dark knight rises and BRAVE are rotten?
Jul 16 - 02:45 PM
From the negative reviews (and even some positive) it seems like the films plot is all over the place and there are too many characters. Sounds like Spider-Man 3. But, this may be only a minor issue. I will wait and see the film.
Jul 16 - 02:46 PM
Rock of ages is fresh?
someone who gives magic mike a perfect 4 stars and a fresh review for battleship should be ignored.
Jul 16 - 02:47 PM
You mean Magic Mike the movie that's certified Fresh on this site? I'm sure there are other critics who gave Magic Mike a positive review that gave(and will give) this a positive review. So do they lose credibility for that as well, they didn't give a positive score to a movie you hated(if you even watched it all)
Jul 16 - 02:59 PM
Snow white is fresh?
All of you should start posting on the RT forum :) We need new blood.
She is fully entitled to her own opinion the film and this is a well written review for those that took the time to actually read it. BTW, she gave 3 out of 4 stars to Magic Mike not 4 out of 4 as has been reported by just about every other fanboy on here.
Jul 16 - 02:48 PM
what about giving a fresh review for battleship??
Jul 16 - 02:51 PM
Once again, she is entitled to her own opinion. In both reviews she stated what she liked and didn't like about each film. She was disappointed by this one and Battleship lived up to low expectations. That's pretty fair to me.
Jul 16 - 02:54 PM
That's really not how reviews are supposed to work. It's not on a "scale of what you were expecting" but rather on a scale of quality.
So you can't say Battleship is 4 stars cause it's exactly what I expected...instead you compare it to true 4 star movies and then think where it would rank (2 at best)
Thus in reviewing Rises, it shouldn't be about whether or not it surpasses/equaled dark knight, but rather is it a great movie on it's own merits
Jul 16 - 03:01 PM
Wanderlust is fresh?
This means war is fresh?
Its funny how 64 critics gave Battleship a fresh, yet those that rate TDKR with a positive will not lose any credibility in the minds of the fools who degrade Christy for the same thing. Silly? Incredibly idiotic is more like it
Jul 16 - 02:52 PM
This comment has been removed.
Rottentomatoes lack of interest in deleting sexist comments means only one thing: they simply don't care. After all, they remove threatening comments
Jul 16 - 02:58 PM
but is he wrong? heck...part of her "problem" with Bane is that they didn't use Tom Hardy's amazing sex appeal; and she mentioned how sexy the men were in avengers, and the magic mike stuff...
all I know is...if this woman is a professional film critic....I certainly could be (and a better one to boot)
Jul 16 - 03:04 PM
Very nicely put. This mob is really depressing. I don't know why I am paying them even this much attention.
Jul 16 - 02:57 PM
Sometimes it's hard to look away. It's funny how RT bans Eric Snider for ironically pointing out the lunacy of these commenters, yet make very little effort to control their own site. Sometimes the truth hurts ...
Why would it matter? If they gave battleship fresh review that means that they don't need much to be happy so it's only natural to expect feom them to give fresh reviews to above average movies too.
Jul 16 - 03:00 PM
Her review is based on failed expectations. That in and of itself might explain why she gave Battleship a marginally fresh review. Figure it out ...
Jul 16 - 03:05 PM
This Means War (2012) " Having great-looking stars who have the added bonus of actually being able to act makes the noisy romp "This Means War" more tolerable than it ought to be." â?? Associated Press
Posted Feb 14, 2012
Colombiana is fresh?
Jul 16 - 02:49 PM
I liked that movie, but I also loved The Dark Knight,the same as you I'm sure. See that, difference in opinion. Learn what that means and grow up.
Jul 16 - 02:55 PM
Kung Fu panda 2 is rotten?
Jul 16 - 02:50 PM
This is just sad. Protip: there will be more negative reviews. No movie gets 100% anymore.
but...but...IZ NOLAN! :(
HE'Z GAWD! D:
She should be banned, she liked Crapship, so I hope everybody continue bitching on her
PROM is fresh?