The Man Who Knew Too Much (1956) - Rotten Tomatoes

The Man Who Knew Too Much (1956)




Critic Consensus: Remaking his own 1934 film, Hitchcock imbues The Man Who Knew Too Much with picturesque locales and international intrigue, and is helped by a brilliantly befuddled performance from James Stewart.

The Man Who Knew Too Much Trailers & Photos

Movie Info

The debate still rages as to whether Alfred Hitchcock's 1956 remake of The Man Who Knew Too Much is superior to his own original 1934 version. This two-hour remake (45 minutes longer than the first film) features more stars, a lusher budget, and the plaintive music of Bernard Herrmann (who appears on-camera, typecast as a symphony conductor). Though the locale of the opening scenes shifts from Switzerland to French Morocco in the newer version, the basic plot remains the same. American tourists James Stewart and Doris Day are witness to the street killing of a Frenchman (Daniel Gelin) they've recently befriended. Before breathing his last, the murder victim whispers a secret to Stewart (the Cinemascope lens turns this standard closeup into a truly grotesque vignette). Stewart knows that a political assassination will occur during a concert at London's Albert Hall, but is unable to tell the police: his son (a daughter in the original) has been kidnapped by foreign agents to insure Stewart's silence. The original script for Man Who Knew too Much was expanded and updated by John Michael Hayes and Angus McPhail. ~ Hal Erickson, Rovimore
Rating: PG (violence)
Genre: Mystery & Suspense, Classics
Directed By:
Written By: Angus MacPhail, Charles Bennett, John Michael Hayes
In Theaters:
On DVD: Mar 6, 2001
MCA Universal Home Video


James Stewart
as Dr. Benjamin 'Ben' M...
Doris Day
as Josephine Conway 'Jo...
Brenda De Banzie
as Lucy Drayton
Bernard Miles
as Edward Drayton
Ralph Truman
as Inspector Buchanan
Daniel Gélin
as Louis Bernard
Mogens Wieth
as Ambassador
Alan Mowbray
as Val Parnell
Hillary Brooke
as Jan Peterson
Christopher Olsen
as Hank McKenna
Reggie Nalder
as Rien the assassin
Richard Wattis
as Assistant Manager
Alix Talton
as Helen Parnell
Yves Brainville
as Police Inspector
Carolyn Jones
as Cindy Fontaine
Leo Gordon
as Chauffeur
Pat Aherne
as English Handyman
Louis Mercier
as French Police
Anthony Warde
as French Police
Lewis Martin
as Detective
Gladys Holland
as Bernard's Girlfriend
John O'Malley
as Uniformed Attendant
Peter Camlin
as Headwaiter
Albert Carrier
as French Policeman
Ralph Heff
as Henchman
Eric Snowden
as Special Branch Offic...
Edward Manouk
as French Waiter
Donald Lawton
as Desk Clerk
Patrick Whyte
as Special Branch Offic...
Allen Zeidman
as Assistant Manager
Frank Atkinson
as Workmen in Taxidermi...
Liddell Peddieson
as Workmen in Taxidermi...
Mayne Lynton
as Workmen in Taxidermi...
Patrick Aherne
as English Handyman
John Barrard
as Workmen in Taxidermi...
Alexis Bobrinskoy
as Foreign Prime Minist...
Janet Bruce
as Box Office Woman
Naida Buckingham
as Lady in the Audience
Clifford Buckton
as Sir Kenneth Clarke
Barbara Burke
as Girlfriend of the As...
Pauline Farr
as Ambassador's Wife
Harry Fine
as Edington
Wolfgang Preiss
as Aide to Foreign Prim...
George Howe
as Ambrose Chappell Sr.
Barry Keegan
as Patterson
Lloyd Lamble
as General Manager of A...
Enid Lindsey
as Lady Clarke
Janet Macfarlane
as Lady in Audience
Leslie Newport
as Inspector at Albert ...
Elsa Palmer
as Woman Cook
Arthur Ridley
as Ticket Collector
Alma Taylor
as Box Office Woman
Guy Verney
as Footman
Peter Williams
as Police Sergeant
Richard Wordsworth
as Ambrose Chappell Jr.
Bernard Herrmann
as The Orchestra Conduc...
Show More Cast

News & Interviews for The Man Who Knew Too Much

Critic Reviews for The Man Who Knew Too Much

All Critics (32) | Top Critics (4)

The film is uncharacteristically rigid and pious for Hitchcock; it feels more like a work of duty than conviction.

Full Review… | March 27, 2009
Chicago Reader
Top Critic

While drawing the footage out a bit long, he still keeps suspense working at all times and gets strong performances from the two stars and other cast members.

Full Review… | March 26, 2009
Top Critic

Starting slowly amid colourful but rather superfluous travelogue-style Moroccan footage, the film improves no end as it progresses.

Full Review… | June 24, 2006
Time Out
Top Critic

Even in mammoth VistaVision, the old Hitchcock thriller-stuff has punch.

Full Review… | March 25, 2006
New York Times
Top Critic

James Stewart is superb, and Bernard Miles and Brenda de Banzie make admirable adversaries.

Full Review… | July 29, 2014
Radio Times

Making marvellous use of settings and locations, Hitchcock treats the viewer to superbly choreographed set-pieces.

Full Review… | July 29, 2014
Total Film

Audience Reviews for The Man Who Knew Too Much

Top notch Hitchcock film. Gotta love the Cold War if Dorris Day's in it!

Christian C

Super Reviewer


This is Alfred Hitchcock doing a remake of one of his own films from early on in his career, and it's an interesting choice. The original was a slick, fun little thriller in its own right, and it really helped set the standard for the bulk of his career from then on.

This time around though, the telling of the storyt is a lot more polished, more artistic, and 45 minutes longer. Both films are great, but this one is the stronger of the two, but by how much is really up for debate.

It's the usual Hitch story: family goes on vacation, meets interesting people, and they get caught up in situations they aren't prepared for, and are in way over their heads. To top it off, the family can't do much since their son has been kidnapped as a way of threatening them, so not only do they need to try to stop an assassination, they need to get their son back.

As I said, this version is a lot more slick and polished. The sets and costumes look great ,AStewart is solid as always, and it's really ncie seeing Doris Day do something dramatic. The film is a mixture of suspense thriller and comedy, and it sometiems works well, but on the other hand, it is fairly uneven at times, and it seems like the film can't make up its mind about which tone to stick with. Also, the film si pretty dated with the rather un PC way characters deal with race and culture, but hey, that's the 50s for you.

Nevertheless, this is an exciting film that never fails to hold one's attention, and there's some excellent sequences, most notable being the 14 minute or so sequence at Royal Albert Hall that is done with no dialogue, and relies soley on music and visuals to build tension and suspense. It's a real showstopper.

All in all, this is required viewing for fans of the genre, and especially fans of Hitch. The original should also be checked out, as it's a real joy as well.

Chris Weber

Super Reviewer


One of my favorites from Hitchcock. Jimmy Stewart, as always, gives his all and the Vista Vision technology is used to it's fullest. Also, Doris Day puts in her best performance.

Graham Jones
Graham Jones

Super Reviewer

The Man Who Knew Too Much Quotes

– Submitted by João P (2 years ago)
– Submitted by Sarfaraz A (3 years ago)

Discussion Forum

Discuss The Man Who Knew Too Much on our Movie forum!