Three...Extremes (Saam gaang yi) (2004)
Average Rating: 6.8/10
Reviews Counted: 62
Fresh: 52 | Rotten: 10
This anthology contains brutal, powerful horror stories by three of Asia's top directors.
Average Rating: 6.5/10
Critic Reviews: 24
Fresh: 17 | Rotten: 7
This anthology contains brutal, powerful horror stories by three of Asia's top directors.
liked it
Average Rating: 3.7/5
User Ratings: 14,839
My Rating
Movie Info
Three Asian directors, from Hong Kong, Korea, and Japan, join forces to create an omnibus horror film, Three...Extremes. In Fruit Chan's "Dumplings," shot by Christopher Doyle, Mrs. Li (Miriam Yeung), a thirtysomething former actress with a philandering husband (Tony Leung) goes to visit Aunt Mei (Bai Ling), who sells the most expensive dumplings in Hong Kong. Mrs. Li knows about their rejuvenating powers, and she also knows about their unpleasant main ingredient, but after some initial nausea,
Watch It Now
ADVERTISEMENT
All Critics (64) | Top Critics (24) | Fresh (53) | Rotten (10) | DVD (3)
You can't believe what they're doing here.
Asian horror like the new Three ... Extremes beats an American film like Saw II at its own game.
'Cut,' Park's contribution to Three... Extremes
It's just three gifted filmmakers with vision to spare, daring you to go to their extremes.
One is haunting and wonderful, one is very good, and one spoils the fun.
Evokes a queasy fascination.
All the episodes are interesting and disturbing - perhaps too much so, without any clear reason for the audience to endure the suffering.
This anthology is a mixed bag.
A great horror anthology that thankfully restores my faith in the anthology gimmick that Hollywood completely diminished years ago...
The big revelation is a second DVD dedicated to Chan's amazing feature-length expansion of "Dumplings." Meatier and headier... [it's] superior to 3 Extremes itself.
Irregular como a maior parte das antologias, traz episódios longos a ponto de diluírem suas tramas, mas curtos demais para permitirem um bom desenvolvimento das situações e personagens. Mas é um esforço intrigante.
Un ensemble de films extrêmement intéressant à explorer, mais chacun pour des raisons bien distinctes.
This isn't for the weak of heart or stomach. This is disturbing stuff, people.
Things that are unique are interesting, and that can only be a plus to the stuck-up, artsy-fartsy horror film critic like myself.
These films give you a rush that most American horror movies don't, even if you're not entirely certain what's going on.
The general population may not get this one, but Asian cult cinema fanatics and some horror buffs will be absolutely thrilled.
Ninety percent...is fun, but that fun is compromised by the 10 percent that isn't %u2013 i.e., the conclusions.
Takes the tension to an extreme by deliberately trying to shock the audience's sensibility
A satisfying trio of twisted tales.
An instantly memorable, at times squirm-inducing, assemblage as likely to take your breath away as it is to trigger the gag reflex.
Audience Reviews for Three...Extremes (Saam gaang yi)
"Three..Extremes" an offering from the dark underworld of Asian horror is one such film. This collaboration of film-makers from three different countries tells three different stories, all approximately 40 minutes in length, all exhibiting different levels of "Disturbing"!
Since we are talking about three disparate stories here, it is only fair that each be reviewed separately.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The first tale of terror comes from Hong Kong, an absolute shocker named "Dumplings", written by Lillian Lee and directed by Fruit Chan. This one goes straight for your jugular with its utterly disgusting theme revolving around a certain Mrs. Li and a certain Aunt Mei. Mrs. Li (Miriam Yeung) is an aging ex-actress going through a supposed midlife crisis and an unhappy marriage. Desperate to rejuvenate herself and regain her lost youth, she visits Aunt Mei (Bai Ling..superb!) who claims to have a secret recipe for some special "dumplings" that are supposed to give the partakers the ability to stay young. Only the "secret" of the recipe is revolting enough for anyone to lose their appetite...
Fruit Chan directs very well and manages to succeed in his obvious goal of freaking the viewer out with his in-your-face display of gross-out material with some cringe-inducing special effects and sound effects. He builds the story to a shocking yet satisfying climax in a steady pace and subjects us to some highly repulsive images on the way. All said and done, this segment is a work of shimmering originality from Fruit Chan, who clearly knows his art. "Dumplings" treads new grounds in depicting the far extent to which human beings can go to in order to fulfill their deepest, darkest desires. Truly extreme....
Words of caution:
1)Not recommended for the squeamish.
2) Avoid watching over meals!
Score: 9/10.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The second segment, "Cut" (South Korea) is a "Saw"-like tale from the maker of the Godly Korean film "Oldboy", Park Chan-Wook. A frustrated and mentally unstable man acting as an extra in a successful film-maker's films kidnaps the film-maker and his wife and keeps them all tied up in their own house. He then forces the film-maker to be a part of his sadistic games or face the consequences, which include chopping off his pianist wife's fingers one by one over every five minutes that the film-maker refuses to comply. This story is akin to the cult thriller "Saw" or Park Chan-Wook's own "Oldboy" on many levels.
This segment is surprisingly the weakest of the three, in spite of the name of Park Chan-wook attached to it. It is one of those typical thrillers (wrongly dubbed as "horror") dealing with sadistic individuals depicting torture for the sake of torture yet there is no convincing basis for the tormentor's actions. In spite of being the weakest of the lot, this film succeeds on the directorial front with some taut storytelling, fantastic acting by Won-hie Lim and an aptly built claustrophobic atmosphere. The gore quotient is moderate, definitely lower than "Dumplings", and barring a couple of scenes, most of the blood spilling happens off-screen, so all you faint-hearts don't have to turn away every time.
Score: 8/10.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The last story is the icing on this bizarre cake..."Box" (Japan) by Takashi Miike is my most favourite of the three. This is a segment that would please lovers of atmospheric, surreal psychological thrillers as well as horror fans alike. It is about a young and beautiful writer named Kyoko who has recurring nightmares about being wrapped in a plastic sheet and being buried in a box in some unknown snow-clad region by a person whose face is not seen. "The dream always ends there.." as she reiterates. Is this dream somehow connected to her reality?
Takashi Miike directs with the kind of poetic finesse that would make David Lynch proud. "Box" is brilliantly executed with haunting imagery, minimalist sound effects, a terrifying sense of isolation, astounding background score, clubbed with a layered narrative. The strange, enigmatic storyline further adds to its many qualities. Kôichi Kawakami's cinematography is especially noteworthy in this...."Box" is the most beautiful looking segment of all! Almost like a painting coming to life! Kyoko Hasegawa as Kyoko, delivers a commendable performance here and looks beautiful as well. "Box" is devoid of extreme gore and relies primarily on mood and atmosphere. This is one exceptional quality of this segment that separates it from the previous two. "Box" clearly scores the most, 'cause it is easier for any film to create shock value from extremely disturbing situations and gore but it is much more difficult to hold an audience captive in its unsettling environment.
Score: 9.5/10.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Conclusion: "Three..extremes" is a solid entry from Asian cinema and a must-see for all film connoisseurs who like their films freaky and wicked!
Super Reviewer
Discussion Forum
There are no discussion threads for Three...Extremes (Saam gaang yi) yet.
What's Hot On RT
The Last Stand, Side Effects
Trailer for James Franco adaptation
Rachel McAdams' time travel romantic drama
Blockbusters ranked!
Featured on RT
- Ranking the Blockbusters with Summer Movie Scorecard 2013 0
- RT on DVD & Blu-Ray: The Last Stand and Side Effects 6
- Box Office Guru Wrapup: Star Trek Softer Than Expected at #1 77
- Weekly Ketchup: Will Smith to Star in Wild Bunch Remake? 37
- Critics Consensus: Star Trek Into Darkness is Certified Fresh 106
- Red Carpet Roundup: Star Trek Into Darkness Edition 0
- Video Interviews with Katie Aselton & Lake Bell of Black Rock 2
Top Headlines
-
Alex Gibney Talks We Steal Secrets: The Story of Wikileaks
0
-
RED Screenwriters Returning for RED 3
0
-
Brave's Brenda Chapman Talks Merida Makeover Controversy
0
-
Gold Discovers Spike Lee
1
-
Morgan Freemand and Diane Keaton Team Up for Life Itself
0
-
The Ten O'Clock People Are Counting on Chris Evans
0
-
Marton Csokas in Talks for The Equalizer
0










Top Critic
"Dumplings" - Directed by Fruit Chan
In Dumplings, an actress who has entered middle age and begun to lose the attention of her husband to an affair with a younger woman visits Aunt Mei, an old woman who still has the looks of her youth. Aunt Mei has a secret recipe that makes anyone look years younger, but such an unnatural benefit comes from a truly abominable source. I found Dumplings to be absolutely stomach-churning. A horror movie that doesn't even attempt to scare you, but actually tries (and succeeds, in my case) to horrifying you. Not for the squeamish. Even the sound effects eventually became almost more than I could bear. Disturbing and entertaining. - 4/5
"Cut" - Directed by Chan-wook Park
A talented director and his wife are taken captive by a murderous, utterly insane movie extra. Cut is darkly comedic, utterly absurd, and far more meta than the other movies in this collection. It took me a while to figure out whether I liked it or not, but by the end of the segment, I was won over. Like Dumplings, Cut isn't frightening in the conventional sense. Instead, it's flat-out zany (in a good way). - 3.5/5
"Box" - Directed by Takashi Miike
The most haunting of the three segments. Box is about a jealousy-fueled tragic accident involving two young sisters. The surviving sibling suffers from suffocating (literally) dreams and disturbing visions of her deceased sibling, even years later as an adult. Box is probably the creepiest of the three, and it has a psycho-sexual aspect to it that makes the whole thing even more unsettling. Definitely more of an atmospheric, "mood" movie than the other two. - 4/5
I liked all three segments, as well as the movie as a whole. I found Dumplings to be the most effective/entertaining, but I recommend the entire anthology. The three short films are not only memorable and very different from one another, but they're also fairly unique among the other horror movies that I've seen.
Overall - 4/5